Abstract:Manuscript Tytpe: Empirical Research Question/Issue: We study the relation between mutual fund performance and Morningstar's fiduciary grades using quantile regression models. This research is important because we shed new light on the principal‐agent issue in the mutual fund industry, and investors and professional managers often use Morningstar's rating system to guide their investment decisions. Quantile regressions allow us to examine the differential impact of mutual fund governance variables such as manager incentives and board quality on fund performance across the entire performance distribution. Research Findings/Insights: Quantile regressions find a strong contemporaneous association between Stewardship Grade and Sharpe Ratio. Manager incentives, though not significant in the OLS regression, are positively related to the fund performance for better performing funds, and negatively correlated with portfolio turnover. However, manager incentives are shown to have little predictive power for funds' future performance. In contrast, board quality, which is in the center stage of the proposed SEC mutual fund regulation, bears little relationship with contemporaneous fund performance, yet is strongly related to funds' future performance. Theoretical/Academic Implications: Our analyses and results have two important implications for the principal‐agent theory. Our finding that board quality has a more profound impact on fund performance than manager incentives suggests that incentive alignment through compensation contracts is less effective in mitigating agency problems than quality board monitoring. Our quantile regression results also provide new insights to the analysis of corporate governance research. The major advantage of using quantile regression is that it reveals the whole spectrum of heterogeneous mutual fund performance responses to their governance efforts, especially the behavior of funds at the tails of the distribution; hence better corporate governance policies can be drawn up and instituted. This methodology is useful for other governance research as well and entails meaningful regulatory implications when firms/industries are heterogeneous and the conditional means of traditional regression analysis does not provide much information and guidance for corporate decision making. Practitioner/Policy Implications: This study shows that fund performance is associated with manager incentives contemporaneously, while board quality predicts fund performance in the long haul. This finding has important regulatory implications, as the efficacy of SEC's proposal on board and chairman independence is under great debate. Our results also provide useful information for investors who use Morningstar's Stewardship grades to guide their investments.

The Incentive Programs Research of Fund Management

Research on the Payment Systems of Executives in Listed Companies in Post-crisis Era——Pattern of Risk Management and Long-term Incentive

Optimal Control of DC Pension Plan Management under Two Incentive Schemes

Investigation of Fund Managers' Risk-taking Behavior Motivated by Fund Tournament

The Incentive Effect of Management:On the Sample Analysis of Listed Companies in China

The Effect of Incentive Structure on Referral: the Determining Role of Self-Construal

Research Review and Prospect of Equity Incentive Effect

Risking or De-Risking: How Management Fees Affect Hedge Fund Risk-Taking Choices

Does Equity Incentive Have Persistent Incentive Effects?---An Empirical Analysis Based on Propensity Score Matching Method

Research on incentives contract design and learning mechanism in risk investment

Managers’ Characteristics and Fund Performance---An Empirical Research Based on China Stock Fund

Influential Effects of Intrinsic-Extrinsic Incentive Factors on Management Performance in New Energy Enterprises

Review on the Incentive Effect of Team Compensation Scheme

Excessive Incentive and Corporate Performance: Research Based on Marginal Diminishing Effect and Top Management Team of Chinese Listed Companies

Incentives and Matching of Heterogeneous Principals and Agents: Field Evidence from a Mutual Fund Scandal

Gambling or De-Risking: Hedge Fund Risk Taking Vs. Managers' Compensation

The Optimal Managerial Incentive Mechanism for China’s Local and Central SOEs: an Empirical Study of Listed Companies

A Study on Sustainable Innovation of the Incentive Mechanism for Internal Human Resources in Enterprises

Incentives in the Chinese Construction Industry

Star Ratings and the Incentives of Mutual Funds

Mutual Fund Governance and Performance: A Quantile Regression Analysis of Morningstar's Stewardship Grade