Abstract:BACKGROUND:Medical malpractice litigations affect the practices of patient safety. However, medical malpractice litigations involve highly specialized knowledge. Thus, medical appraisal is usually essential in the ascertainment of responsibility and judicial decision-making. China's judicial system is characterized by a dual-mode of medical appraisal resulting from two parallel appraisal agencies: judicial appraisal institutions and medical associations. This paper examines whether or not and how choices of different medical appraisal agencies affect malpractice lawsuit results in China.METHODS:We collected and sampled a total of 2557 verdicts pertaining to medical disputes from "China Judgements Online" in 2014. We used an ordinary least square regression model and a mediating effect regression model to analyze to what extent and how different choices between two medical appraisal agencies affect malpractice litigations.RESULTS:(1) Almost 81.55% (2082) of litigants resorted to medical malpractice appraisals in China in 2014. Among 2070 cases with appraisal results accepted by the court, 60.10% of the litigants chose judicial appraisal institutions (1244), as opposed to medical associations (826). (2) Among 2557 cases, 2306 (90.18%) claimed compensation and 1919 (83.22%) were awarded compensation by the courts. The proportion of compensation paid in a case is 48% on average. (3) Appraisal agencies matter in the investigation of medical errors, which in turn affects the proportion of compensation paid in a case. (4) Choosing judicial appraisal institutions will raise the proportion of compensation paid by about 10% on average.CONCLUSIONS:Different choices between appraisal institutions affect malpractice litigations in China. As the last resort for remedying medical malpractice, medical appraisals in the judicial system could be a source of inequality in China's medical litigation outcomes.

Right maintenance and self-discipline of practicing dentist On the liability in medical damage of the tortuous liability(IV)：medical authentication system for medical debates needs to be consummated

Rights maintenance and self-discipline of practicing dentist: Part Ⅴ. Consequence in medical dispute

[Rights maintenance and self-discipline of practicing dentist: Part IV. Consequence in medical dispute].

Right maintenance and self-discipline of practicing dentist on the liability in medical damage of the tortuous liability (IX): a medical lawsuit case induced by supragingival oral prophylaxis performed by a medical student]

Rights maintenance and self-discipline of practicing dentist:Part Ⅴ.Compensate for personal harm in medical treatment dispute

Problem and Improvement of Legislation on Liability for Medical Damages

Discussion on Administrative Accountability on the Medical Side in Medical Damage Cases

A Practical Analysis on the Legal Regulation of Medical Malpractice

Countermeasure on the dual expert witness model of medical tort liability

Suggestions on medical damage liability related legal problems

Thoughts on establishing all recognized medical damage identification system

Difficult Litigation Issues on Compensation for Medical Malpractice and Trial Countermeasures

Identification Principle and Thought of "Medical Malpractice" Based on Theoretical Analysis

Infantile mammary duct ectasia: a cause of bloody nipple discharge.

Risk management and empirical study of the doctor-patient relationship: based on 1790 litigation cases of medical damage liability disputes in China

Studies of Relief for Low Cure Rate Patients Damage Caused by Medical Malpractice

[Study and application of legislative changes on liability for medical damage in the Civil Code].

Identification of Negligence in Medicine Malpractice Lawsuit.

Study on Patient's Right of Informed Consent under the Tort Law Through the Method of Case Analysis

Comparative Study on the Treatments of Medical Disputes Between Medical Staff and Patients

Inequality in the Last Resort: How Medical Appraisal Affects Malpractice Litigations in China