Interactive comment on “ Comparison of secondary organic aerosol formation from toluene on initially wet and dry ammonium sulfate particles ” by Tengyu

Tengyu Liu
2017-01-01
Abstract:This manuscript describes laboratory experiments aimed at measuring the yield and composition of SOA formed from the OH oxidation of toluene, in the presence of either initially deliquesced ("wet") or effloresced ("dry") ammonium sulfate (AS) seeds. This work extends the study by Faust et al. (2017), by examining the effects of toluene SOA yield/composition at different OH exposures. The authors certainly highlights an important point that SOA formed onto AS seed particles will lower the deliquescence RH (for initially dry AS) or contribute to additional aerosol liquid water (for initially wet AS). However, my main concern is that the authors only attributed the decrease in relative SOA yield (between dry and wet AS) with increasing OH exposures to the effects of aerosol liquid water, while the experiment design/data presented preclude the isolation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?