Critical instability at moving keyhole tip generates porosity in laser melting

Cang Zhao,Niranjan D Parab,Xuxiao Li,Kamel Fezzaa,Wenda Tan,Anthony D Rollett,Tao Sun,Niranjan D. Parab,Anthony D. Rollett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abd1587

IF: 56.9

2020-11-27

Science

Abstract:Driving the pores away The formation of “keyholes” (vapor-filled depressions) during additive manufacturing leads to porosity, which degrades alloy performance, especially fracture properties, and remains a big challenge for the 3D printing of metals. Zhao et al. used high-speed x-ray imaging to take a detailed look at how keyhole formation connects to porosity in a titanium alloy. They found that instability at the keyhole tip drives pores away to get trapped in the solidification front. Understanding this process and the operating parameters under which it occurs provides a roadmap for avoiding porosity and building high-quality metal parts. Science , this issue p. 1080

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the porosity problem in Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) 3D printing technology, especially the porosity related to deep and narrow vapor depressions (called keyholes). These porosities are formed under high - power, low - scanning - speed laser melting conditions and have a negative impact on product performance (such as corrosion resistance and fatigue life) in fatigue - sensitive applications.

Specifically, through high - speed X - ray imaging technology, the paper observed the formation process of porosities in Ti - 6Al - 4V titanium alloy during the LPBF process in real - time and revealed a key mechanism: the critical instability at the tip of the keyhole generates sound waves, which provide an additional and crucial driving force for the porosities near the tip of the keyhole, making the porosities move away from the keyhole and finally be trapped as defects.

### Main research contents of the paper include:

1. **Determination of keyhole porosity boundaries**:
- The study found that in the power - speed (P - V) space, the shape of the keyhole porosity boundary is very smooth and sharp, and the boundary change is very small regardless of the presence or absence of the powder layer.
- Through quantitative analysis, the researchers defined the keyhole porosity boundary and explained the influence of the powder layer.

2. **Porosity formation mechanism**:
- The "J" - shaped structure at the bottom of the keyhole is pinched off under specific conditions, rapidly released and moves towards the laser beam wake, and finally is captured by the solidified front.
- Driven by the keyhole instability, the sound waves push these pinched - off porosities away from the keyhole, causing them to become structural defects.

3. **Influence of the powder layer**:
- When the powder layer exists, the keyhole fluctuates more and more porosities are formed.
- Powder particles occasionally enter the laser beam path, temporarily blocking the keyhole, reducing the local temperature and recoil pressure, thereby promoting the keyhole depth fluctuation.

4. **Relationship between keyhole depth and porosity**:
- Porosities are formed only when the keyhole depth exceeds a certain threshold.
- The keyhole depth threshold shows different power - law relationships with the change of scanning speed and laser power.

5. **Dynamics of porosity movement**:
- High - speed micro - jets and sound waves act together, resulting in asymmetric collapse, splitting and rebound of porosities.
- The movement of porosities is controlled by thermocapillary forces and viscous drag, and sound waves play a key role in it.

Through these studies, the paper provides new insights into understanding the porosity formation mechanism in the LPBF process and a theoretical basis for further optimizing 3D printing process parameters to reduce porosities.