Abstract:Second language (L2) learners' beliefs about the nature of language learning, specifically language mindsets, is a recent productive line of L2 research. Researchers argue that language mindsets are key factors for language learning success. However, the association between language mindsets and different language learning outcomes is inconsistent in the literature, and its overall effect remains unclear. The copious body of quantitative research instigates the need for a synthetic approach to capture an overall view of how language mindsets relate to several outcome variables (e.g., general language achievement, grammar, pragmatics, reading, speaking, and writing). Thus, the present study used multilevel meta-analysis to examine the overall effectiveness of the association between language mindsets and language learning outcomes and to examine to what extent this overall effectiveness might vary as a function of some moderators (i.e., age, proficiency level, and learning context). Through a systematic search and screening, we identified a total of 22 studies and 50 effect sizes ( n = 17,622 participants) on the correlation between language mindsets and different learning outcomes. The weighted average correlation between fixed language mindset and the language learning outcomes was found to be significantly negative but weak in size ( r = − 0.19). In contrast, the association between the growth language mindset and the learning outcomes was significantly positive but relatively moderate in size ( r = 0.26). These associations did not significantly vary as a function of moderating variables. These findings suggest that a higher level of growth language mindsets and a lower level of fixed mindset are important for learners' success in language learning. Pedagogical implications and suggestions for further research are discussed.

“Does My Teacher Believe I Can Improve?”: The Role of Meta-Lay Theories in ESL Learners’ Mindsets and Need Satisfaction

Whose Goal Emphases Play a More Important Role in ESL/EFL Learners’ Motivation, Self-Regulated Learning and Achievement?: Teachers’ or Parents’

Hong Kong Secondary Students’ Self-Regulated Learning Strategy Use and English Writing: Influences of Motivational Beliefs

Self-efficacy, Task Values and Growth Mindset: What Has the Most Predictive Power for Primary School Students’ Self-Regulated Learning in English Writing and Writing Competence in an Asian Confucian Cultural Context?

Teacher Mindsets Concerning the Malleability of Intelligence and the Appraisal of Achievement in the Context of Feedback

Measuring Language Mindsets and Modeling Their Relations With Goal Orientations and Emotional and Behavioral Responses in Failure Situations

Motivational factors underlying learner preferences for corrective feedback: Language mindsets and achievement goals

The Relationships among Chinese University EFL Learners’ Feedback-Seeking Behavior, Achievement Goals, and Mindsets

Breaking the vicious cycle of language anxiety: Growth language mindsets improve lower-competence ESL students’ intercultural interactions

Influence of teacher autonomy support in feedback on high school students' feedback literacy: the multiple mediating effects of basic psychological needs and intrinsic motivation

Who perceives more value of teacher feedback? Exploring the roles of college students’ possible second language selves and language learning strategies

A Multilevel Meta-analysis of Language Mindsets and Language Learning Outcomes in Second Language Acquisition Research

Mindsets as sources of L2 speaking anxiety and self-confidence: the case of international teaching assistants in the U.S.

ESL Teachers’ Perceptions of Effective Classroom Assessment Feedback

‘This is not what I need’: conflicting assessment feedback beliefs in a post-secondary institution in Hong Kong

Text quality and changing perceptions of teacher feedback and affective-motivational variables: a study with secondary EFL students

Domain-specific motivation and self-assessment practice as mechanisms linking perceived need-supportive teaching to student achievement

Metacognitive Beliefs and Strategies in Learning Chinese As a Foreign Language

STUDENTS’ BELIEFS ON CORRECTIVE FEEDBACK IN LANGUAGE LEARNING: BASIS FOR DEVELOPING HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS’ TYPOLOGY

The motivational paradox of feedback: teacher and student perceptions

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses