Abstract:Aims Predictive species distribution models (SDMs) are increasingly applied in resource assessment,environmental conservation and biodiversity management.However,most SDM models often yield a predicted probability (suitability) surface map.In conservation and environmental management practices,the information presented as species presence/absence (binary) may be more practical than presented as probability or suitability.Therefore,a threshold is needed to transform the probability or suitability data to presence/absence data.However,little is known about the effects of different threshold-selection methods on model performance and species range changes induced by future climate.Of the numerous SDM models,random forest (RF) can produce probabilistic and binary species distribution maps based on its regression and classification algorisms,respectively.Studies dealing with the comparative test of the performances of RF regression and classification algorisms have not been reported.Methods Here,the RF was used to simulate the current and project the future potential distributions of Davidia involucrata and Cunninghamia lanceolata.Then,four threshold-setting methods (Default 0.5,MaxKappa,MaxTSS and MaxACC) were selected and used to transform modelled probabilities of occurrence into binary predictions of species presence and absence.Lastly,we investigated the difference in model performance among the threshold selection methods by using five model accuracy measures (Kappa,TSS,Overall accuracy,Sensitivity and Specificity).We also used the map similarity measure,Kappa,for a cell-by-cell comparison of similarities and differences of distribution map tnder current and future climates.Important findings We found that the choice of threshold method altered estimates of model performance,species habitat suitable area and species range shifts under future climate.The difference in selected threshold cut-offs among the four threshold methods was significant for D.involucrata,but was not significant for C.lanceolata.Species' geographic ranges changed (area change and shifting distance) in response to climate change,but the projections of the four threshold methods did not differ significantly with respect to how much or in which direction,but they did differ against RF classification predictions.The pairwise similarity analysis of binary maps indicated that spatial correspondence among prediction maps was the highest between the MaxKappa and the MaxTSS,and lowest between RF classification algorism and the four threshold-setting methods.We argue that the MaxTSS and the MaxKappa are promising methods for threshold selection when RF regression algorism is used for the distribution modeling of species.This study also provides promising insights to our understanding of the uncertainty of threshold selection in species distribution modeling.

Methods and Models for Identifying Thresholds of Habitat Loss

Author Response for "non‐linear Thresholds in the Effects of Island Area on Functional Diversity in Woody Plant Communities"

Ecological Thresholds: Concept, Methods and Research Outlooks

Structural Uncertainty in Models Projecting the Consequences of Habitat Loss and Fragmentation on Biodiversity

From habitat decline to collapse: a spatially explicit approach connecting habitat degradation to destruction

Disproportionate loss of threatened terrestrial mammals along anthropogenic disturbance gradients

Setting conservation management thresholds using a novel participatory modeling approach

Habitat loss-induced tipping points in metapopulations with facilitation

Loss of Only the Smallest Patches Will Reduce Species Diversity in Most Discrete Habitat Networks

How Species Diversity Responds to Different Kinds of Human-Caused Habitat Destruction

Quantifying the Risk of Irreversible Degradation for Ecosystems: A Probabilistic Method Based on Bayesian Inference

Threshold and resilience management of coupled urbanization and water environmental system in the rapidly changing coastal region

Abundance Versus Vital Rates: the Extent and Predictors of Inconsistent Conclusions on Avian Population Responses to Forest Loss and Degradation

Threshold effect of ecosystem services in response to human activity in China's urban agglomeration: a perspective on quantifying ecological resilience

Indirect effects of habitat destruction on model ecosystems

Responses of Metapopulation Dynamics to Two Different Kinds of Habitat Destruction Caused by Human Activities

A Null Model for Quantifying the Geometric Effect of Habitat Subdivision on Species Diversity

Indirect Effects among Biodiversity Loss of Mutualistic Ecosystems

An Evaluation of Four Threshold Selection Methods in Species Occurrence Modelling with Random Forest: Case Studies with Davidia Involucrata and Cunninghamia Lanceolata

The mechanism of species extinction under habitat destruction at different rates

Top ten hazards to avoid when modeling species distributions: a didactic guide of assumptions, problems, and recommendations