Abstract:After the Meiji Restoration in 1868, Japan rapidly industrialized, greatly raising its level of economic productivity. However, the peasants were kept in a state of hunger under a semifeudal agricultural system. How should this semi-feudality be understood? About this question arose a debate among Japanese Marxists in prewar Japan: the Debate on Japanese Capitalism. This article examines the methodologies of three analysists of Japanese capitalism focusing on the level of abstraction of the analysis of capitalism, whose ideas were derived from Hegel’s Logic and Marx’s methodology of downward analysis and upward development: Moritarō Yamada of Kōzaha, Itsurō Sakisaka of Rōnōha, and Kōzō Uno, who distanced himself from both sides. Uno criticized Yamada and Sakisaka for directly analyzing a particular Japanese capitalism with a highly general theory such as Capital, and proposed the Three-Stage Theory: the Pure Theory, which is based on the assumption of a pure capitalism, such as Marx’s Capital; the Stage Theory, which clarifies the historical developmental stage of capitalism, such as Lenin’s Imperialism (1917); and the Empirical Analysis, which analyzes capitalism in each country at a given time. However, Uno’s main concern was to analyze Japanese capitalism in the Stage Theory, doing little to further advance it in the Empirical Analysis. Therefore, this article divided the Empirical Analysis into two levels of abstraction: the domain of theoretical construction of Japanese Capitalism, such as Lenin’s Development of Capitalism in Russia (1899), and of data analysis of specific conditions of Japanese capitalism, such as Engels’ The Condition of the Working Class in England (1844), and thus proposed the Four-Stage Theory. It is a hypothesis for complementing Uno’s Three-Stage Theory, which should be further developed by data. Finally, such methodological consideration for analyzing capitalism is applicable to non-Japanese capitalist societies.

Marx-Okishio System and Perron-Frobenius Theorem

A Logical Evolution of Marx's Conception on Burgher Society

From Marx's fundamental equalities to the solving of the transformation problem -- Coherence of the model

Marx-Sraffa Equilibria and Eigenvalue Problems : A Moore-Penrose Pseudoinverse Approach

The Transformation from Value Determination to Value Realization: the Logical Dilemma of the Okishio Theorem

Marx's Achievements in His Criticism of Proudhon——an Analysis on the Significance of The Poverty of Theory

THE DIALECTICAL PRESENTATION OF THE GENERAL NOTION OF CAPITAL IN THE LIGHT OF HEGEL’S PHILOSOPHY: ON THE LOGICAL ANALYSIS OF POLITICAL ECONOMY WITH SPECIAL CONSIDERATION OF ADORNO AND THE RESEARCH RESULTS OF RUBIN, BACKHAUS, REICHELT, UNO, AND SEKINE

The Markov Process Is Misleading in Solving the Transformation Problem:A Review of Michio Morishima's Solution

Marx's "Value Transfonnation" and Sraffa' s "Standard System

The Philosophical Method of Marx's Economic Assumptions as Exemplified in the Relationship between Two Definitions of "Socially Necessary Labor Time"

Marx's "Value Transformation" and Sraffa's "Standard System"

A new approach to the Korpelevich method for solving pseudomonotone equilibrium problems

A multidimensional interpretation of Marxist globalization theory based on decentralized internet

On Grassman's Interpretations of the Structure and Method in Marx's Capital: Considerations on the Political Economy Approaches by Early Frankfurt School

Comments on Japanese "Early Marx" Controversy:The Significances of Glossen zu James Mill on the Reconstruction of Marx’s Alienation Theory

A Probabilistic Proof of the Perron-Frobenius Theorem

On Karl Marx's Early Economic Study from the Perspective of Doctrinal History

Inter-subjectivity、Inter-objectivity and Inter-subjectivity-objectivity——on Relationship Theory of Marx's Practical Materialism

Marxism and the Debate on the Transition to Capitalism in Prewar Japan

Basic Framework of Marxist Principles as a Whole

On Marx-Hess Academic Relationship from the Perspective of Feuerbach Chinese Full Text