Abstract:Forest–grassland ecotones, the transitional zones between forests and grasslands, often harbor high levels of biodiversity. According to the portfolio theory, communities with such high biodiversity should exhibit high stability in ecosystem functioning. On the contrary, the theory of ‘bi-stability’ or ‘multistability’ predicts that ecosystems exhibiting multiple states or regimes (e.g. forest and grassland) are less stable. Understanding the stability of forest–grassland ecotone has broad implications for forest management and restoration. In this study, by quantifying landscape heterogeneity and temporal invariability of regional climatic and vegetational metrics, we aimed to reveal how landscape diversity influences the stability of ecosystem functioning in the forest–grassland ecotone. We focused on the forest–grassland ecotone in northern China (i.e. from the forest belt in the Greater Khingan Mountains to the steppe grassland in Inner Mongolia) and used remote sensing data of land cover dynamics from 1992 to 2015 to analyze the landscape diversity and ecosystem dynamics at different grain sizes. To measure the temporal stability of climatic variables and vegetational dynamics, we calculated the interannual variation of temperature (T), wind speed (WS), precipitation (P), and the net primary productivity (NPP) on the grided sampling cells at different spatial scale over the same period. Our results showed that landscape diversity across this forest–grassland ecotone was positively related to the stability of T and NPP, but negatively related to that of WS and P. These opposite patterns may be explained by the differential nature of ecosystem variables, namely whether they involve transporting substance across space (WS and P) or not (T and NPP). We also found that as the spatial scale increases, the diversity-stability relationships strengthened for all three climatic variables (i.e., T, P, WS). However, the stabilizing effects of landscape diversity on NPP first increased but then decreased with increasing grain size, peaking at 30 km. Our empirical analyses demonstrate strong, but context-dependent diversity-stability relationships, shedding light on the paradox in the stability of ecosystem functioning in the ecotone. These findings also have implications for the management of landscape resources to maintain the sustainability of forest–grassland ecotones.

Consistent Stabilizing Effects of Plant Diversity Across Spatial Scales and Climatic Gradients

[Maintaining Mechanism of Species Diversity of Land Plant Communities].

Biotic Homogenization Destabilizes Ecosystem Functioning by Decreasing Spatial Asynchrony

Biodiversity stabilizes plant communities through statistical-averaging effects rather than compensatory dynamics

Biodiversity Contributes to Stabilizing Ecosystem Productivity Across Spatial Scales As Much As Environmental Heterogeneity in a Large Temperate Forest Region

Different contributions of plant diversity and soil properties to the community stability in the arid desert ecosystem

Local species diversity, β-diversity and climate influence the regional stability of bird biomass across North America

Environmental factors indirectly reduce phytoplankton community stability via functional diversity

Consistently Positive Effect of Species Diversity on Ecosystem, but Not Population, Temporal Stability

Biodiversity and Ecosystem Stability Across Scales in Metacommunities.

Stable or Unstable? Landscape Diversity and Ecosystem Stability Across Scales in the Forest–grassland Ecotone in Northern China

Land use imperils plant and animal community stability through changes in asynchrony rather than diversity

Latitudinal Patterns of Forest Ecosystem Stability Across Spatial Scales As Affected by Biodiversity and Environmental Heterogeneity

Biomass Temporal Stability Increases at Two Spatial Scales During Secondary Succession

Synchrony matters more than species richness in plant community stability at a global scale

Stability and asynchrony of local communities but less so diversity increase regional stability of Inner Mongolian grassland

Ecosystem Stability and Its Relationship with Biodiversity

Temporal asynchrony of plant and soil biota determines ecosystem multifunctional stability

Species Richness Stabilizes Productivity Via Asynchrony and Drought-Tolerance Diversity in a Large-Scale Tree Biodiversity Experiment.

Nutrients and Herbivores Impact Grassland Stability Across Spatial Scales Through Different Pathways

Soil biota diversity and plant diversity both contributed to ecosystem stability in grasslands