Clinical outcome comparison of treating unstable intertrochanteric fracture by proximal femoral nail anti-rotation with dynamid hip screw and trochanter stabilizing plate
ZHANG Dao-jian,CHAI Wei-bing,MI Chuan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3977/j.issn.1005-8478.2012.16.06
2012-01-01
Abstract:[Objective]To compare the clinical outcome of treating the unstable intertrochanteric fracture by PFNA(proximal femoral nail anti-rotation) with DHS+TSP(dynamic hip screw+trochanter stablizing plate).[Method]Forty-seven patients admitted for unstable intertrochanteric fracture(AO classicification A2 type) who could be followed up during January 2004 and August 2008 were reviewed.Twenty-four patients were treated with PFNA as internal fixation,while the other twenty-three patients were treated with DHS+TSP as internal fixation.The operate time,blood loss during the operation,the time of lying in bed post operation,the function of the hip joint were compared,the function were compared by Harris assessment system.The condition of the bone union were obeserved.Patients were followed up at 1 week,three months,six months and 1 year post operation.The clinical outcome was assessed and the reason of the complications of each patient was analyzed.[Result]The mean operate time of PFNA group were 113±29 min,the mean blood loss during the operation were 135±85ml,the mean Harris score post operation were 89±3,one patient complained of cutting out of the femoral head by the blade,no patients complained for varus of hip joint,the patients all got bone union,the mean union time were 5±1 months.The mean operate time of DHS+TSP group were 156±35 min,blood loss during the operation were 429±266 ml,the mean post operation Harris score were 84±6.One patient died of pulmonary infection post-operation and two patients complained about over slide of the compress nail in the femoral head which were treated by postpone the time for the patient to leave bed.For unstable intertrochanteric fracture,compared with DHS+TSP,the operate time was shorter P=0.002(P<0.05),the time of lying in bed was shorter P=0.000(P<0.05),the blood loss during operation was less in the group of using PFNA P=0.001(P<0.05),the hip joint Harris score was higher P=0.006(P<0.05).[Conclusion]PFNA is a good choice to treat unstable intertrochanteric fracture.It is superior to DHS+TSP.It is easy to use,with minimal soft tissue injured,stable in fixation of the bone fragment,and with few complications and the patient could return to walk soon after the operation.