Abstract:The criteria for radwaste acceptance valid in the Exclusion Zone of SSE “Chornobyl NPP” require that each batch (package) of solid radioactive waste (SRW) sent for burial be certified. For the radionuclides that are difficult to measure (DTM) with using standard control systems directly in a package, the IAEA recommends using the Scaling Factors (SF). In the course of special studies to determine their quantitative values, some difficulties were encountered when analyzing laboratory data on the DTM nuclide in SRW, which largely consisted of so-called nondetectable (ND) results declared in the reports as <MDA (less than the minimum detectable activity). The work was aimed to evaluate the known algorithms for SF determination used in the world practice of radwaste management, in terms of acceptability of their application to laboratory data sampling with different proportions of ND results (<MDA) on the example of 241Am content in ChNPP historical waste. Three data sampling were formed with the share of ND results equaling to 18, 42 and 55 percent. This work addresses several methods for SF calculation, which are used in radwaste management systems of the countries with developed nuclear fuel cycle. Among the selected algorithms for data process testing, the most powerful one of methods for ND results censoring is included — the method of maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), which allows by restoring the normal law of distribution of random data to most accurately adjust the value of mean contaminant content according to the probability of appearance of each of measurement results, with taking into account the added ND results after their censoring by a numerical value multiple of MDA. The possibilities of selected algorithms, from the viewpoint of accuracy of statistical indicators’ reproduction in the initial arrays of experimental data sampling with SF application, were investigated on “problematic” data sampling related to 241Am content in ChNPP historical waste. The studied algorithms are ranked according to the quantitative scale of acceptability (reliability) assessment for each of them for the use in radwaste management system of ChNPP for certification of DTM activity contained in the SRW packages. The data obtained allowed drawing conclusions on the most acceptable algorithms that can be recommended for SF calculation, depending on the content of experimental data collected after laboratory control. The influence of data censoring on the accuracy of reproduction of the original spectrum of experimental data for different algorithms is estimated. The validity of use of Mean Activity Method recommended by the IAEA for data sampling, which contains a significant proportion of ND results, was confirmed.

Comparison of Currie Method and ISO Standard 11929 Method of the Minimum Detectable Activity Concentration

Comparison of Two Risk Assessment Methods in Natural Gas Shallow Freezing Unit Assessment

Comparative Study of the Measurement of Thoron Gas

A comparison of alternative ISO-11929 compliant detection limit calculations for the case of large systematic uncertainties

Evaluation of Airborne Radiation Survey Used for Monitoring Leakage of Radionuclides in Nuclear Accident

INTERCOMPARISON EXPERIMENT AND UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS OF THREE MEASUREMENT METHODS FOR RADON PROGENY AT NIM.

Reduction of detection limits in monitoring of internal exposures by a combined evaluation of emissions and spectra

Results of Comparative Evaluation of Algorithms for Calculating Scaling Factors of Difficult-To-Measure Nuclides in CHNPP Wastes at 241Am Example

Minimum detectable activity concentration of online monitoring instrument in primary circuit of HTR-PM based on Monte Carlo simulation

Comparison of Morphological Characteristics for Alpha Tracks in CR-39 Using Different Radon Monitors

Multi-group approximation, scattering and calibration coefficients, uncertainty estimates and detection limits of a NaI(Tl)-based gamma spectrometry set-up for low-level activity analysis

Study on Accurate Measurement of ~(220)Rn Activity Concentration by Using RAD7 Radon Monitor

International Intercomparison and Quality Assessment of Passive and Active 222rn Measuring Devices in the Asia-Pacific Region

Analysis of the standard calibration methods for neutron monitors

Comparison Study on Rare Earth Radioanalysis

An Instrument for Measuring the Unattached Fraction of Radon Progeny with Etched Track Detectors

Two new 222Rn emanation sources – a comparison study

Efficiency Analysis And Comparison Of Different Radon Progeny Measurement Methods

Design of a Measurement Unit for Measuring the Neutron, Gamma Dose Equivalent Meanwhile Based on Single-sphere Multi-detector Neutron Spectrometer and GM Counter

A baseline estimation procedure to improve MDA evaluation in gamma-ray spectrometry

Preliminary Study on Aerosol Particle Addition Calibration Method for On-Line Quantitative Analysis of Airborne Radioactive Particles with Icp-Ms