Exploring the Factors of "AI Guilt" Among Students -- Are You Guilty of Using AI in Your Homework?

Cecilia Ka Yuk Chan

2024-07-15

Abstract:This study explores the phenomenon of "AI guilt" among secondary school students, a form of moral discomfort arising from the use of AI tools in academic tasks traditionally performed by humans. Through qualitative methodologies, the research examines the factors contributing to AI guilt, its social and psychological impacts, and its implications for educational practices. The findings revealed three main dimensions for AI guilt - perceived laziness and authenticity, fear of judgment, and identity and self-efficacy concerns. The findings suggest a need to redefine academic integrity and shift our mindset to reconsider what we should value in education. The study also emphasizes the importance of ethical guidelines and educational support and provides implications to help students navigate the complexities of AI in education, reducing feelings of guilt while enhancing learning outcomes.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address a psychological phenomenon prevalent among students—"AI guilt." Specifically, the study explores the following aspects:

1. **Definition and Background**:
- Definition of "AI guilt": The moral or ethical discomfort that individuals experience when using AI tools in academic, professional, or creative environments, due to concerns that such reliance may be viewed negatively by others or may feel insincere.
- Background: With the development of AI technology, algorithms can assist in tasks such as writing, creating presentations, and designing personalized assessments. The application of these technologies has elicited emotional responses from students when using AI tools.

2. **Research Objectives**:
- To explore current high school students' perceptions of AI guilt, investigate the reasons for these feelings, and examine their impact on educational practices.
- To understand how students morally cope with the use of AI tools, providing a basis for developing guidelines and policies that support the ethical integration of AI.

3. **Research Questions**:
- Influencing Factors: What factors lead to AI guilt among high school students?
- Socio-psychological Impact: What are the social and psychological impacts of AI guilt on students?
- Willingness to Use: How does AI guilt affect students' willingness to use AI tools in different types of academic tasks?
- Guidelines and Policies: What guidelines and educational policies should be developed to alleviate AI guilt and promote responsible use of AI?

Through these questions, the paper aims to reveal the psychological conflicts and ethical dilemmas students face with the increasing prevalence of AI technology and propose corresponding solutions to build a more ethically oriented and effective educational system.