Abstract:BackgroundShock is common in critically ill and injured patients. Survival during shock is highly dependent on rapid restoration of tissue oxygenation with therapeutic goals based on cardiac output (CO) optimization. Despite the clinical availability of numerous minimally invasive monitors of CO, limited supporting performance data are available.MethodsFollowing approval of the University of Saskatchewan Animal Research Ethics Board, we assessed the performance and trending ability of PiCCOplus™, FloTrac™, and CardioQ-ODM™ across a range of CO states in pigs. In addition, we assessed the ability of invasive mean arterial blood pressure (iMAP) to follow changes in CO using a periaortic transit-time flow probe as the reference method. Statistical analysis was performed with function-fail, bias and precision, percent error, and linear regression at all flow, low-flow (> 1 standard deviation [SD] below the mean), and high-flow (> 1 SD above the mean) CO conditions.ResultsWe made a total of 116,957 paired CO measurements. The non-invasive CO monitors often failed to provide a CO value (CardioQ-ODM: 40.6% failed measurements; 99% confidence interval [CI], 38.5 to 42.6; FloTrac: 9.6% failed measurements; 99% CI, 8.7 to 10.5; PiCCOplus: 4.7% failed measurements; 99% CI, 4.5 to 4.9; all comparisons, P < 0.001). The invasive mean arterial pressure provided zero failures, failing less often than any of the tested CO monitors (all comparisons, P < 0.001). The PiCCOplus was most interchangeable with the flow probe at all flow states: PiCCOplus (20% error; 99% CI, 19 to 22), CardioQ-ODM (25% error; 99% CI, 23 to 27), FloTrac (34% error; 99% CI, 32 to 38) (all comparisons, P < 0.001). At low-flow states, CardioQ-ODM (43% error; 99% CI, 32 to 63) and Flotrac (45% error; 99% CI, 33 to 70) had similar interchangeability (P = 0.07), both superior to PiCCOplus (48% error; 99% CI, 42 to 60) (P < 0.001). Regarding CO trending, the CardioQ-ODM (correlation coefficient, 0.82; 99% CI, 0.81 to 0.83) was statistically superior to other monitors including iMAP, but at low flows iMAP (correlation coefficient, 0.58; 99% CI, 0.58 to 0.60) was superior to all minimally invasive CO monitors (all comparisons P < 0.001).ConclusionsNone of the minimally invasive monitors of CO performed well at all tested flows. Invasive mean arterial blood pressure most closely tracked CO change at critical flow states.

Agreement between transpulmonary thermodilution and pulmonary artery catheter thermodilution cardiac output measurements in pigs

OP02.02: Quantitative Comparison of Cardiac Performance Index Derived from a Novel Automatic Method and Traditional Technique in Normal Fetuses

Assessment of Cardiac Output and Volume Load by Transpulmonary Thermodilution Technique in Immature Pigs.

Validation of Cardiac Output Measurement by Ultrasound Dilution Technique With Pulmonary Artery Thermodilution in a Pediatric Animal Model

Accuracy of continuous thermodilution cardiac output measurement during liver transplantation

Correlation, agreement and concordance of cardiac output estimated by transthoracic ultrasound and transesophageal Doppler with pulmonary artery thermodilution in anesthetized cats

Comparison of noninvasive cardiac output and stroke volume measurements using electrical impedance tomography with invasive methods in a swine model

Agreement between Electrical Cardiometry and Pulmonary Artery Thermodilution for Measuring Cardiac Output in Isoflurane-Anesthetized Dogs

A comparison of hemodynamic measurement methods during orthotopic liver transplantation: evaluating agreement and trending ability of PiCCO versus pulmonary artery catheter techniques

Validation of capnodynamic determination of cardiac output by measuring effective pulmonary blood flow: a study in anaesthetised children and piglets

Comparison of Ultrasonic Cardiac Output Monitor and Pulse Indicated Continuous Cardiac Output Monitor on Determination of Hemodynamic Parameters in Critical Patients

Validation of the Use of Foreign Gas Rebreathing Method for Non-Invasive Determination of Cardiac Output in Heart Disease Patients

The Effect of Different Position and Positive End-expiratory Pressure on Cardiac Preload in Pigs with Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome

Continuous Cardiac Output Measurements with Transesophageal Doppler Echocardiography Versus Swan-Ganz Catheterization

Comparison of accuracy of two uncalibrated pulse contour cardiac output monitors in off-pump coronary artery bypass surgery patients using pulmonary artery catheter-thermodilution as a reference

Indirect cardiac output assessment in a swine pediatric acute respiratory distress syndrome model

A performance comparison of the most commonly used minimally invasive monitors of cardiac output

Comparison of methods of temperature measurement in swine

Haemodynamic monitoring after paediatric cardiac surgery using echocardiography and PiCCO

The Equilibration of PCO2 in Pigs Is Independent of Lung Injury and Hemodynamics

Accuracy of oscillometric blood pressure measurement using a Cardell Touch multiparameter monitor in anesthetized pigs