2 and 10 year retrievals of zirconia femoral heads - XRD, SEM and Raman spectroscopy studies

d d green,giuseppe pezzotti,s sakakura,michael d ries,ian c clarke,IC Clarke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118406069.ch14

2003-01-01

Abstract:Analysis of zirconia implant performance in patients is limited to one study of two Kobelco(1) implants (retrieved after 3 and 5 years use). The Japanese authors reported extensively cratered surfaces and formation of 20%-30% monoclinic phase. Here we report on two zirconia balls (Prozyr(TM), SGCD Inc), one retrieved at 2 years and the other at 10 years in the USA. Analysis was carried out for surface roughness, SEM, XRD and Raman Spectroscopy to determine the phases present, the residual-stress mapping and surface condition of the bearing surfaces. The bearing surfaces appeared satisfactorily preserved and XRD showed the majority of the surface was tetragonal phase with monoclinic < 8% after 10 years use. The Raman spectroscopy described close to neutral residual stresses on the surface. Thus these 2 year and 10 year Prozyr(TM) retrievals demonstrated satisfactory performance in the patients. This was in direct contrast to the Japanese zirconia retrieval study. Thus we may have to consider on case-by-case basis any differences in manufacturing, implant design and patient performance. In our study there was a trend for the residual compressive-stresses to decrease and the tensile-stresses to increase. This observation could imply that the tensile residual-stresses and monoclinic phase on the zirconia surface were increasing with time under the main bearing area. More detailed work is needed in this area.