Abstract:Based on a large real-world dataset comprising Instagram posts of popular influencers, this study empirically analyzes the impact of disclosed and undisclosed advertising on consumers' engagement with (a) the advertisement and (b) future non-advertising posts of the same author. As extant research reports inconsistent effects of ad disclosures based on inferred motives, persuasion knowledge, and source credibility, this study develops a conceptual framework incorporating these theoretical concepts. To identify undisclosed advertisements, we use data from regions with proper disclosure culture to train a model to predict if posts are advertising. Based on the predictions for > 65,000 posts of 239 macro-influencers, we find that advertising posts gather less engagement than non-advertising posts. Regarding immediate ad engagement, we find that disclosed ads gather less engagement than undisclosed ads. Contrastingly, when analyzing future engagement, we identify positive persistent effects of disclosed advertising and negative persistent effects of undisclosed advertising on consumers' engagement with future posts of the same author. We conclude that source credibility explains the effect of disclosures on future posts, while the Persuasion Knowledge Model can explain the effect of disclosures on the current advertisement. Thus, consumers' coping strategies triggered by activated persuasion knowledge are mostly limited to the advertisement. Our findings can explain the opposing results of extant research. From a managerial perspective, we find that by not disclosing advertising posts, influencers and marketers increase an ad's engagement levels at the expense of persistently lowered attitudes. Conversely, in the long run, they may benefit from transparent disclosures.

Ad Disclosure vs. Ad Recognition: How Persuasion Knowledge Influences Native Advertising Evaluation

Reducing Native Advertising Deception: Revisiting the Antecedents and Consequences of Persuasion Knowledge in Digital News Contexts

The effects of disclosure format on native advertising recognition and audience perceptions of legacy and online news publishers

Avoidance and Acceptance of Native Advertising on Social Media: Applications of Consumer Social Intelligence, Persuasion Knowledge, and the Typology of Consumer Responses

Unguarded against Persuasion and Willing to Share: The Combined Effect of Chronic Regulatory Focus and Disclosure Language on Consumer Responses to Native Advertising

The Deceptiveness of Sponsored News Articles

Going Native: Effects of Disclosure Position and Language on the Recognition and Evaluation of Online Native Advertising

Intrusive or Relevant? Exploring How Consumers Avoid Native Facebook Ads through Decomposed Persuasion Knowledge

Disclosing Instagram Influencer Advertising: The Effects of Disclosure Language on Advertising Recognition, Attitudes, and Behavioral Intent

Improving Consumers' Ability to Detect Native Advertising Using Identified Disclosure

Consumers’ responses to native vs. banner advertising: moderation of persuasion knowledge on interaction effects of ad type and placement type

The Role of a Companion Banner and Sponsorship Transparency in Recognizing and Evaluating Article-style Native Advertising

Effects of Disclosure, Placement Type, and Ad–Context Congruence on Brand and Advertising Recognition: An Exploration of CARE Model Processing

Advertising nativeness as a function of content and design congruence

Consumers' ambiguous perceptions of advertising disclosures in influencer marketing: Disentangling the effects on current and future social media engagement

How advertising relevance and consumer–Brand relationship strength limit disclosure effects of native ads on Twitter

A Study on the Video-Type Native Advertising Effect According to the Advertising Appeal, Involvement and Persuasion Knowledge

Native Advertising: Is Deception an Asset or a Liability?

The role of relevancy in native advertising on social media

Can US advertising students recognize an ad in editorial’s clothing (native advertising)? A partial replication of the Stanford “Evaluating information” test

The Persuasion Knowledge Model Within Instagram Advertisements