Describing Road Booming Noise with a Hybrid Simulation Model Using a Time Segmentation of the Excitation Load Approach

Michael Herrmann,Jan Kralicek,Wolfgang Stein,Frank Gauterin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/vehicles3030028
2021-08-04
Vehicles
Abstract:One of the most important goals in vehicle acoustics is to describe the NVH behavior of a vehicle at sound pressure level using simulation models at an early stage of development. Different simulation models and methods are used for this purpose. To balance the advantages and disadvantages of the different methods, it is important to combine the simulation models. For the virtual description of the road booming noise behavior of a vehicle passing a rough road, we use a multibody simulation model excited with the elevation profile of the road in the time domain. To calculate the sound pressure inside the vehicle, the internal chassis forces of the multibody simulation model are combined with a finite element body model including the air cavity inside the cabin. The methodology for combining the chassis forces and body transfer functions to calculate the sound pressure is first validated using test data and then applied to the simulation data. The correlation of the calculated sound pressure based on test data (ρ=0.96) and based on simulation data (ρ=0.90) compared to a microphone measurement is very high.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to use a hybrid simulation model to describe the low - frequency road booming noise behavior inside the vehicle when the vehicle passes through an uneven road surface. Specifically, the author aims to combine the multi - body dynamics simulation model (MBS) and the finite element method (FEM) model to achieve an accurate evaluation of the sound pressure level of the vehicle under real or simulated chassis excitation. The goal of this research is to be able to accurately predict and evaluate the NVH (noise, vibration and harshness) performance of the vehicle through the simulation model in the early stage of vehicle development, especially the performance of low - frequency road noise. ### Background of the Paper With the transformation of the automotive industry towards the electric drive concept, the acoustic behavior of vehicles has become increasingly important. Due to the absence of internal combustion engine noise and the loss of its masking effect, the importance of road noise has increased significantly. Among them, low - frequency road noise is caused by non - uniform road surfaces, which mainly lead to the pitching and lifting movements of the rear axle, and then cause the coupled vibration mode of the vehicle body. Passengers will experience this phenomenon as ear pressure and low - frequency rumbling. Therefore, developing a complete vehicle simulation model that can evaluate the low - frequency road noise behavior of the vehicle under the sound pressure level has become an important development goal. ### Research Methods 1. **Test Vehicle and Test Track**: - A station wagon was selected as the test vehicle because this type of vehicle is more sensitive to road noise. - An approximately 750 - meter - long non - uniform road surface was used as the test track. The corrugation coefficient of this road surface is 2.0, and the unevenness level is 33.0, which belongs to a poor subjective rating (category D). 2. **Measurement Equipment and Methods**: - **Determining the Noise Transfer Function of the Vehicle**: A force was applied at the chassis connection points using an impact hammer, and the transmitted force and the sound pressure measured by the microphone were recorded. After being converted to the frequency domain by FFT, the noise transfer function was calculated. - **Determining the Internal Force of the Chassis**: The relative displacement was calculated using the bearing stiffness method, and then multiplied by the dynamic stiffness of the bearing to obtain the internal force. 3. **Different Methods for Sound Pressure Calculation**: - **FFT Algorithm Averaging of the Excitation Spectrum**: The test track was divided into multiple windows, the relative displacement of each window was calculated, averaged after FFT conversion, and then multiplied by the noise transfer function to obtain the total sound pressure. - **Time Segmentation of the Excitation Load**: The test track was divided into small windows, each window was processed separately, the internal force and sound pressure of each window were calculated, and finally the RMS average was carried out to obtain the total sound pressure. ### Results The paper compared the performance of the two methods on the measured data, and the results showed that: - **FFT Algorithm Averaging of the Excitation Spectrum**: The calculation result has a similar curve to the measured data, but there are large deviations at some frequency points, and the maximum error can reach 7 dB(B). - **Time Segmentation of the Excitation Load**: The calculation result is smoother and has a higher degree of agreement with the measured data, and the maximum error is reduced to 3 dB(B). ### Conclusion By combining the multi - body dynamics simulation model and the finite element method model and using the time segmentation method of the excitation load, the low - frequency road noise behavior of the vehicle when driving on an uneven road surface can be described and evaluated more accurately. This provides a powerful tool in the early stage of vehicle development and helps to optimize the NVH performance of the vehicle.