Title The effect of Index Funds Competition on Money ManagementFees
Yang Sun,Marco Di Maggio,David Matsa,William Mullins,Jun Pan,Jonathan Parker,Tarun Ramadorai,Jonathan Reuter,Nancy Rose,Stephen Ross,Felipe Severino,Adrien Verdelhan,Jiang Wang,Xiao Yu Wang,Keith Wong,Yan Xu
2014-01-01
Abstract:This paper estimates the effect of competition from low-cost index funds on fees in the money management industry. A difference-in-differences analysis exploiting the staggered entry of index funds finds that while actively managed funds sold directly to retail investors reduce fees by six percent, those sold through brokers increase fees by four percent. Additionally, actively managed funds, especially closet indexers, shift away from holding the index portfolio. A market segmentation model illustrates that beyond a price-competition effect, the index fund entry creates a selection effect that isolates the least-price-sensitive investors and results in a price increase for this group. †MIT Sloan School of Management (email sunyang@mit.edu). I am indebted to Nittai Bergman, Andrey Malenko, Stewart Myers and especially Antoinette Schoar for their invaluable guidance and encouragement. I thank Jean-Noel Barrot, Asaf Bernstein, Tara Bhandari, Hui Chen, Martijn Cremers, Pengjie Gao, Xavier Giroud, Xing Hu, Raj Iyer, Dirk Jenter, Li Jin, Mark Kritzman, David Laibson, Chen Lin, Tse-Chun Lin, Hong Luo, Marco Di Maggio, David Matsa, William Mullins, Jun Pan, Jonathan Parker, Tarun Ramadorai, Jonathan Reuter, Nancy Rose, Stephen Ross, Felipe Severino, Pian Shu, Dragon Tang, Adrien Verdelhan, Jiang Wang, Xiao Yu Wang, Keith Wong, Yan Xu, as well as seminar participants at MIT Finance Lunch, MIT Finance Seminar, University of Hong Kong and University of Notre Dame for helpful comments. In addition, I am grateful to Gary Gastineau, John Minahan, Kim Perry, Gita Rao, Steve Snider and Brian Walters for sharing insights on the institutional setup. All errors are mine.