Abstract:Common random numbers (CRN) is a widely-used technique for reducing variance in comparing stochastic systems through simulation. Its popularity derives from its intuitive appeal and ease of implementation. However, though CRN has been observed to work well with a broad range of models, the class of systems for which it is provably advantageous has remained rather limited. This paper has two purposes: We first discuss the effectiveness and optimality of CRN in a general setting, stressing the roles played by monotonicity and continuity properties. We then present specific, new classes of systems and comparisons for which CRN is beneficial and even optimal. Our conclusions for these systems are largely consistent with simulation practice and lend further theoretical support to folklore. Our results differ from those of previous analyses primarily because we put conditions on the timing of events, rather than the sequence of states, in a discrete-event simulation. We formulate our results in three settings corresponding to three applications of CRN: distributional comparisons, structural comparisons, and sensitivity analysis. In each case, we make use of conditions that simultaneously ensure monotonicity and continuity in the timing of events. These properties are established through explicit recursions for event epochs in terms of increasing, continuous functions.

Context-Free Grammars and Random Number Generation

Design of Random Number Generation Algorithm

Random Graph Generation in Context-Free Graph Languages

Uniform random generations and rejection method(I) with binomial majorant

Analysis of Random Number Generators Using Monte Carlo Simulation

Generating High-Quality Random Numbers by Next Nearest-Neighbor Cellular Automata

Random Generation of 2-Connected Graphs

Random Numbers in Scientific Computing: An Introduction

Some Guidelines and Guarantees for Common Random Numbers

A Search for Good Pseudo-random Number Generators : Survey and Empirical Studies

Design and Implementation of Random Selection

A Novel Random Number Generator Based on Continuous-Time Chaos

Optimal Discrete Uniform Generation from Coin Flips, and Applications

How to get the random graph with non-uniform probabilities?

Is Randomness "Native" to Computer Science?

Improving Random Number Generators in the Monte Carlo Simulations Via Twisting and Combining.

Geometric Random Inner Products: A New Family of Tests for Random Number Generators

Choosing 1 of N with and without lucky numbers

Random Grammar-based Testing for Covering All Non-Terminals

Statistical properties of probabilistic context-sensitive grammars

Randomness: what is it and why does it matter?