Abstract:Duncan Pritchard recently proposed a Wittgensteinian solution to closure-based skepticism. According to Wittgenstein, all epistemic systems assume certain truths. The notions that we are not disembodied brains, that the Earth has existed for a long time and that one’s name is such-and-such all function as “hinge commitments.” Pritchard views a hinge commitment as a positive propositional attitude that is not a belief. Because closure principles concern only knowledge-apt beliefs, they do not apply to hinge commitments. Thus, from the fact that a subject knows that he is sitting in a room, and the fact that the subject’s sitting in a room entails his bodily existence, it does not follow that the subject also knows that he is not an envatted brain. This paper rejects Pritchard’s non-belief reading of hinge commitments. I start by showing that the non-belief reading fails to solve the skeptical paradox because the reasons that Pritchard uses to support the non-belief reading do not exempt hinge propositions from closure principles. I then proceed to argue that the non-belief reading is false as it claims that hinge commitments, unlike ordinary beliefs, are rationally unresponsive—with the help of a scenario in which a subject’s experience is internally chaotic, we can safely conclude that the hinge commitment that one is not systematically mistaken about the world is equally responsive to one’s evidential situations.

Pragmatic Commitments to Naturalized Epistemology

Cooperative Naturalism

Naturalized Epistemology:From Method to Content

Dennett's “Heterophenomenology”

The Two Dogmas of Naturalism

Logical Given, Interactive Negotiation and Self-Denial of Self-Consciousness-Hegelian Pragmatism in Contemporary Analytic Philosophy and Its Critique

Putnam on Terms of Natural Kinds——On Essentialism in Contemporary Logic Philosophical Vision

The Controversy Between Meaning Holism and Epistemological Reductionism on the View of "Convention"

A Critique to Richard Rorty's Conception of Knowledge--And On the Pragmatics Turn of Epistemology

Two Approaches to Expand Epistemology

Closure, Deduction and Hinge Commitments

Coordination and Regression:Reconstruction in Research Program of Naturalized Epistemology

The Expansion of Epistemology: the Metaphysical Vs. the Practical Approach

Epistemology and social work: enhancing the integration of theory, practice and research through philosophical pragmatism

The Naturalized and Normative Approach of Scientific Philosophy

Contemporary Information Science Thought：Pragmatism

A New Concept of Pragmatics: A Perspective on Language and Adaptation Theory

The Philosophy of Scientific Practice in Naturalist Thought: Its Approaches and Problems

Pritchard on Ignorance and Normativity

Ethnopragmatics:A New Perspective on Pragmatic Study

How Could Chinese Thinking Modes Integrate into Contemporary Western Epistemology? -A Hybrid Perspective of Both AI and the Confucian Theory of the Rectification of Names