Abstract:We assessed the reptile and amphibian community at 54 sites spanning four habitat types in a fragmented landscape in Costa Rica. Our study revealed that small forest patches and corridors play an important role in herpetofauna conservation, as they support a similar richness, abundance, and community composition to large forest preserves. We also found that while species richness increases in patches with a higher proportion of edge habitat, the forest‐specialist species decrease in these complexly shaped patches, indicating a need to consider specific taxa when setting conservation goals. Habitat loss and fragmentation are the greatest threats to reptiles and amphibians (herpetofauna) around the globe, but especially in the Neotropics where high diversity and ongoing land‐use change coincide. Persistence of biodiversity in fragmented systems relies both on characteristics of habitat patches, and on the permeability of the landscape that separates the patches (the "matrix"). We sought to understand: (a) how the herpetofauna community differs between forest reserves, patches, corridors, and matrices, and (b) the landscape characteristics that increase suitability of a habitat patch. We conducted herpetofauna surveys in patches, corridors, matrices, and preserves (54 total sites) in a fragmented landscape in Costa Rica for three seasons. We recorded 1663 individuals of 52 species. We found that the herpetofauna community differed, and had lower richness and abundance, in the matrix compared to the other three habitat types. Patches and corridors supported a similar community to the forest preserves, demonstrating the conservation value of small forest remnants. Water body presence was an important predictor of richness and abundance in both patches and matrices. While total richness increased in patches with more edge, this was driven by the response of generalist species, whereas the prime indicator species of forest preserves decreased in patches with complex shapes. The differing response to landscape characteristics between specialist and generalist species demonstrates the importance of considering specific taxa when setting conservation goals, rather than using richness measures alone. Our findings can help guide preservation of forest fragments to optimize biodiversity conservation in mixed forest‐pastoral landscapes. in Spanish is available with online material. RESUMEN La pérdida y fragmentación del hábitat son las mayores amenazas para los reptiles y anfibios (herpetofauna) en todo el mundo, pero especialmente en el Neotrópico, donde coinciden la alta diversidad y el cambio continuo en el uso de la tierra. La persistencia de la biodiversidad en sistemas fragmentados depende tanto de las características de los parches de hábitat como de la permeabilidad del paisaje que separa los parches (la "matriz"). Buscamos comprender: (a) Cómo la comunidad de herpetofauna difiere entre reservas forestales, parches, corredores y matrices, y (b) Las características del paisaje que aumentan la idoneidad de un parche de hábitat. Realizamos estudios de herpetofauna en parches, corredores, matrices y reservas (54 sitios en total), en un paisaje fragmentado en Costa Rica durante tres temporadas, en donde registramos 1663 individuos de 52 especies. Descubrimos que la comunidad de herpetofauna difería y tenía menor riqueza y abundancia en la matriz en comparación con los otros tres tipos de hábitat. Parches y corredores sustentaron una comunidad similar a las reservas forestales, lo que demuestra el valor de conservación de los pequeños remanentes de bosque. La presencia de cuerpos de agua fue un predictor importante de riqueza y abundancia tanto en parches como en matrices. Si bien la riqueza total aumentó en parches con más bordes, esto fue impulsado por la respuesta de especies generalistas, mientras que las especies indicadoras principales de reservas forestales disminuyeron en parches con formas complejas. La diferente respuesta a las características del paisaje entre especies especialistas y generalistas demuestra la importancia de considerar taxones específicos al establecer objetivos de conservación, en lugar de utilizar medidas de riqueza únicamente. Nuestros hallazgos pueden ayudar a guiar la preservación de fragmentos de bosque para optimizar la conservación de la biodiversidad en paisajes mixtos de bosque y pastoreo.

Habitat loss over six decades accelerates regional and local biodiversity loss via changing landscape connectance

Use of long-term data to evaluate loss and endangerment status of Natura 2000 habitats and effects of protected areas

Ecosystem decay exacerbates biodiversity loss with habitat loss

Connectedness of habitat fragments boosts conservation benefits for butterflies, but only in landscapes with little cropland

Long-term species loss and homogenization of moth communities in Central Europe

Habitat amount modulates biodiversity responses to fragmentation

Anthropogenic climate and land-use change drive short- and long-term biodiversity shifts across taxa

Higher trophic levels and species with poorer dispersal traits are more susceptible to habitat loss on island fragments

Global effects of land use on local terrestrial biodiversity

Habitat Fragmentation Affects Richness—A View Through a Metacommunity Lens

Habitat isolation diminishes potential of self-organised pattern formation to promote local diversity in metacommunities

Rate and extent of genetic diversity loss under non-equilibrium scenarios of habitat loss

Landscape-scale forest loss as a catalyst of population and biodiversity change

Complex patch geometries maximize species richness at the expense of forest specialists

From habitat decline to collapse: a spatially explicit approach connecting habitat degradation to destruction

Complex nonmonotonic responses of biodiversity to habitat destruction

Genetic diversity loss in the Anthropocene will continue long after habitat destruction ends

Does habitat loss affect the communities of plants and insects equally in plant–pollinator interactions? Preliminary findings

Continental‐scale determinants of population trends in European amphibians and reptiles

Geometric effects of fragmentation are likely to mitigate diversity loss following habitat destruction in real‐world landscapes

Geometric and demographic effects explain contrasting fragmentation-biodiversity relationships across scales