Physical and Analytical Modeling of Soil Loss Caused by a Defective Sewer Pipe with Different Defect Locations

Yao Tang,David Z. Zhu,Dave H. Chan,Shuai Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11440-022-01747-7

2022-01-01

Acta Geotechnica

Abstract:Defects in sewer pipes are the leading cause of soil erosion and road collapse, but the effect of the defect location is unclear. Laboratory model tests were conducted to investigate the erosion and loss of sandy soil adjacent to a defective sewer pipe. Five defect locations around a round pipe were examined with a physical model in the laboratory. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) shows that the erosion in the soil around the pipe is limited to a narrow region above the defect in the pipe, and the defect location affects the soil erosion and flow rates. The eroded soil region did not change when the defect was located in the top half of the pipe, whereas the eroded region expanded when the defect is located in the bottom half of the pipe. The eroded region was more than two times wider for a pipe with a defect at the invert than a defect at the crown. Flow rate analysis demonstrated that the soil and water flow rates are reduced when the location of the defect is changed from the crown to the invert, and the time it takes during erosion is increased. The ratio between the soil and water flow rates is constant until the erosion cavity reaches the defect. The soil/water flow rate ratio is not affected by the water level or the defect location and it only depends on the ratio between the defect size and the particle size. The ratio between the soil/water flow rates and the defect/particle sizes can be approximated by an exponential relationship which is consistent with experimental observations and predictions using the free-fall arch theory. An analytical model is proposed to estimate the rate of soil loss for cohesionless soil, and the soil flow rate can be calculated using an erosion cavity model based on the law of mass conservation. A kinetic model is extended to predict the soil velocity during erosion which is verified with laboratory measurements.