THE INFLUENCE OF THE CONCEPT OF THE SPIRIT OF LAWS ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF MODERN CIVIL SUBSTANTIVE, AS WELL AS CIVIL AND ARBITRATION PROCEDURAL LAW

V.N. KOVAL
DOI: https://doi.org/10.24031/2226-0781-2022-12-1-23-39
2022-04-15
Herald of Civil Procedure
Abstract:It is customary to criticize legal science for its sufficient distance from practice. In turn, the law enforcement officer is often reproached by theorists. This article is a modest attempt to unite the opposing sides and show that the thesis stated above does not correspond to reality. Based on the most general theoretical positions, the author of this work examines in detail real trials and proves that they are based not only on a strict legal norm, but also on the spirit of the law. The judge, being in a constant difficult situation of choosing the side that is right, making the final decision, is based primarily on his legal consciousness, and it, as will be shown later, corresponds to theoretical concepts, legal traditions, established ethical rules of judicial practice. Due to the specifics of their research interests, decisions on civil law cases considered in the framework of civil and arbitration protsesses were chosen. General scientific methods of deduction and induction, analysis and synthesis were used to prepare this work. In order to enhance the objectivity of the results obtained, the method of expert assessments was used. Interpretation and modeling made it possible to trace the logic of the law enforcer and evaluate it for compliance with the spirit of the law.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?