Abstract:Quantitative estimation of evapotranspiration (ET) plays a significant role in the mechanism study of water cycling and agriculture management. Remotely sensed satellites provide spatial continuous surface parameters, which make estimation of regional surface ET possible. However, surface parameters retrieved by remote sensing data is discontinuous temporally, which can only provide 1-2 instantaneous values at satellite over-passing time. Thus, time scale extrapolation process is of crucial necessity for daily ET estimation. Recently, many ET time scale extrapolation methods have been proposed, such as sine function method, constant evaporative fraction (EF) method, and crop coefficient method. It has been proved that different models have different applicability and accuracy over variant climate conditions and underlying surfaces. Many studies assemble these extrapolation methods into remote sensing models to estimate regional daily ET in China, however, little researches focus on the accuracy assessment of these methods. The purpose of this study is to compare and assess the accuracy of four commonly used ET extrapolation methods over variant climate conditions and vegetation types. The study was conducted at Gaoying flux site located in North China Plain and Tongyu flux long-term land surface processes observational station located in North-east China Plain to represent semi-humid and semi-arid climate respectively. The predominant crops of Gaoying site are winter wheat and summer maize planted in rotation. Tongyu long-term land surface processes observational station has two flux sites located on the sorghum and degraded grassland, respectively. Each site of Tongyu station as well as Gaoying site has an EC system to record half-hour latent heat flux and sensible heat flux. Four commonly used ET extrapolation methods selected from literatures were tested in this study. The selection was carried out considering their applicability to the Remote sensing data used. The first method is the constant evaporative fraction (EF) method, which assumes the evaporative fraction, defined as the ratio between latent heat flux and available energy is stable during daytime under fair weather. The second method is a variance to constant EF method (so called variant EF method), with a change that soil heat flux is neglected. One assumption implied in variant EF method is the average daily soil heat tends to be zero and could be excluded in estimating daily ET. The third method is sine function method, that proposed by the assumption that the ratio of instantaneous latent heat flux to daily ET to the diurnal trend of solar irradiance with a sine curve. The fourth method is the crop coefficient method, which implies the ratio of actual ET to reference ET (i.e. crop coefficient) stays stable during the day. Four wheat seasons and four maize seasons from 2005 to 2008 at Gaoying flux site, two seasons of sorghum, grass land and bare soil at Tongyu flux site are used in this study. By accumulating the half-hour LE measurements, daily ET is calculated and used as validation data. Results show that all the four methods have the similar patterns, but the variant EF method has the best accuracy and performs well over the typical croplands in north China. The assumption implying in the extrapolation methods that a certain parameter (such as EF, crop coefficient, etc.) remains stable during daytime does not work in the study areas. Therefore, estimation derived from morning satellite underestimates the daily evapotranspiration, but overvalues from afternoon satellite. The diurnal pattern of evaporative fraction will come next to get a better understand of extrapolation from instantaneous value to daily evapotranspiration, and a new extrapolation approach will be proposed.

Comparison of Different Complementary Relationship Models for Regional Evapotranspiration Estimation

Changes in Actual Evapotranspiration and Its Dominant Drivers Across the Three-River Source Region of China During 1982–2014

Evaluation of Applicability of Three Evapotranspiration Models Using Meteorological Data

A Complementary Relationship Evaporation Model Referring to the Granger Model and the Advection-Aridity Model

Comparison of Satellite-Based Evapotranspiration Models over Terrestrial Ecosystems in China

Comparison of temporal extrapolation methods for evapotranspiration over variant underlying croplands

Comparison of hydrological models in the middle reach of the Yellow River

A Comparative Study on Models for Estimating Evapotranspiration

Comparison of Seven Models for Estimation of Evapotranspiration and Groundwater Recharge Using Lysimeter Measurement Data in Germany

Estimation of actual evapotranspiration from different ecosystems on the Tibetan Plateau based on a generalized complementary evapotranspiration theory model

Comparison of three dual-source remote sensing evapotranspiration models during the MUSOEXE-12 campaign: Revisit of model physics: Two-source remote sensing ET model comparision

Comparative evaluation of four actual evapotranspiration models over different ecosystems and climate zones in China

Evaluation of Five Complementary Relationship Models for Estimating Actual Evapotranspiration During Soil Freeze-Thaw Cycles

Comparison of Evapotranspiration Estimates Based on the Surface Water Balance, Modified Penman‐Monteith Model, and Reanalysis Data Sets for Continental China

Modelling Seasonal Evapotranspiration of Arid Lands in China

Evaluation of Precipitation Products by Using Multiple Hydrological Models over the Upper Yellow River Basin, China

Evaluation and Comparison of Reanalysis Data for Runoff Simulation in the Data-Scarce Watersheds of Alpine Regions

A Review of Current Methodologies for Regional Evapotranspiration Estimation from Remotely Sensed Data

Evaluation of Remote Sensing-Based Evapotranspiration Datasets for Improving Hydrological Model Simulation in Humid Region of East China

Comparison of Monthly Water Balance Models

Comparison of Differences in Actual Cropland Evapotranspiration under Two Irrigation Methods Using Satellite-Based Model