Reassessment of the Zircon Raman Spectroscopic Pressure Sensor and Application to Pressure Determination of Fused Silica Capillary Capsule
Hao Cui,Richen Zhong,Xiaolin Wang,Zimeng Li,Yifan Ling,Chang Yu,Huan Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2020.103540
IF: 3.3
2020-01-01
Ore Geology Reviews
Abstract:The Raman shift of the nu(3)(SiO4) mode of zircon at -1008 cm(-1) has been observed to vary with the pressure (P) and temperature (7) of the environment. The relationship between the nu(3)(SiO4) peak position and P-T was calibrated in previous work and used to develop a pressure sensor for high P-T experiments, up to 1000 degrees C and 10 GPa, to an accuracy within +/- 50 MPa. This pressure measurement method is valid for zircon grains for which the nu(3)(SiO4) Raman shift occurs specifically at or close to 1008.17 cm(-1) at room temperature (25 degrees C). However, the peak position of nu(3)(SiO4) for some zircon grains may shift to a lower or higher wavenumber under ambient conditions, mainly due to the chemical composition of the grains. This may cause substantial deviation in the measured pressures. In the present study, we recalibrated the pressure sensor by determining the position of the nu(3)(SiO4) peak for zircon grains with different chemical compositions at given P-T conditions and developed a model applicable to both natural and synthetic zircon samples. All the zircon samples considered were found to have a universal nu-T relationship when the nu(3)(SiO4) wavenumbers under ambient conditions were calibrated to the same position. Based on this relationship, the temperature-induced wavenumber shift of nu(3)(SiO4) can be expressed as Delta nu(T) (cm(-1)) = 8.00 x 10(-9) x (T-3 - T-o(3))- 2.00 x 10(-5) x (T2 - T-o(2))- 2.78 x 10(-2) x (T - T-o), where T and T-0 are the target and room temperatures, respectively. In addition, the pressure-induced wavenumber shift of nu(3)(SiO4) can be calculated using Delta nu(P) (cm(-1)) = Delta nu - Delta nu(T), where Av is the total frequency shift between the target and ambient P-T conditions. By the linear regression of the experimental results, the global slope (partial derivative nu/partial derivative P)(T) was determined to be 5.91 x 10(-3) cm(-1)/MPa. In addition, high P-T experiments performed in isochoric systems using a hydrothermal diamond anvil cell (HDAC) showed that the cross-derivative term (partial derivative(2)nu/partial derivative P partial derivative T) was equal to zero, which is the same as the previous study. The revised method was used to determine the pressures inside a fused silica capillary capsule (FSCC) containing a NaCl solution. The pressures determined from the zircon Raman spectra (P-zr) were compared with those calculated using the equation of state (P-Eos) of a NaCl-H2O system. The determined P-Zr and P-Eos values agreed well for temperatures lower than similar to 500 degrees C. However, P. was significantly lower than P-Eos at higher temperatures due to the thermal expansion of the FSCC, i.e., the expansion of the sample chamber under the high internal pressures when the silica glass softened at high temperatures. The revised method was programmed in a Microsoft EXCEL spreadsheet and is presented in the Appendix B.