Abstract:Summary An approach to numerically simulate ice accretion on airfoils has been developed and used to characterize ice accretion on a NACA0012 airfoil. In this paper we present the background and motivation for the investigation, the techniques used, and then the main results are presented. The validation of the simulation approach developed in this paper is also discussed. Finally, the conclusions are presented based on our analysis of the results presented. BACKGROUND INTRODUCTION Ice accretion on airplane wings can be a hazard to flight safety. The cause of the accretion is due to supercooled water droplets impinging to the windward face of the wings. Ice accretion can modify the designed aerodynamic shape of airfoils and considerably degrade their aerodynamic performance. Thus, being able to evaluate the mechanisms and consequences of ice accretion is of great importance to anti-icing and de-icing. Different icing conditions form different type of ice accretions. Depending on the icing mechanism, ice accretions can be classified as: rime ice, glaze ice or mixed ice. Rime ice occurs in a low temperature environment and forms because supercooled droplets freeze simultaneously when they impinge onto the airfoil surface. Glaze ice occurs in an environment with relatively high temperature (while still lower than freezing point) under which the droplets freeze partially at the impingement location and then freeze gradually during the flow along the airfoil surface caused by airflow. Mixed ice is defined as a mixture of rime and glaze ice. Glaze ice and mixed ice can corrupt the designed aerodynamic shape of airfoils more significantly than rime ice. These forms of ice accretion can be investigated by several means, including flight test, experimental simulation, engineering method and numerical simulation. Flight test and experimental simulation can obtain exact ice shape but are usually too expensive to be widely adopted. The engineering method uses the typical experimental data and empirical formulae but could hardly analyze the ice accretion process. Therefore, numerical simulation is widely adopted because it is economical and can simulate the icing process and so provide a relatively exact evaluation of ice accretion. Several codes for simulating ice accretion have been developed internationally, such as: LEWICE (USA), ONERA (France), DRA (UK), FENSAP-ICE (Canada), CIRAMIL (Italy). TECHNIQUES DESCRIPTION This paper develops an approach to numerically simulate ice accretion on airfoils which is based on four modules: (1) air flowfield solution, (2) droplets collection efficiency calculation, (3) boundary layer characteristics evaluation, and (4) ice accumulation evaluation via a thermodynamic model. Air flowfield solution The air flowfield can be obtained by using the panel method to solve the Euler equations or directly solving the compressible Navier-Stokes equations. The panel method can calculate the air velocity at any point in the flowfield directly but usually lacks accuracy in computing the complete flowfield. In contrast, the solution of the compressible Navier-Stokes equations can provide a more accurate flowfield computation but is time consuming. In order to synthetically consider the computational precision and efficiency, an Euler flow computation is adopted in this paper. Droplets collection efficiency calculation The droplets’ collection efficiency on the airfoil surface is important in numerically simulating ice accretion and two computational methods are available: Lagrangian and Eulerian two-phase flows methods. The Lagrangian method obtains the collection efficiency by solving the motion equation of droplets to track each droplet’s trajectory in the flowfield. Eulerian two-phase flow methods consider the droplets in the airflow as a form of pseudo fluid which interpenetrates with the air and the collection efficiency is obtained through solving the velocity and apparent density distribution of droplets. There are advantages in using the Eulerian two-phase flow method compared with a Lagrangian approach since the same mesh can be used to solve the governing equations for the airflow and droplets. Also, the droplets’ collection efficiency may be obtained based on the solution of the droplets’ flowfield directly, meaning that particles don’t have to be tracked. For these reasons the Eulerian two-phase flows method has been adopted here.

Performance Deterioration of Pitot Tubes Caused by In-Flight Ice Accretion: A Numerical Investigation

Numerical Simulation Of Airfoil Icing And Analysis Its Effects On Aerodynamic Performance

Influence of Air Flow Field Computation on an Ice Accretion Simulation of Airfoils

Insight into Rime Ice Accretion on an Aircraft Wing and Corresponding Effects on Aerodynamic Performance

Numerical Investigation of Airfoil Ice Accumulation: Ice Shape and Ice Crack Propagation

Numerical simulation of icing effect on aerodynamic characteristics of a wind turbine blade

Aerodynamic prediction and roughness implementation toward ice accretion simulation

Numerical Simulation of Airfoil Aerodynamic Performance under the Coupling Effects of Heavy Rain and Ice Accretion

A Numerical Study of Droplet Impingement for In-Flight Ice Accretion Prediction

An Experimental Investigation on the Unsteady Heat Transfer Process over an Ice Accreting NACA 0012 Airfoil

Aerodynamic Performance Degradation Induced by Ice Accretion. PIV Technique Assessment in Icing Wind Tunnel

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF ICE ACCRETION ON AIRFOILS

An Experimental Investigation on the Dynamic Glaze Ice Accretion Process over a Wind Turbine Airfoil Surface

Numerical Study of Mixed Phase Ice Accumulation in Aero-Engine Inlet System

Numerical Simulation of Glaze Ice Accretions on an Airfoil

Numerical Investigations on Aero-Engine Icing Characteristics at Mixed Phase Conditions

An experimental study on the aerodynamic performance degradation of a wind turbine blade model induced by ice accretion process

Experimental measurement and analytical method for critical temperature of aircraft icing detection failure

Numerical Simulation of Ice Accretions on an Aircraft Wing

Numerical and Experimental Investigations into Protection Net Icing at the Helicopter Engine Inlet

An Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ice Accretion Process on a Wind Turbine Airfoil Model Considering Various Icing Conditions