The Variation Theory of Comparative Literature and the Cross-Civilization Studies

Shunqing Cao,Song Shi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/25723618.2011.12015564

2011-01-01

Abstract:(2011). The Variation Theory of Comparative Literature and the Cross-Civilization Studies. Comparative Literature: East & West: Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 5-26.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Variation Theory: A Breakthrough in Research of World Comparative Literature Theory

Shunqing CAO

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/25723618.2010.12015581

2010-01-01

Abstract:(2010). Variation Theory: A Breakthrough in Research of World Comparative Literature Theory. Comparative Literature: East & West: Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 1-8.
The Theoretical Basis and Framework of Variation Theory

Shunqing Cao,Zhoukun Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7771/1481-4374.3108

2017-01-01

CLCWeb Comparative Literature and Culture

Abstract:In their article "The Theoretical Basis and Framework of Variation Theory" Shunqing Cao and Zhoukun Han re-examine the conclusions on variation theory drawn from Cao's The Variation Theory of Comparative Literature. Drawing on the past three decades of Chinese comparatist practice, the proposal of variation theory in that book is a scientific endeavor from China. China's comparative literature has sustained a focus on comparison of literatures Eastern and Western. And Chinese scholars have long been aware of the heterogeneity of civilizations and the variability in literature exchanges. By demonstrating uses and potentials of variation theory, this thesis attempts to show that variation theory offers a response and potential way forward for the current disciplinary crisis in comparative literature.
On Research and Application of Variation Theory of Comparative Literature in China

Shunqing Cao,Zhuang Peina

2014-01-01

Abstract:Literary variation has long existed, ancient and modern, domestic and foreign, but it is the Variation Theory that first systemizes the study of variation and serves as guidance for research on the phenomena of literary variation in Comparative Literature. This thesis conducts a general overview on the domestic research on Variation Theory and also its application both from the synchronic and diachronic perspective with an aim to identifying the trend and the uncharted in the current research, thus enriching the frame and application of the Variation Theory.
The legitimacy of comparison between eastern and western literatures and proposal of comparative literary variation

Shunqing Cao

2013-01-01

Abstract:Within the former Western framework of comparative literature theories, the justifiability of comparing literatures from different civilizations such as Eat and West was questioned. This was demonstrated overtly that there was no justifiability of comparing literatures of diverse civilizations in the former Western framework of theories. The proposal of the Variation Theory is a conceptual change in terms of the building of the discipline, which enables the study of Comparative Literature to transform from seeking homology to seeking heterogeneity. In other words, not only homology and affinity but also variation and heterogeneity should be the focus of the Variation Theory. Only when these aspects are organically combined together, will the discipline of Comparative Literature be satisfactorily built. The Variation Theory proposed by Chinese scholars is a great innovation and push to Chinese comparative theories and will exert great influence and value on the development of the world Comparative Literature.
Variations Studies in Comparative Literature

Cao Shunqing

2006-01-01

Abstract:Variations as a phenomenon exist in all literatures. Variations Studies in Comparative Literature, with variations in comparative literature as its object of studies, is advanced on the basis of deliberate considerations of the perplexities and issues arising out of the study and development of comparative literature as a discipline in China. Its values lie mainly in 1) that it helps promote the studies of relationships of literatures in the world; 2) that it helps put in order the disciplinary system of comparative literature and improve the structure of the textbooks in this field; and 3) that it clarifies and enriches the scope of comparability in comparative literature studies by advocating comparison of heterogeneity and otherness abased on cross - civilization studies, a complement of the traditional focus on the comparison of identity. Major research methods of Variations studies in comparative literature include studies of variations in language, in reception and in images.
The Academic Background and Theoretical Assumptions of the Theory of Variation of Comparative Literature

Cao Shunqing,Yu Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-7519.2008.03.019

2008-01-01

Abstract:The proposal of the Theory of Variation of Comparative Literature is a revolutionary change in the basic notion of comparative literature study in China. The present paper has tried to expound the proposal of this theory from the following three aspects: firstly, the proposal of this theory is to correct the misclassification of medio-translatology and imagology by integrating the disciplinary theories of comparative literature; secondly, this article sums up the core issue of academic research, differentiation, by reviewing deconstructionism and cross-civilization study; finally, this article takes heterogeneity as the basis of comparative study and puts forward that variation theory is to concentrate on heterogeneous elements in literary circulation and the variation phenomenon. In this way we may get a holistic consideration of all the elements in literary exchange on the basis of similarity and difference.
Variation Theory:A Breakthrough in Theorizing Comparative Literature Studies

CAO Shunqing,XU Huan

2010-01-01

Abstract:Although the French school proposed "influence study" and the American school proposed "parallel study" in international comparative literature studies,we should understand that the discipline of comparative literature is still incomplete.Concentrating on the variation in current comparative literature studies would be a major breakthrough,because it represents a new research perspective and method.It opens up a new possibility in theorizing comparative literature in the new stage,namely,heterogeneity and variability research.It not only highlights the differences between human civilizations thus but also promotes the heterogeneity of dialogues and exchanges among different civilizations,thus opening up a new possibility forthe development of literary history.From homogeneity to heterogeneity and to today’s variability,the theoretical exploration of comparative literature has gone much deeper in depth.It is not only a comparative study of literary theories,but also looks at the entire human culture toward another innovative goal.Therefore,proposed by Chinese comparatists,seeking "variations in comparative literature studies" will not only promote China’s comparative literature studies,but also contribute a great deal to the theorization of comparative literature in the new era.Thus the theorization of variation in comparative literature studies might well mark a new breakthrough in the development of comparative literature studies.
Variation Theory And The Reception Of Chinese Literature In The English-Speaking World

shunqing cao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7771/1481-4374.2599

2015-01-01

CLCWeb - Comparative Literature and Culture

Abstract:In his article "Variation Theory and the Reception of Chinese Literature in the English-speaking World" Shunqing Cao introduces "variation theory" he developed and suggests that the framework can be applied in studying the dissemination and reception of Chinese literature in the English-speaking world. Cao argues that cultural and literary differences produce variations in literary exchanges among different cultures and variation theory concentrates on these variations. With unique perspectives on variation in translation, cultural misreading, and domestication, variation theory is a useful theoretical framework and methodology for the study of the reception of Chinese literature in the English-speaking world.
Types and Validity of Cross-Civilization Studies in Comparative Literature from the Perspective of Variation Theory

Shun-qin CAO,Yi ZENG

2015-01-01

Abstract:Cross-civilization studies in comparative literature from the perspective of variation theory is classified into similarity comparison and difference comparison. The similarity comparison emphasizes “seeking similarities” on the basis of equal discourse rather than “assimilation” based on discourse coverage. And the difference comparison includes the influence variation in the influence study, the interpretation variation in the analogy study, and the new category of the analogy study-common topics in different discourse. The influence variation mainly focuses on the real but neglected variation factors in the influence study. The interpretation variation enriches the traditional analogy study in two aspects: the heterogeneity and two-way interaction of discourse, and the connotation analogy and over-interpretation of interpretive availability. Common topics in different discourse, a new category of the analogy study, is a breakthrough in analogy study on the dimension of heterogeneous discourse. All these cross-civilization studies make difference comparison valid, which enriches the theories of comparative literature, and is a comparison of “seeking both similarities and differences” in its true sense.
A New Orientation in Chinese-Western Comparative Literature: From Homogeneity to Variation

Wang Ning,Liu Tongyang

2023-01-01

Abstract:Variation theory is one of the original viewpoints put forward by China's comparatist Cao Shunqing. This shows that comparative literature studies, especially the study of Chinese-Western comparative literature, is no longer just a pursuit of convergence, but also an exploration of the differences between different national literatures. In this respect, Chinese literature and Western literature belong to two completely different cultural traditions, and the gap between languages is more than similarities, so the comparative study should seek its heterogeneity. Of course, we cannot deny that there is still a certain degree of convergence between different national literatures, but in this sense, especially for Chinese and Western literature, the convergence is only relative, heterogeneity is absolute. The emergence of the theory of variation would point to a possible new direction for international comparative literature studies, which is currently considered in crisis. This is also Cao Shunqing's contribution, as a Chinese comparatist, to the cross-cultural comparative literature studies.
The Variation:The Breakthrough in Theories of Comparative Literature

Cao shun-qing

2008-01-01

Abstract:This article dwells on the characteristics and the dilemma of the two schools of comparative literature,the French School and the American School,including the insufficiencies of their own.It also points out that there is lack of studies of the variability.It emphasizes that scholars must pay more attention to the heterogeneity and the variability,while noticing the similarities.The variation study in Comparative Literature embodies a new point of view,a new method and a new theory.It turns on a new phase which emphasizes the heterogeneity and the variability in Comparative Literature Theories. And it is a great breakthrough in Comparative Literature Theories all over the world.
VARIATION IN LITERATURE COMMUNICATION AND THE FORMATION OF WORLD LITERATURE

Shunqing Cao,Shuaidong Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5325/complitstudies.57.3.0475

2020-01-01

Comparative Literature Studies

Abstract:Abstract Starting with the fact that Chinese literature was absent from world literature in the twentieth century, this article reveals a contradiction in Johann Wolfgang Goethe's prediction. The line drawn between Chinese literature and world literature manifests a hierarchical structure of the existing world literature. Through a brief retrospective of Sino-Western cultural exchanges in history, we are led to the phenomenon of literary variation that usually appears when works circulate out of their original backgrounds, indicating the compatibility of heterogeneous literatures. From the perspective of Variation Theory, a new pattern of world literature's formation that differs from the core-periphery model or literary compromises may get inspired. Resorting to translative variation and thematic variation, works acquire worldness without sacrificing their national characteristics. In this case, world literature will be hopefully formed in comprehensive communications among different literatures.
The Research Field of Literary Variation in Comparative Literature

CAO Shun-qing,LI Wei-tao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0257-0289.2006.01.012

2006-01-01

Abstract:This paper posits that the study of literary variation that is newly proposed from a fresh perspective constitutes a potential research field of comparative literature.It analyses the theoretical bases of the proposed study of literary variation,and its relationship with the cross and literary characteristics of comparative literature.In the concluding part,it discriminates the research objects and the range of literary variation.
Cross-civilization Study of Comparative Literature—The Turn and Construction of the Discipline Theory of Comparative Literature

Shunqing Cao,Fu Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/25723618.2005.12015331

2005-01-01

Abstract:Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image size Additional informationNotes on contributorsShunqing CaoCao Shunqing, Ph. D., Dean and Professor, College of Literature and Journalism, Sichuan University. Vice-president of China Comparative Literatue Association and President of Sichuan Comparative Literature Association. One of leading scholars in the field of comparative literaty studies in Mainland China.
A Tentative Expansion of Variation Theory: A Case Study on “one Belt and One Road”

Shunqing Cao,Wenting Shi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/ajc.2016.42007

2016-01-01

Advances in Journalism and Communication

Abstract:Misunderstanding and misinterpretation are common existence when an item of news is put to its global distribution.On the basis of Variation Theory of Comparative Literature (VTCL) proposed by Chinese scholar Cao Shunqing, the present paper makes a case study on various international news reports on "One Road, One Belt" initiated by Chinese government in 2015.The aim of this study is on one hand to reveal how misunderstanding and misinterpretation happen during its circulation, and to test the feasibility of VTCL in the research of Mass Media on the other.The significance of such investigation lies in the construction of a new path to the sought of difference between heterogeneous cultures and further attempt to build up variation theory of communication.
Reexamining the Influence Studies in Comparative Literature from the Perspective of Variationology

Li Yan,Cao Shunqing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-6101.2006.04.001

2006-01-01

Abstract:By tracing the history of the lnfluence Study, this article analyzes the defect of this traditional method which leads to the conservative and provincial study in lack of cultural dialogue and communication.However, in the view of Variationolog, the Influence Study expands the thought space, reflects the variant phenomenon of literature communication. More importantly, builds a bridge of literary blending and complementing between different ethnics, which can help to form a more dynamic generation mechanism of literature.
The Legitimacy of Comparative Literature and the Variation Studies of Comparative Literature

Shunqing CAO,Ying LIU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/25723618.2012.12015545

2012-01-01

Abstract:Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image size Additional informationNotes on contributorsShunqing CAOShunqing CAO, Ph. D. professor and dean of College of Literature and Journalism, Sichuan University. He is also a Yangtze River Scholar under the Chinese Educational Ministry. Meanwhile he serves as Vice president of China Comparative Literature Association, president of Sichuan Comparative Literature Association. His major interests cover comparative literary studies and classical Chinese literary theory.
Heterogeneity, Variation and Domestic Appropriation of Cross-civilization Literary Theories

Shun-qing CAO

2016-01-01

Abstract:During the dialogue among cross-civilization literary theories, the co-existence of different literary theories will appear, and then the variation and even the domestic appropriation will be developed. By summarizing existing experience, we should clearly know that domestic appropriation is a significant law of the development of culture and literary theories. And the sinofication of western literary theories must highlight the key point which is about centering on Chinese academic rules. The sinofication of western literary theories and meeting the needs of China are closely related. And the basic ways to the sinofication of western literary theories are not only the dialogue among heterogenous literary theories and the activation of newly elements of literary theories, but also the interaction among similar heterogenous literary theories and the creative misreading of heterogenous literary theories. Moreover, the dialogue among heterogenous literary theories has two fundamental? principles—the independence of discourse and equal dialogue, and three main approaches—different discourses with common topics, different discourses with common context and the dialogue in the translation of discourses. All in all, the heterogeneity, variation and domestic appropriation laws of cross-civilization literary theories are important to the development of literary theories in different countries and even of world literary theories.
Cross-civilization Studies:Keep Pace with the Orientation of the Academic World and the Academic Frontiers

CAO Shun-qing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-778x.2005.04.013

2005-01-01

Abstract:Cross-civilization studies has become an academic trend all over the world with an emphasis on the heterogeneity of different civilizations. The cross-civilization studies in comparative literature has the mutual complement as its ultimate goal while interpreting the heterogeneity of different civilizations. Cross-civilization studies is different from the ideological trend of globalization because it pursues the cultural ideal of “generality in differences” or “generality with differences”. At present, three problems as the academic frontiers can help promote the cross-civilization studies in Chinese comparative literature: 1. the theoretical problem of “Lendingism” or “discovery of the Orient and export of (our) culture; 2. the problems in comparative poetics concerning the convertibility and the un-convertibility of heterogeneous civilizations; 3. “aphasia” of Chinese culture viewed from the perspective of cross-civilization studies.
Variation Studies of Literary Dissemination: the Image of China Anddee Goong an (di Gong An)

Siyu Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/25723618.2020.1782025

2020-01-01

Abstract:Variation studies of literary dissemination, based on the Variation Theory of Comparative Literature, focuses on the heterogeneity and variability in the process of cross-national literary communication, exchange and influence. This paper uses Variation Theory, and elucidates the variation phenomenon when different literatures disseminate and influence each other before proposing the method of variation studies of literary dissemination. Detailed discussions are divided into two categories of case analysis. Firstly, the images of China shown in Western literature experience changes from positive to negative in different periods due to historical milieu, ideology and writers' personal viewpoints etc. Secondly, the literary textDee Goong An(Di Gong An) undergoes "China-the West-China" and "Chinese-English-Chinese" circulation. In such a cyclical influence, the text, the image of Judge Dee and Chinese detective novels all experience several instances of recreation and variation, showing that cultural context, readers' esthetic reception and linguistic variations etc. influence the dissemination of literary texts. Case analysis illustrates that this method conforms to the core idea of Variation Theory, transforming from simply seeking the sameness to filling in the gaps of differences. Thus, a new method is provided for the studies of cross-cultural literary communication.

The Variation Theory of Comparative Literature and the Cross-Civilization Studies

Variation Theory: A Breakthrough in Research of World Comparative Literature Theory

The Theoretical Basis and Framework of Variation Theory

On Research and Application of Variation Theory of Comparative Literature in China

The legitimacy of comparison between eastern and western literatures and proposal of comparative literary variation

Variations Studies in Comparative Literature

The Academic Background and Theoretical Assumptions of the Theory of Variation of Comparative Literature

Variation Theory:A Breakthrough in Theorizing Comparative Literature Studies

Variation Theory And The Reception Of Chinese Literature In The English-Speaking World

Types and Validity of Cross-Civilization Studies in Comparative Literature from the Perspective of Variation Theory

A New Orientation in Chinese-Western Comparative Literature: From Homogeneity to Variation

The Variation:The Breakthrough in Theories of Comparative Literature

VARIATION IN LITERATURE COMMUNICATION AND THE FORMATION OF WORLD LITERATURE

The Research Field of Literary Variation in Comparative Literature

Cross-civilization Study of Comparative Literature—The Turn and Construction of the Discipline Theory of Comparative Literature

A Tentative Expansion of Variation Theory: A Case Study on “one Belt and One Road”

Reexamining the Influence Studies in Comparative Literature from the Perspective of Variationology

The Legitimacy of Comparative Literature and the Variation Studies of Comparative Literature

Heterogeneity, Variation and Domestic Appropriation of Cross-civilization Literary Theories

Cross-civilization Studies:Keep Pace with the Orientation of the Academic World and the Academic Frontiers

Variation Studies of Literary Dissemination: the Image of China Anddee Goong an (di Gong An)