Abstract:After many years of research across disciplines, it remains unclear whether people are more motivated to seek appraisals that accurately match self-views (self-verification) or are as favorable as possible (self-enhancement). Within sociology, mixed findings in identity theory have fueled the debate. A problem here is that a commonly employed statistical approach does not take into account the direction of a discrepancy between how we see ourselves and how we think others see us in terms of a given identity, yet doing so is critical for determining which self-motive is at play. We offer a test of three competing models of identity processes, including a new "mixed motivations" model where self-verification and self-enhancement operate simultaneously. We compare the models using the conventional statistical approach versus response surface analysis. The latter method allows us to determine whether identity discrepancies involving over-evaluation are as distressing as those involving under-evaluation. We use nationally representative data and compare results across four different identities and multiple outcomes. The two statistical approaches lead to the same conclusions more often than not and mostly support identity theory and its assumption that people seek self-verification. However, response surface tests reveal patterns that are mistaken as evidence of self-verification by conventional procedures, especially for the spouse identity. We also find that identity discrepancies have different effects on distress and self-conscious emotions (guilt and shame). Our findings have implications not only for research on self and identity across disciplines, but also for many other areas of research that incorporate these concepts and/or use difference scores as explanatory variables.

Individuals with Higher Economic Insecurity Manifest Greater Self‐serving Bias

Effect of construal level and job insecurity on responses to perceived external employability

The Relationship Between College Students'Self-Esteem and Social Anxiety: the Mediating Effect of Intolerance of Uncertainty

Relationships Between Self-esteem, Intolerance of Uncertainty,Career Decision-making Difficulties and Job Anxieties

Riskier for Me or for Others? the Role of Domain and Probability in Self-Other Differences, in Risky Decision-Making

Economic inequality is linked to biased self-perception

Social Dominance Orientation and Selfish Behaviors in Chinese Adolescents: the Mediating Role of Psychological Entitlement

Economic Inequality Increases Status Anxiety Through Perceived Contextual Competitiveness

Immune to Situation: The Self-Serving Bias in Unambiguous Contexts.

The Effects of Self-esteem on the Tendency Towards Self-verification: Evidences from Choosing Interaction Partners

Unpackaging the link between economic inequality and self-construal

Collective self-doubt: does subjective SES predict behavioral self-handicapping tendency in college students?

The Psychological Mechanism of the Influence of Social Exclusion on Risk-Taking Behavior

Material Hardship Predicts Response Bias in Loss-Averse Decisions: The Roles of Anxiety and Cognitive Control

To thine own self be true? Clarifying the effects of identity discrepancies on psychological distress and emotions

Why are people 'Lying Flat'? Personal relative deprivation suppresses self‐improvement motivation

I deserve better outcomes: Self-esteem relates to stronger reactions to unfairness

Experiencing More Job Insecurity Than Co-Workers: How Does It Impact on Extra-Role Behavior

Effects of Social Exclusion on Self-Evaluation: Domain Discrepancy Based on the Big Two Model

The effect of social reference points on self-other risk decision-making

The impact of information presentation on self-other risk decision-making