Abstract:Governments, businesses, and civil society organizations have diverse policy tools to incentivize adaptation. Policy tools can shape the type and extent of adaptation, and therefore, function either as barriers or enablers for reducing risk and vulnerability. Using data from a systematic review of academic literature on global adaptation responses to climate change (n = 1549 peer-reviewed articles), we categorize the types of policy tools used to shape climate adaptation. We apply qualitative and quantitative analyses to assess the contexts where particular tools are used, along with equity implications for groups targeted by the tools, and the tools’ relationships with transformational adaptation indicators such as the depth, scope, and speed of adaptation. We find diverse types of tools documented across sectors and geographic regions. We also identify a mismatch between the tools that consider equity and those that yield more transformational adaptations. Direct regulations, plans, and capacity building are associated with higher depth and scope of adaptation (thus transformational adaptation), while economic instruments, information provisioning, and networks are not; the latter tools, however, are more likely to target marginalized groups in their design and implementation. We identify multiple research gaps, including a need to assess instrument mixes rather than single tools and to assess adaptations that result from policy implementation. Key policy insights Information-based approaches, networks, and economic instruments are the most frequently documented adaptation policy tools worldwide. Direct regulations, plans, and capacity building are associated with higher depth and scope of adaptation, and thus more transformational adaptation. Capacity building, economic instruments, networks, and information provisioning approaches are more likely to target specific marginalized groups and thus equity challenges. There are many regions and sectors where certain tools are not widely documented (e.g. regulations and plans in Africa and Asia), representing a key research gap. Information-based approaches, networks, and economic instruments are the most frequently documented adaptation policy tools worldwide. Direct regulations, plans, and capacity building are associated with higher depth and scope of adaptation, and thus more transformational adaptation. Capacity building, economic instruments, networks, and information provisioning approaches are more likely to target specific marginalized groups and thus equity challenges. There are many regions and sectors where certain tools are not widely documented (e.g. regulations and plans in Africa and Asia), representing a key research gap.

Policy implementation styles and local governments: the case of climate change adaptation

Deciding climate change adaptation implementation at the local level – a tale of two cities in the Netherlands

Policy design, spatial planning and climate change adaptation: a case study from Australia

Local adaptation policy responses to extreme weather events

Implementing climate change adaptation through mainstreaming at the local level—a comparative case study of two municipalities in the Netherlands

National-level factors affecting planned, public adaptation to health impacts of climate change

Applying a Typology of Governance Modes to Climate Change Adaptation

Climate policy processes, local institutions, and adaptation actions: mechanisms of translation and influence

Explaining Public Organization Adaptation to Climate Change: Configurations of Macro- and Meso-Level Institutional Logics

Supporting local climate adaptation planning and implementation through local governance and decentralised finance provision

Applying collective action frameworks to analyse local-level collaboration for electric vehicle-related policies

Structure, agency and local climate governance: how do individual actors exploit local contexts to shape policymaking in smaller cities and towns?

What drives sustainable climate change adaptation at the local level? Approaching three knowledge gaps

A global assessment of policy tools to support climate adaptation

Climate adaptation in Coastal Virginia: an analysis of existing policies and main stakeholders

What factors drive municipal climate adaptation policy? The role of risk management capacity and transnational municipal networks

Overcoming Bureaucratic Resistance: An Analysis of Barriers to Climate Change Adaptation in South Africa

Mainstreaming climate adaptation into urban development projects in the Netherlands: private sector drivers and municipal policy instruments

Local governments as key agents in climate change adaptation: challenges and opportunities for institutional capacity-building in Mexico

Climate change policy instruments in agriculture sector: From policy to adaptation practice at local level in Nepal

Unequal considerations of justice in municipal adaptation planning: an assessment of US climate plans over time and by context