Abstract:Special issues are a unique mode of scholarly communication designed to highlight essential or emerging research themes through high-quality manuscripts. Special issues are increasingly becoming a fixture across a wide range of disciplines. Yet whether publishing special issues is necessarily a beneficial practice remains controversial. In this paper, we explore whether the actual effect of special issues meets the academic community's expectations, which is to enhance citation impact and highlight important research topics. Our sample, which comprises all special issue articles in all disciplines published between 2008 and 2017, reveals that there has been a proliferation of special issues across countries, institutions, and journals, with some differences among the disciplines. Opportunities to appear in special issues are more given to countries/institutions that achieved the highest overall research output. The effectiveness of special issues in promoting academic development varies across disciplines and even across journals. Honing in on library and information science as a case area to explore citation impacts and the topic distribution of special issues, we find that many special issues present high-impact manuscripts, especially those of the less prominent journals. However, the issue of publishing low impact manuscripts through special issues also exists in many fields. Special issues are also more likely to publish interdisciplinary or cross-disciplinary articles and rarely discussed research themes compared to regular issues. Further, such topics are seldom explored on a large scale in the normal editions of the journal. To ensure the quality of the manuscripts, we recommend optimizing the procedures for selecting special issue topics and reviewing submissions.

Procedure and Practice of Publishing Special Issues for Sci-tech Periodicals

Practice and experience of editing special issues for Chinese scientific journals: taking Chinese Journal of Biotechnology as an example

Exploring the characteristics of special issues: distribution, topicality, and citation impact

Four steps to realize effective peer review of academics journals published in China

Special Topic on Conservation Biology of Endangered Wildlife Pushes Conservation Studies

Preface for Publication of the Special Issue of I3S 2004

Special Issue On Computation, Business, And Health Science

Special Issue "Construction Materials and Other Related Materials: Basic Theory, Applied Technology and Advanced Research Methods"

Publishing Research in China: History, Characteristics, and Challenges

Editorial for Special Issue “advances in Hyperspectral Data Exploitation”

Shortening publication frequency—a good method to serve authors

Special Issue "Process Safety in Coal Mining"

WHICH ACADEMIC JOURNALS DO SCIENTISTS PREFER?—As a Sample Sponsored by Special Grant for Key Academic Journals of NSFC—10 Years Viewing of J of Zhejiang University-SCIENCE(A/B/C)

Several Problems about "consistency" Need to Be Concerned in Editing of Sci-Tech Journals

Analyses of hot research spots on sci-tech periodicals' diversified development

Special Issue on "green Chemical Process and Intensification"

Special Issue "Research on Process System Engineering"

Origin,Influence and Obstacles about Online Publication of Sci-tech Papers

Editorial for the Special Issue on Advances in Ultra-Precision Machining Technology and Applications

Digital publishing practice of Hepatobiliary & Pancreatic Diseases International

Dhanalakshmi Srinivasan College of Arts and Science for Women - A Special Issue