Conceptual Analysis of Legal Behavior, Civil Behavior and Civil Law Behavior--Inspiration on the Compilation of General Provisions of Civil Law

Kuan WANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-7504.2015.05.013
2015-01-01
Abstract:The argument of whether it is legitimate or not in related law in our country and in Rus?sia confuses legitimacy of legal behavior with its effectiveness. In fact, the establishment of legal be?havior is not based on illegitimacy; it lies in the element to judge its legitimacy and the effective el?ement decides its effectiveness; there is no relation between legal behavior and its legitimacy and“ef?fectiveness”reveals more the nature of legal behavior than“legitimacy”. Russian Civil Law inherits that of Germany and due to ideological and economic need, Russia replaces self governing of private law with state will and regards legal behavior as behavior abiding the law. Our General Provisions of Civil Law replaces“behavior abiding the law”with“civil behavior”and“civil law behavior”, which is not suitable, leads to many transformation in practice and is criticized by scholars. It is illuminat?ing to delete ineffective legal behavior (civil behavior) and define neutrality and suitability of legal behavior. Future regulation of legal behavior in General Provisions of Civil Law will decide way of life of this country and this nation and legalists should work for it.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?