Abstract:In 2001, the US moved to regulate internal control reporting by management and auditors. While some jurisdictions have followed the lead of the US, many others have not. An important question, therefore, is the relevance of internal control to stakeholders. The more specific issue of the benefits of US-style regulation of internal control reporting is also topical. We review studies on the determinants of internal control quality and its economic consequences for stakeholders including investors, creditors, managers, auditors and financial analysts. We extend previous reviews by focusing on US studies published since 2013 as well as all non-US studies investigating IC quality including countries regulating IC disclosure as well as unregulated settings and both developed and developing economies. In doing so, we identify research questions where evidence remains mixed and new directions in which there are research opportunities. Three main insights arise from our analysis. First, evidence on the economic consequences of internal control quality suggests that the quality of internal control can have a significant effect on decision making by users of financial information. Second, the results of research on the empirical association between ownership structure, certain board characteristics and internal control quality is generally mixed. Empirical evidence concerning the association between audit committee characteristics and internal control quality generally supports a positive and significant association. Finally, while studies in non-US jurisdictions are increasing, opportunities remain to explore the determinants and consequences of internal control in other jurisdictions. Our review provides evidence for policy makers of whether there are benefits from requiring management and auditors to report on internal control over financial reporting.

The Effect of Voluntary Internal Control Audits on the Cost of Capital

Internal Control and Stock Price Crash Risk: Evidence from China

The Effect of SOX Internal Control Deficiencies on Firm Risk and Cost of Equity

Internal Control,Audit Quality and Agency Cost

Internal Control, Information Environment and the Cost of Capital:Empirical Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies

Voluntary Interim Audit and Agency Costs Between Management and Shareholders: the China Experience

Internal control in accounting research: A review

THE ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF VOLUNTARY DISCLOSURE OF AUDITORS' REPORTS ON INTERNAL CONTROL——Based on Propensity Score Matching and Difference-in-difference Approaches

Internal control reporting and cost of bond financing: Evidence from China

The Role of Internal Control Disclosure in Financial Reporting Precision and the Quality of Audited Financial Reports

Voluntary Disclosure of Auditors’ Report on Internal Control: Firm Characteristics and Economic Consequences

Effecting Factors and Economic Consequences of Internal Control——A Review of Foreign Empirical Literatures of Internal Control

Direct and Indirect Effects of Internal Control Weaknesses on Accrual Quality: Evidence from A Unique Canadian Regulatory Setting

Study on the Internal Control and Audit Pricing——Based on the evidences of Chinese listed companies

Dynamic Internal Control Performance Over Financial Reporting and External Financing

The Impact Of Internal Control Audit On Real Earnings Management Behaviors

The impact of internal control, external assurance, and integrated reports on market value

Can Voluntary Interim Auditing Reduce Earnings Management?——An empirical test of a self-selection model

The Effectiveness of Internal Control and Corporate Social Responsibility: Evidence from Chinese Capital Market

The Effect of External Auditors on Managerial Slack