Abstract:The abolition of the judicial interpretation issued by the Supreme People's Court of the People's Republic of China in Qi Yuling's case marks the end of the trend of developing a judicial constitutional review system in China, but issues of courts invoking constitutional norms in judicial decisions continue to arise. This essay investigates the actual situation of the Constitution in judicial decisions by categorizing 1907 court decisions that invoked the Constitution as the reasoning basis and the court decisions which invoked the Constitution as the decision-making basis and by exploring the logic of the use of the Constitution by Chinese judges. In the absence of a constitutional review system, the primary sense of Chinese judges invoking constitutional norms is characterized by "simplistic reasoning ", "politicized enforcement " and the "parent law " concept. The insufficient judgment reason is a universal feature of judicial adjudication in Chinese courts. However, due to the lack of a constitutional review system, the poor perception of the interpretation and application of the constitution may exacerbate the lack of legal arguments invoked by the Constitution. The political model of Constitution enforcement in China makes judges invoke the Constitution in judicial decisions by "asserting the prestige of the Constitution ", which leads to numerous errors in legal argumentation in judicial decisions. This also reflects the tendency of "political enforcement " to take precedence over the legal enforcement of the Constitution. The influence of the old "parent law " concept is that judges can arbitrarily apply constitutional norms directly to civil cases, including fundamental rights norms. By summarizing and describing the above three features, we can depict the activities of current Chinese courts in invoking the Constitution.

Constitutional Evolution Through Legislation: the Quiet Transformation of China's Constitution

A Constitution Without Constitutionalism? the Paths of Constitutional Development in China

How Do Chinese Judges Invoke the Constitution? Analysis Based on 1907 Decisions

Constitutional Supervision in China after the 2018 Amendment of the PRC Constitution: Refining the Narrative of Constitutional Supremacy in a Socialist Legal System

Chinese Constitutionality in Globalization Era

Breaching the Taboo? Constitutional Dimensions of the New Chinese Civil Code

Regime-Centered and Court-Centered Understandings: the Reception of American Constitutional Law in Contemporary China

A Debate on the Probability of Constitutional Government in Modem China

"Constitutional Review" in China:Characteristics and Actuality of Generating——From the Perspective of the Tactics for Change of Three Related Terms

Regime-Centered and Court-Centered Understandings: the Reception of American Constitutional Law in Contemporary China†

Chinese Legal Culture and Constitutional Order

A sociosemiotic approach to fundamental rights in China

The Constitution of China

The Limits of Constitutional Amendments and the Challenges of Constitutional Amending Models——A Legal Appraisal in the Context of China's Constitutional Development in the Past Sixty Years

The Irony in the Lineage of Modern Chinese Constitutions and Constitutionalism

Towards Constitutional Re-Enlightenment: Teaching American Constitutional Law in China

A Study on Legislative Transformation in the Course of Contemporary China's Social Changes

Constitutional Review without a Constitution: The British Story

Experimentalist approach of Chinese legislation model: From passive response to institutional design

International Law in Chinese Courts During the Rise of China

On Legal System's Positions and Roles in Building the Democratic Politics