Are Lung Ntcp Models Different in Hypofractionated and Standard Fractionated Radiotherapy?

A. Troeller,M. Soehn,I. S. Grills,D. Ionascu,M. Guckenberger,R. Klement,J. Belderbos,J. Sonke,A. J. Hope,J. Bissonnette,M. Werner-Wasik,Y. Xiao,D. Yan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrobp.2014.05.162
2014-01-01
Abstract:NTCP modeling of radiation induced lung pneumonitis in hypo-fractionated SBRT has resulted in a much higher MLD50 compared to the standard, 2 Gy, fractionated RT (SFRT). Although the LQ-model is the most popular method in clinical use, it has been shown to be inaccurate for very low and high doses per fraction. Here we investigate the use of the low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity (LD-HRS) model as an alternative to adjust for fractionation effects in hypo-fractionated RT. The aim of this study is to show that the lung NTCP model in hypofractionated SBRT is similar to the one in the SFRT, as long as the correct radiation-induced lung cell survival model is used. Lung DVHs and CTCAE toxicity scores of 409 patients from 5 institutions treated with hypo-fractionated SBRT in 3-10 fractions were investigated in this study. The physical DVHs of SBRT were converted to biologically equivalent DVHs of SFRT using the LD-HRS model. This model has 4 parameters: αs determines sensitivity to radiation in the low-dose regime, dc is the threshold dose for induced repair, and α and β as in the LQ-model. The latter three were fixed to the same previously published in vitro values throughout the study, while the parameter αs was a variable to be determined. Optimal NTCP parameters of the Lyman model for grade ≥ 2 pneumonitis were then determined based on the mean lung dose (MLD) for all values αs within a pre-selected interval using the corresponding biologically equivalent DVHs. Maximum likelihood estimation was used for the parameter optimization. Twenty-nine (7.1%) of the patients investigated experienced pneumonitis of grade ≥ 2. Optimal values for the slope parameter m were stable within the range (0.55 - 0.57) for different αs, while the MLD50 inversely correlated to the αs. Values for MLD50 ranged from 20.0 Gy to 64.0 Gy for the values of αs investigated. All models had similar log-likelihoods, and thus described the dataset equally well. Comparing to the αs reported in vitro for human lung cell line, a higher value can be selected to obtain an identical lung NTCP model for both SBRT and SFRT. If the low-dose sensitivity parameter is properly selected, SBRT and SFRT can share an identical NTCP model to describe radiation-induced lung toxicity. Therefore, the LD-HRS cell survival model has the potential to resolve fractionation issues in NTCP modeling uncertainty for lung cancer RT.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?