Ecosystem stability relies on diversity difference between trophic levels

Yizhou Liu,Jiliang Hu,Jeff Gore

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.23.609466

2024-08-26

Abstract:The stability of ecological communities has a profound impact on humans, ranging from individual health influenced by the microbiome to ecosystem services provided by fisheries. A long-standing goal of ecology is the elucidation of the interplay between biodiversity and ecosystem stability, with some ecologists warning of instability due to loss of species diversity while others arguing that greater diversity will instead lead to instability. Here, by considering a minimal two-level ecosystem with multiple predator and prey species, we show that stability does not depend on absolute diversity but rather on diversity differences between levels. We discovered that increasing diversity in either level first destabilizes but then stabilizes the community (i.e., a re-entrant stability transition). We therefore find that it is the diversity difference between levels that is the key to stability, with the least stable communities having similar diversities in different levels. An analytical stability criterion is derived, demonstrating quantitatively that the critical diversity difference is determined by the correlation between how one level affects another and how it is affected in turn. Our stability criterion also applies to consumer-resource models with other forms of interaction such as cross-feeding. Finally, we show that stability depends on diversity differences in ecosystems with three trophic levels. Our finding of a non-monotonic dependence of stability on diversity provides a natural explanation for the variety of diversity-stability relationships reported in the literature, and emphasizes the significance of level structure in predicting complex community behaviors.

Ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the relationship between ecosystem stability and species diversity. Specifically, the author focuses on how the stability of an ecosystem in a two - tier ecosystem containing multiple predator and prey species is affected by the diversity differences between different trophic levels. The core question of the paper is to explore whether the key factor in ecosystem stability lies in absolute diversity or in the diversity differences between different trophic levels.

### Main Findings
1. **Non - monotonic Dependence**: The study found that increasing the diversity of any trophic level will first disrupt the stability of the community, but then restore stability, that is, there is a re - entrant stability transition.
2. **Importance of Diversity Differences**: The stability of the ecosystem depends on the diversity differences between different trophic levels, rather than the total diversity. When the diversities of the two trophic levels are similar, the community is the most unstable.
3. **Analysis of Stability Criteria**: The author derived a quantitative stability criterion, indicating that the key diversity differences are determined by the correlations of interactions between different trophic levels.
4. **Multi - trophic - level Systems**: The study also found that this conclusion also applies to ecosystems containing three trophic levels, further emphasizing the importance of trophic - level structure in predicting the behavior of complex communities.

### Formula Analysis
The paper uses some key formulas to describe the dynamics and stability in the ecosystem:

1. **Dynamic Equations for Predators and Prey**:
\[
\frac{dN_i}{dt} = N_i \left( r_i - \sum_j C_{ij} P_j - d_i - a_i N_i \right)
\]
\[
\frac{dP_j}{dt} = P_j \left( \sum_i Y_{ij} C_{ij} N_i - m_j \right)
\]
where:
- \( N_i \) represents the quantity of the \( i \) - th prey.
- \( P_j \) represents the quantity of the \( j \) - th predator.
- \( r_i \) is the growth rate of the \( i \) - th prey.
- \( C_{ij} \) is the predation rate of the \( j \) - th predator on the \( i \) - th prey.
- \( d_i \) and \( a_i \) are the natural mortality rate and self - regulation coefficient of the \( i \) - th prey respectively.
- \( Y_{ij} \) is the conversion efficiency obtained by the \( j \) - th predator from the \( i \) - th prey.
- \( m_j \) is the natural mortality rate of the \( j \) - th predator.

2. **Stability Criterion**:
\[
\rho \leq \sqrt{\frac{\min\left(\frac{S_1}{S_2}, \frac{S_2}{S_1}\right)}{\alpha}}
\]
where:
- \( \rho \) is the correlation of interactions between different trophic levels.
- \( S_1 \) and \( S_2 \) are the diversities of the two trophic levels respectively.
- \( \alpha \) is a constant representing the standardized parameter of interaction intensity.

### Conclusion
Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, this paper reveals the complex relationship between ecosystem stability and diversity, especially emphasizing the importance of diversity differences between different trophic levels. These findings not only help to understand the stability mechanisms of ecosystems, but also provide a new perspective for predicting and managing complex ecosystems.