Abstract:Watts and Zimmerman (1983, p. 615) address a proposition that “an audit will reduce the agency costs borne by the manager only if the market expects the auditor to have a nonzero level of independence.” But no literature investigates using archival data whether an audit per se does reduce agency costs between management and shareholders, because it is difficult to obtain a similar no-audit case as the benchmark of comparison. Chinese market provides a natural experimental setting to examine whether and how an audit itself can reduce agency costs. A number of Chinese listed firms voluntarily audit their interim reports, even though interim audit is not mandatory except for some specific circumstances. Using the data of voluntary interim audit and with a sample of 7407 firm-years from China over the period of 2002-2009, this paper evaluates the impact of voluntary audit on agency costs after controlling for potential self-selection bias and firm-specific factors. The findings show that agency costs are significantly lower for firms with voluntary audit than for firms with no audit across all regression specifications. Particularly, firms with voluntary audit have a significantly lower expense ratio (a positive proxy for agency costs) and a significantly higher assets utilization ratio (an inverse proxy for agency costs) than do firms with no audit. However, the results suggest no significant difference in reducing agency costs between BIG4-audited firms and non-BIG4-audited firms. The results, taken together, lend supports to Watts and Zimmerman’s proposition, suggesting that voluntary audit per se is value of information and plays an important role of corporate governance for reducing agency costs in a contemporary capital markets setting where an audit is not mandatory.

Can Voluntary Interim Auditing Reduce Earnings Management?——An empirical test of a self-selection model

Ex ante Uncertainty Risk,Governance Conflicts,and Auditor Choice:Empirical Evidence from China's IPO Market,1998—2004

Do Big Auditors Always Perform Better?——Evidence from China's rights issuers and non-issuers

Corporate Governance Causes of the Voluntary Audit Behaviour of Interim Financial Reporting of Public Listed Companies——Some Evidences from Shenzhen Stock Exchange

Buy, Lie, or Die: an Investigation of Chinese ST Firms’ Voluntary Interim Audit Motive and Auditor Independence

Voluntary Interim Audit and Agency Costs Between Management and Shareholders: the China Experience

The Voluntary Adoption of an Audit Committee and Earnings Quality: Evidence from China

Are Accounting Estimate Changes Associated with an Aggressive Earnings Effect? Empirical Evidence

Earnings Management of the Listed Companies and Auditor Change: Empirical Evidence from China

Can Voluntary Management Earnings Forecasts Improve Value Relevance of Earnings in China

Can High Audit Quality Constrain Real Earnings Management

Interlocking Directors,Auditor Selection and Earnings Management

The Impact Of Internal Control Audit On Real Earnings Management Behaviors

The Impact of Earnings Management on Audit Opinions

Voluntary Disclosure of Auditors’ Report on Internal Control: Firm Characteristics and Economic Consequences

Earnings Management and Audit Opinions:An Empirical Study Based on Non-operating Earnings

Audit Firm Size, Earnings Management, and Information Asymmetry

THE ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF VOLUNTARY DISCLOSURE OF AUDITORS' REPORTS ON INTERNAL CONTROL——Based on Propensity Score Matching and Difference-in-difference Approaches

Audit quality and earnings management for China IPO firms

Unintended Consequences from Downward Audit Adjustments: Evidence from China

Audit Report Information Improvement and Earnings Management