Abstract:Abstract Although the differentiation of clades at the species level is usually based on a justifiable and testable conceptual framework, the demarcation of supraspecific boundaries is less objective and often subject to differences of opinion. The increased availability of large-scale phylogenies has in part promulgated a practice of what we consider excessively splitting clades at the “genus” level. Many of these new genus-level splits are predicated on untenable supporting evidence (e.g., weakly supported phylogenies and purportedly “diagnostic” but actually variable, non-exclusive, or otherwise problematic opposing character state differences) without careful consideration of the effects on downstream applications. As case studies, we critically evaluate several recent examples of splitting established monophyletic genera in four amphibian families that resulted in the creation/elevation of 20 genus-level names (Dicroglossidae: Phrynoglossus , Oreobatrachus , Frethia split from Occidozyga ; Microhylidae: Nanohyla split from Microhyla ; Ranidae: Abavorana , Amnirana , Chalcorana , Humerana , Hydrophylax , Indosylvirana , Papurana , Pulchrana , Sylvirana split from Hylarana ; Rhacophoridae: Tamixalus , Vampyrius , Leptomantis , Zhangixalus split from Rhacophorus , Rohanixalus split from Feihyla , Orixalus split from Gracixalus , and Taruga split from Polypedates ), and also address the taxonomic status of the monotypic genus Pterorana relative to Hylarana . We reassess the original claims of diagnosability and justifications for splitting and argue that in many cases, the generic splitting of clades is not only unnecessary but also destabilizes amphibian taxonomy, leading to a host of downstream issues that affect categories of the user community (stakeholders such as taxonomists, conservationists, evolutionary biologists, biogeographers, museum curators, educators, and the lay public). As an alternative, we advocate for the use of the subgenus rank in some cases, which can be implemented to establish informative partitions for future research without compromising on information content, while avoiding gratuitous (and often transient) large-scale binomial (genus-species couplet) rearrangements. We encourage taxonomists to consider the actual needs and interests of the larger non-taxonomic end-user community who fund the majority of taxonomic research, and who require a system that remains reasonably stable and is relatively intuitive, without the need for inaccessible laboratory equipment or advanced technical scientific knowledge to identify amphibian species to the genus level.

Molecular Phylogenetics of Amphibians and Reptiles

Phylogeny Reconstruction in the Study of Molecular Evolution

Phylogentic Relationships of Living Amphibians among Three Orders Based on the Mitochondrial Trna Genes

Phylogenomics Reveals Ancient Gene Tree Discordance in the Amphibian Tree of Life

Integrated Analyses Resolve Conflicts over Squamate Reptile Phylogeny and Reveal Unexpected Placements for Fossil Taxa

Nested Species Subsets of Amphibians and Reptiles in Thousand Island Lake

Studing progress on molecular evolution of proteid of reptiles

Phylogenetic relationships of the Chinese torrent frogs (Ranidae: Amolops) revealed by phylogenomic analyses of AFLP-Capture data

Advances in Molecular Ecology of Marine Mammals.

DNA Fingerprinting Analysis of Some Species of Hynobiidae Genera and a Discuss of Their Classification

Comparative Mitogenomics of True Frogs (Ranidae, Anura), and Its Implications for the Phylogeny and Evolutionary History of Rana

Genome Evolution and the Future of Phylogenomics of Non-Avian Reptiles

Evolutionary Landscape of Amphibians Emerging from Ancient Freshwater Fish Inferred from Complete Mitochondrial Genomes.

Molecular Phylogeny and Diversification of the Genus Odorrana (amphibia, Anura, Ranidae) Inferred from Two Mitochondrial Genes

Molecular Markers, Natural History and Evolution

Molecular technology in paleontology and paleobiology: Applications and limitations

Integrated phylogenetic analyses reveal the evolutionary, biogeographic, and diversification history of Asian warty treefrog genus Theloderma (Anura, Rhacophoridae)

Unnecessary splitting of genus-level clades reduces taxonomic stability in amphibians

Phylogeny of Twenty-One Mammals

[Recent progress in plant molecular population genetics]

Insights into phylogenetic positions and distribution patterns: Complete mitogenomes of two sympatric Asian horned toads in Boulenophrys (Anura: Megophryidae)