The Comparison for Various Kinds of Internal Fixations of Intertrochanteric Hip Fractures
张经纬,蒋垚,张先龙,冯建翔,杨立峰,赵刘军,吴志军,黄雷,曾炳芳
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/j.issn:0253-2352.2005.01.002
2005-01-01
Abstract:Objective To explore the significance of optional internal fixations of intertrochanteric hip fractures by comparing the effects of various kinds of internal fixations. Methods From February 1998 to May 2003, 169 cases with intertrochanteric hip fractures were followed up. They were treated with the followed four kinds of operations respectively: angled blade plate (group A), dynamic hip screw (DHS, group B), Gamma nail (group C), proximal femoral nail(PFN, group D). The data of each group were collected for statistical analysis on the following aspects: operative time, blood loss, intraoperative complications, fluoroscopy exposures, drainage, clinical healing time of fracture, post-operative restored function and complications. Results The differences of the operative time, blood loss, fluoroscopy exposures, drainage and clinical healing time between group A, B and group C, D were of statistical significance(P 0.01). In comparing with group A, B, group C, D was of shorter operative time and clinical healing time, fewer blood loss and drainage, but of more fluoroscopy exposures. The differences of intraoperative complications between group A, B, D and group C were of statistical significance(P 0.05), group C was of higher rate of intraoperative complications. The differences of the post-operative restored function between group A and group B, C, D were significant in statistics(P 0.01), group A was less satisfactory. The differences in post-operative complications between all groups were of no statistical significance(P 0.05). Conclusion By comparison, for type ⅠA and ⅠB, angled plate, DHS, Gamma nail and PFN are all applicable. For type Ⅱ and Ⅲ, Gamma nail and PFN are suitable. For some cases of type Ⅱ and Ⅲ in which the outer cortical bone for insertion are intact, DHS combined with tension band or buttress plate of major trochanter is suggestive. The intertrochanteric fracture plane showing a coronal position can not use angled blade plate and DHS, but Gamma nail and PFN are appropriate. For reversed intertrochanteric fracture, angled blade plate, Gamma nail and PFN all can be used.