Abstract:The purpose of this study is to examine the kinds of ad appeals and brand types that contribute to perceived ad–media congruence on Instagram and how such congruence influences consumers' engagement intentions via the interaction of self-related congruence constructs. Additionally, ad intrusiveness was studied as a mediator of the relationship between ad–media congruence and consumers' behavioral engagement intention. An online 2 (Ad appeal: hedonic vs utilitarian) × 2 (Brand type: hedonic vs utilitarian) between-subject experiment was conducted with four versions of mock-up Instagram in-feed native ads. Results showed that hedonic advertising appeals contributed to ad–media congruence on Instagram, which yielded a lower level of ad intrusiveness and further resulted in higher consumer behavioral engagement intentions. The brand type did not significantly influence participants' perceptions of ad–media congruence. Moreover, the findings indicate individuals' brand-self congruence and ad-self congruence were significant moderators in interactions with ad–media congruence in influencing consumers' behavioral engagement intentions. Both brand managers and social media providers can leverage this study's findings to improve ad effectiveness and consumer experiences in their respective social media landscapes. Specifically, knowing what kind of ad is more congruent and less intrusive, as well as how to better tailor targeting strategies in digital media spaces by building higher ad self- and brand self-congruence, can help them achieve persuasive effects when complying with the Federal Trade Commission disclosure guideline. The current study advances extant literature on native advertising by examining the core characteristic of ad–media congruence and its relation to the key metric of social media marketing success – consumer engagement intentions. The findings also extend the congruence theory by examining the interaction effect of media- and self-related congruence constructs.

How advertising relevance and consumer–Brand relationship strength limit disclosure effects of native ads on Twitter

The role of relevancy in native advertising on social media

Unguarded against Persuasion and Willing to Share: The Combined Effect of Chronic Regulatory Focus and Disclosure Language on Consumer Responses to Native Advertising

Prosocial native advertising on social media: effects of ad-context congruence, ad position and ad type

Consumers' ambiguous perceptions of advertising disclosures in influencer marketing: Disentangling the effects on current and future social media engagement

How, why, and when disclosure type matters for influencer marketing

Disclosing Instagram Influencer Advertising: The Effects of Disclosure Language on Advertising Recognition, Attitudes, and Behavioral Intent

The effects of disclosure format on native advertising recognition and audience perceptions of legacy and online news publishers

Not All Friends Are Created Equal: the Effect of Friendship Type on Performance of Shared Native Ads on Social Media

Ad Disclosure vs. Ad Recognition: How Persuasion Knowledge Influences Native Advertising Evaluation

Native advertising effectiveness: The role of congruence and consumer annoyance on clicks, bounces, and visits

Consumers’ responses to native vs. banner advertising: moderation of persuasion knowledge on interaction effects of ad type and placement type

Intrusive or Relevant? Exploring How Consumers Avoid Native Facebook Ads through Decomposed Persuasion Knowledge

Going Native: Effects of Disclosure Position and Language on the Recognition and Evaluation of Online Native Advertising

Going Native on Social Media: The Effects of Social Media Characteristics on Native Ad Effectiveness

Effects of Disclosure, Placement Type, and Ad–Context Congruence on Brand and Advertising Recognition: An Exploration of CARE Model Processing

The Role of a Companion Banner and Sponsorship Transparency in Recognizing and Evaluating Article-style Native Advertising

Demystifying congruence effects in Instagram in-feed native ads: the role of media-based and self-based congruence

Improving Consumers' Ability to Detect Native Advertising Using Identified Disclosure

Serial Position Effects on Native Advertising Effectiveness: Differential Results Across Publisher and Advertiser Metrics

Sponsorship Disclosure in Native Advertising: A Theoretical Framework