Abstract:There are two main reasons why the subject matter of physics might be thought ontologically prior to that of chemistry. The first is mereological: properties of wholes depend in some way on the properties of their parts. The second line of thought is that the science of physics is unique in that it aims at full coverage. Since physical laws cover everything, including chemical systems and their parts, if possession of a chemical property confers genuine causal powers, this must be in virtue of some relationship that that chemical property bears to some property that falls under a physical law. Both these considerations are empirical, and are also supported historically by the close interaction between the two disciplines that began in the nineteenth century, when physical methods of investigation like spectroscopy began to be accepted in chemistry. The classical models of intertheoretic reduction are now widely rejected by philosophers, but this chapter considers how well they fit the relationship between physics and chemistry, if only because they are so well understood. The central point is that the failure of the explanatory relationship between physical and chemical theories to fit some model of intertheoretic reduction does not settle the question of whether chemistry is reducible “in principle.” There are many reasons why intertheoretic reductions can fail that are independent of “in principle” reducibility, including mathematical intractability, complexity and conceptual mismatch between different sciences. The chapter also concentrates on the ontological issues, which promise a more direct approach to the question of reducibility in principle.

Hume's Reductionism of Testimony: Hot Water and Way Out

Testimonial Evidence and Its Definition

A Feminist Interpretation of Hume on Testimony

The Controversy Between Meaning Holism and Epistemological Reductionism on the View of "Convention"

Consciousness in the Modern World View and Its Philosophical Hard Problem

A Philosophical Analysis of the Concept of "Reduction"

Pragmatic Commitments to Naturalized Epistemology

The Concept of Evidence: Its History of Evolution and Its Epistemological Reconstruction

Reductionism and its heuristics: Making methodological reductionism honest

HOLISM, INDIVIDUALISM, REDUCTIONISM

Holism versus Reductionism in Modern Social Science Research

Reductionism and holistic medicine

The history of reductionism versus holistic approaches to scientific research

Holism and Reductionism - A Daoist Explanation

Quantum Field Theory and the Limits of Reductionism

Reduction and Construction——Interpreting The Idea of Phenomenology

Complexity theory for complexity reduction? Revisiting the ontological and epistemological basis of complexity science with Critical Realism

Reduction, Emergence and Physicalism

David Hume’s Notion of Perception and his Problem with Causality

The Inconsistencies in Wang Chong's Lunheng Eliminated in the Light of Analogical Reasoning

Dennett's “Heterophenomenology”