A Comparative Study Between Virtual Touch Tissue Imaging in the Differential Diagnosis Between Benign and Malignant Solid Thyroid Nodules
Jie CHEN,Hui-xiong XU,Xiao-hong XU,Yi-feng ZHANG,Chang LIU,Jun-mei XU,Jing ZHANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0785.2013.23.065
2013-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the value of the virtual touch tissue imaging(VTI) of acoustic radiation force impulse imaging(ARFI) in the differential diagnosis between benign and malignant solid thyroid nodules. Methods Retrospective analysis was performed to evaluate the images of conventional ultrasound, elasticity imaging(EI) and VTI of 132 histologically proven thyroid nodules in 110 patients. The EI features were divided into 4 grades and the VTI features were divided into 6 grades. The higher grade represented harder tissue. Results All 132 pathologically proven thyroid nodules included 84 begnan and 48 malignant nodules. Of all the benign nodules, there were 54 nodules with EI scores less than 3 and 30 nodules greater than or equal to 3. There were 71 nodules with VTI scores less than Ⅳ and 13 nodules greater than or equal to Ⅳ. Of all the malignant nodules, there were 8 nodules with EI scores less than 3 and 40 nodules greater than or equal to 3. There were 6 nodules with VTI scores less than Ⅳ and 42 nodules greater than or equal to Ⅳ(P=0.000). The sensitivity, specificity and accuracy, PPV and NPV, Youden index of conventional ultrasound were 72.9%(35/48), 77.4%(65/84), 75.8%(100/132), 64.8%(35/54), 83.3%(65/78), 0.50, respectively; 83.3%(40/48), 64.3%(54/84), 71.2%(94/132), 57.1%(40/70), 93.1%(54/58), 0.48, respectively, for EI; and were 87.5%(42/48), 84.5%(71/84), 85.6%(113/132), 76.4%(42/55), 88.8%(71/80), 0.72, respectively, for VTI. Conclusion VTI of ARFI elastography showed superior performance in the differential diagnosis between malignant and benign solid thyroid nodules compared with conventional ultrasound and EI. VTI of ARFI elastography showed superior performance in the differential diagnosis between benign and malignant nodules.