Internal Control,Corporate Lawsuits and Firm Value
LIN BIN,ZHOU MEIHUA,SHU WEI,LIU CHUNLI
2013-01-01
Abstract:Five Chinese government authorities and regulatory bodies jointly issued the Basic Standard for Enterprise Internal Control (C-SOX)in June 2008,which requires listed companies established within the territory of mainland China to establish,evaluate and assess the effectiveness of their internal controls,and encourage large and medium-sized Chinese en-terprises which are non-listed to fulfill these requirements.C-SOX stipulates that one of the internal control objectives is to provide reasonable assurance to realize the compliance of laws and regulations.However,whether the internal control can achieve this objective and im-prove firm value is still full of doubt.Considering these factors,we use corporate lawsuits data in Chinese capital market from 2000 to 2007 to investigate the relationship among inter-nal control,corporate lawsuits and firm value. Based on the contract theory,internal control is an important internal mechanism to en-sure the contract implementation.If internal control is not effective enough,there is of great probability that the stakeholders will seek for external mechanism to protect their own inter-est,such as lawsuits.As a result,companies with weaker internal control are more likely to be involved in litigation,which will influence firm value. We use empirical research method to solve these issues and find that:(1 )Compared to the firms with better internal control,the probability of being litigated is higher in firms with worse internal control;(2)Compared to other firms,the litigated firms have lower firm val-ue;(3)Further,among the litigated firms,the worse the internal control quality,the lower the firm value.In summary,internal control could enhance the compliance activity in firm’s operation,avoid the loss caused by lawsuit,and further improve firm value. Our paper makes three primary contributions.First,we extend the literature of lawsuit. There are few studies on the causes of lawsuit,and our results offer a new angle to discover these causes.Second,our results contribute to the debate on the consequence of internal con-trol.We find that internal control has a positive effect on the compliance of laws and regula-tions,which extends the research on the economic consequences of internal control.Third, our paper provides empirical evidence on the influencing factors of corporate value.