Abstract:Does an ecological community allow stable coexistence? Identifying the general principles that determine the answer to this question is a central problem of theoretical ecology. Random matrix theory approaches have uncovered the general trends of the effect of competitive, mutualistic, and predator-prey interactions between species on stability of coexistence. However, an ecological community is determined not only by the counts of these different interaction types, but also by their network arrangement. This cannot be accounted for in a direct statistical description that would enable random matrix theory approaches. Here, we therefore develop a different approach, of exhaustive analysis of small ecological communities, to show that this arrangement of interactions can influence stability of coexistence more than these general trends. We analyse all interaction networks of $N\leqslant 5$ species with Lotka-Volterra dynamics by combining exact results for $N\leqslant 3$ species and numerical exploration. Surprisingly, we find that a very small subset of these networks are "impossible ecologies", in which stable coexistence is non-trivially impossible. We prove that the possibility of stable coexistence in general ecologies is determined by similarly rare "irreducible ecologies". By random sampling of interaction strengths, we then show that the probability of stable coexistence varies over many orders of magnitude even in ecologies that differ only in the network arrangement of identical ecological interactions. Finally, we demonstrate that our approach can reveal the effect of evolutionary or environmental perturbations of the interaction network. Overall, this work reveals the importance of the full structure of the network of interactions for stability of coexistence in ecological communities.

Stability of multi-layer ecosystems

Multilayer Network Structure Enhances the Coexistence of Competitive Species.

Structured interactions as a stabilizing mechanism for competitive ecosystems

Assembly, Ecosystem Functions, and Stability in Species Interaction Networks

Stability Criteria for Complex Ecosystems

Structured interactions as a stabilizing mechanism for competitive ecological communities

Networked dynamic systems with higher-order interactions: stability versus complexity

Ecosystem stability relies on diversity difference between trophic levels

Interspecific competition shapes the structural stability of mutualistic networks

Ecosystem Stability and Its Relationship with Biodiversity

Stability of Degree Heterogeneous Ecological Networks

Degree Heterogeneity and Stability of Ecological Networks.

Seasonal structure of interactions enhances multidimensional stability of mutualistic networks

The feasibility of equilibria in large ecosystems: a primary but neglected concept in the complexity-stability debate

Network structural properties mediate the stability of mutualistic communities

Multiple Stabilizing Pathways in Wetland Plant Communities Subjected to an Elevation Gradient

How Complementarity and Selection Affect the Relationship Between Ecosystem Functioning and Stability.

Time delays modulate the stability of complex ecosystems

Stability of Ecological Systems: A Theoretical Review

Impossible ecologies: Interaction networks and stability of coexistence in ecological communities

Effects of Mixing Interaction Types on Ecological Community Stability