10-years of bird habitat selection studies in mainland China: a review
JIANG Aiwu,ZHOU Fang,QIN Yue,LIU Naifa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5846/stxb201108151194
2012-01-01
Acta Ecologica Sinica
Abstract:Habitat selection can be regarded as a hierarchical process of different behavioral responses,which may lead to some habitat being disproportionately used because of spatial variation in fitness and survival.In China,questions about habitat selection have been the most important part of avian ecology research.Early research focused on characterizing the relationship between species diversity and habitat type.In recent years,the number of studies about avian habitat selection conducted by ornithologists in China has increased.To determine the status of bird habitat selection research,we surveyed papers published by ornithologists in mainland China over the last 10 years(2001—2010).We searched titles,abstracts and keywords for the terms "habitat selection and use","nest site selection and use","roost site selection and use",and "foraging site selection and use"in three Chinese journal databases and Google scholar.From each paper,we extracted:(1) the study species;(2) details about the methods;(3) whether the terms "habitat selection"and "habitat use"were used appropriately;(4) whether the results were placed in the context of fitness;and(5) any other relevant information.In total,we found 170 papers about bird habitat selection or habitat use.Of these,154 papers were published in journals of mainland China.The other 16 papers were published in international journals.The study species were 73 bird species belonging to 10 orders and 31 families.Only nine of the 59 endemic birds of mainland China have been studied in last ten years.The number of papers per year has continuously increased in the last ten years.The number of papers published in 2009—2010 was almost 3 times that in 2001—2002.However,the same questions have been consistently asked by Chinese bird habitat selection studies.Furthermore,of the reviewed papers,33.3%(56 /168) suffered from semantic inconsistencies when using"habitat selection"and"habitat use"and this problem does not seem to vary among years.(x 2 = 2.94,P = 0.57).Some researchers appear to regard these two terms as synonymous.In total,93.2%(96 /103) of the papers examined habitat selection by comparing used versus unused habitat;the other 6.8%(7 /103) compared used versus available habitat.However,many authors failed to clarify that not all habitat is equally suitable for bird use.Population density,predators and scales may influence habitat availability.Most(99.0%,101 /103) of the papers did not place their findings in a behavioral or fitness context.Habitat selection is a process in which birds decide to choose a suitable site for nest,roost or forage,and the choice can affect fitness.In most studies,the factors influencing habitat selection were proposed to be food,water and coverage.However,the pathway through which these environmental factors influence habitat selection was seldom discussed.Based on our findings,we propose ways in which bird habitat selection research in mainland China can advance.First,there should be more study of the habitat selection of bird species that are endemic to China.Second,bird habitat selection should be studied at different spatial scales,and for more species and environments.Finally,bird habitat selection should be studied by considering the behavior of individuals,and its fitness consequences.