Abstract:Litigation has forced tobacco companies like Philip Morris to disclose more than 7 million internal documents, including previously confidential public relations plans. We draw from this archive, as well as from activist materials, to demonstrate that, despite vigorous industry efforts to thwart them, activists in this case employed strategies of values advocacy and inoculation and capitalized on economic benefits to persuade publics. This watershed case poses continued challenges for the 2-way symmetrical or mixed-motive theoretical model of public relations. Accounting for public relations activism and understanding its voice in influencing contemporary public debate requires that scholars move beyond this widely accepted model that stresses compromise between activists and organizations. An alternative rhetorical theory of activist public relations is posited to account for groups that refuse to accommodate opponents. The authors would like to thank the various reviewers, as well as colleagues Drs. Rachel L. Holloway, Alan R. Freitag, and Dean Kruckeberg for their assistance with this manuscript. They would also like to thank Pete Bialick, President of Colorado GASP, for access to the group's archives. Notes 1The Excellence Study and research program is funded by the International Association of Business Communicators (IABC) Research Foundation to examine excellence in public relations. Part of the Excellence Theory that emerged from this program of research builds from the original four models to stress creating relationships between organizations and their publics that are two-way and symmetrical. 2The Excellence Study update rebuts ongoing criticism of the models. The authors contend they never argued that symmetrical practices were completely altruistic; they dismiss contingent and mixed-motive critiques as merely elaborating on their original conceptualizations of the theory; they contend that the two-way symmetrical model is not idealistic. They also dismiss the concern over abuse of power in the model, arguing activists can have considerable power by professionally employing public relations skills. 3This research was partially supported by a grant from the National Institutes of Health/National Cancer Institute (R01-CA87490), “Linguistic Analyses of Tobacco Industry Documents.” The views expressed herein are solely those of the authors. 4Cutler (Citation2004) argued that the process of theory development is being dominated by quantitative research such as that of Grunig's Excellence Study. 5The American Legacy Foundation's campaign, truth™, for example, persuades youth to reject tobacco by using values advocacy. Similar to GASP, truth™ focuses on the industry's dishonesty and social costs of tobacco, rather than on the dangers of smoking, to appeal to teens. 6Note, however, these commercials remain suspect for actually encouraging youth smoking under the pretense of preaching “adult choice.” See Landman, Ling, and Glantz (Citation2002).

Laughably Disingenuous, Brazenly Bogus, Extreme Green “Lawfare”: The Rhetorical Framing of Environmentalist Actors in Coal Age Magazine

Greenwashing Consumption: The Didactic Framing of ExxonMobil's Energy Solutions

Engaging Truthiness and Obfuscation in a Political Ecology Analysis of a Protest Against the Pengzhou Petroleum Refinery

Black coal, thin ice: the discursive legitimisation of Australian coal in the age of climate change

Rhetoric, Environmentalism, and Environmental Ethics

Activism and the Limits of Symmetry: the Public Relations Battle Between Colorado GASP and Philip Morris

Disassembling Poland's high-carbon imaginaries from within: The case of local activism in Upper Silesia

Framing industrial decarbonization technologies in the public sphere: Narratives from the digital "town square" in the United Kingdom

Climate Change and Media Representation: A Multimodal Discourse Analysis of Clean Green Pakistan Policy from Eco-linguistic perspective

Building a new environmentalism: News media access and framing in Canada's environmental movement

The Politics of Market-Based Environmental Regulation: Continuity and Change in Air Pollution Control Policy Conflict

United in criticism: The discursive politics and coalitions of Australian energy debates on social media

What would a Swedish mine be without a party? On metals, minerals, and love during the “green” transition: Climate propaganda in The Swedish Mine advertising campaign

Master of Fate or Victim of Circumstance — The Exercise of Corporate Power in Environmental Policy-Making

The Means and End of Greenwash

The micropolitics of coal in India: understanding resource politics from the ground up through a materiality lens

Framing Collective Moral Responsibility for Climate Change: A Longitudinal Frame Analysis of Energy Company Climate Reporting

Greening our Laws: Revising Land Acquisition Law for Coal Mining in India

Transition, hedge, or resist? Understanding political and economic behavior toward decarbonization in the oil and gas industry

Environmentalism and Restructuring of the Global Pulp and Paper Industry

Legitimating impotence: Pyrrhic victories of the modern environmental movement