Abstract:Building ethical machines may involve bestowing upon them the emotional capacity to self-evaluate and repent on their actions. While reparative measures, such as apologies, are often considered as possible strategic interactions, the explicit evolution of the emotion of guilt as a behavioural phenotype is not yet well understood. Here, we study the co-evolution of social and non-social guilt of homogeneous or heterogeneous populations, including well-mixed, lattice and scale-free networks. Socially aware guilt comes at a cost, as it requires agents to make demanding efforts to observe and understand the internal state and behaviour of others, while non-social guilt only requires the awareness of the agents' own state and hence incurs no social cost. Those choosing to be non-social are however more sensitive to exploitation by other agents due to their social unawareness. Resorting to methods from evolutionary game theory, we study analytically, and through extensive numerical and agent-based simulations, whether and how such social and non-social guilt can evolve and deploy, depending on the underlying structure of the populations, or systems, of agents. The results show that, in both lattice and scale-free networks, emotional guilt prone strategies are dominant for a larger range of the guilt and social costs incurred, compared to the well-mixed population setting, leading therefore to significantly higher levels of cooperation for a wider range of the costs. In structured population settings, both social and non-social guilt can evolve and deploy through clustering with emotional prone strategies, allowing them to be protected from exploiters, especially in case of non-social (less costly) strategies. Overall, our findings provide important insights into the design and engineering of self-organised and distributed cooperative multi-agent systems.

The Research Progress and Trend of Guilt

5- 9 Year-old Children's Understanding Trait of Guilt Emotion

Research Review on Guanxi Theory

Guilt Leads to Enhanced Facing-the-viewer Bias

The nonverbal expression of guilt in healthy adults

Empathy and the Evolutionary Emergence of Guilt

When guilt works: a comprehensive meta-analysis of guilt appeals

Guilt Detection in Text: A Step Towards Understanding Complex Emotions

Guilt, Shame and Academic Misconduct

Eliciting guilt in virtual reality games: interplay of self-attribution, presence, and morality

From gratitude to injustice: Neurocomputational mechanisms of gratitude-induced injustice

A Libra in the Brain: Neural Correlates of Error Awareness Predict Moral Wrongness and Guilt Proneness

The Role of Guilt and Empathy on Prosocial Behavior

Exploring the Role of Anticipated Guilt on Cannabis Tourists’ Behavioural Intentions

Vortex of regret: How positive and negative coping strategies correlate with feelings of guilt

Predicting Emotional and Behavioral Reactions to Collective Wrongdoing: Effects of Imagined Versus Experienced Collective Guilt on Moral Behavior

Co-evolution of Social and Non-Social Guilt

Contrasting the semantic space of 'shame' and 'guilt' in English and Japanese

On the Systematic Status of Guiltless Event

Exploring the Factors of "AI Guilt" Among Students -- Are You Guilty of Using AI in Your Homework?

Cognitive neuroscience of social emotions and implications for psychopathology: Examining embarrassment, guilt, envy, and schadenfreude