Interactive comment on “ Airto-sea flux of soluble iron : is it driven more by HNO 3 or SO 2 ? – an examination in the light of dust aging ” by H . Yang and Y .

Gao,H. Yang,Y. Gao
2007-01-01
Abstract:Anonymous Referee #1 Received and published: 1 August 2007 Review of manuscript “Air-to-Sea Flux of Soluble Iron: Is It Driven More by HNO3 or SO2? An Examination in the Light of Dust Aging by Yang and Gao I have reviewed this paper about a year ago when it was submitted to Geophysical Research Letters. Although paper has been changed to some extent and some of specific comments I had at that time have been taken into account, my general comment about the paper remains the same. As most of the conclusions of the manuscript are based on iron dissolution method that in my opinion is incorrect (see below), I would not recommend publication
What problem does this paper attempt to address?