Finite element analysis on the femoral revision with two types of revision hip stems

Lei YANG,Yue WANG,Yang-yang YANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-6170.2018.02.005
2018-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the stress distribution on the femur after femoral revision for bone defect using extensively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stems and tapered fluted titanium stems.Methods The 3D solid models of the femur,exten-sively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stems and tapered fluted titanium stems was established through software Mimics, Geomagic Studio and Solidworks.In SolidWorks,type IIA,IIB,IIC and IIIA femur bone defect models were established according to the Parprosky classification.Then,2 types of prosthesis and 4 different degree of bone defect model were assembled together to obtain 8 fem-oral revision models that were divided into extensively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stem group and tapered fluted titanium stem group.Finally,femoral revision models were imported to ANSYS Workbench for finite element analysis.von Mises stress value of femur was compared.Results Under the condition of the same degree of bone defect,tapered fluted titanium stem group had higher von Mises stress value than extensively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stems group in bone defect regions(P<0.05).Be-sides,Von Mises stress was distributed more regularly in upper and middle femur in tapered fluted titanium stem group while extensively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stems group showed uneven.Furthermore,there was stress concentration at the distal area of the porous coating region in extensively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stems group while it was not observed in the tapered fluted titanium stem group.Conclusion Extensively porous-coated cylindrical cobalt-chromium stems have more serious stress shiel-ding in bone defect zone and stress concentration at the distal part when compared to tapered fluted titanium stem.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?