Cyclic oxidation and interdiffusion behavior of a NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating on a Ni-based single crystal superalloy
Bo Bai,Hongbo Guo,Hui Peng,Liquan Peng,Shengkai Gong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corsci.2011.04.025
IF: 7.72
2011-01-01
Corrosion Science
Abstract:A novel NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating was deposited onto a Ni-based single crystal superalloy DD3. The cyclic oxidation and interdiffusion of the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating and a NiAlDy coating at 1100 °C were investigated. For the NiAlDy coating, secondary reaction zone (SRZ) consisting of γ′, γ and σ-topologically-closed-packed phase (σ-TCP) needles was formed in the superalloy after 100 h annealing. The NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating effectively suppressed the formation of SRZ as the RuNiAl layer worked as a buffer layer. Premature scale spallation was observed on the NiAlDy coating after about 80 h cyclic oxidation, whereas the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating exhibited improved oxidation-resistance property. Keywords A. Superalloys A. Metal coatings B. Thermal cycling C. Oxidation C. Interfaces 1 Introduction In order to protect hot-section components in gas turbine engines, thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) are widely applied [1,2] . A typical TBC consists of a thermally insulating Y 2 O 3 -stabilized ZrO 2 (YSZ) ceramic top coat, a bond coat and a thermally grown oxide (TGO) layer in between them [3,4] . The bond coat as a glue between the top coat and the substrate provides oxidation protection due to the formation of a protective Al 2 O 3 scale during thermal exposure [5] . TBCs can be deposited onto the superalloy substrate either by plasma spray (PS) or electron beam physical vapor deposition (EB-PVD). MCrAlY (M: Ni, Co) is a typical bond coat material, which usually exhibits a stable TGO growth rate when the operating temperatures is below 1100 °C. The use of the bond coat above higher temperatures results in accelerated TGO thickening and cracking, finally leading to premature spallation of TBC [5,6] . As the turbine-inlet temperature continues to rise, NiAl has attracted increasing attentions due to its high melting point and excellent oxidation resistance [7] . However, its poor cyclic oxidation limits its application as high-temperature protective coating. Extensive efforts have been made to improve its oxidation-resistance property. Platinum (Pt) can modify the adhesion of alumina and NiPtAl coating, but the mechanism has not been fully understood. Reactive elements such as Hf, Zr, Y and their oxide dispersions also effectively enhance the oxide scale adherence and improve cyclic oxidation performance [8–14] . Recently, the addition of Dy to β-NiAl has not only improved the oxide scale adherence but also lowered the growth rate of oxide scale [15–19] . Another problem for utilizing NiAl coating is the interdiffusion between the coating and its underlying superalloy substrate. When the substrate alloy containing high level of refractory elements such as Re and W is operated at high-temperature, inter-diffusion between the coating and substrate results in precipitation of topologically-closed-packed phase (TCP) through cellular transformation and secondary reaction zone (SRZ) [20–23] . The formation of SRZ is undesirable as it leads to significant reduction of mechanical properties of the superalloy, which can be attributed to three aspects: (1) the formation of SRZ reduces the effective bearing area of the substrate; (2) a large number of micro-crack sources exist between the SRZ and the γ-γ′ alloy, resulting in continuous generation and rapid growth of microcracks along grain boundaries and eventually leading to development of large cracks; (3) most of TCP phases are very brittle and deleterious to the mechanical properties of superalloy. Ruthenium (δ-Ru) is one of four elements which increases the liquidus temperature of nickel (γ-Ni) and is used as one of important alloying elements for advanced Ni-based single crystal superalloys to improve their high-temperature capabilities [24] . Ru-containing coating is considered as a possible solution to improve the high-temperature properties of bond coats and a lower cost alternative to Pt. As RuAl also has a similar B2 structure but its melting point is higher than that of NiAl, a ruthenium-modified aluminized bond coat could improve the temperature capability [25] . Furthermore, RuAl owns thermal expansion coefficients close to those of α-Al 2 O 3 [26] . In addition, the ruthenium-modified aluminized bond coat is more creep resistant than the NiAl coating, which has been of interest for high-temperature structural application [27] . Recently, the addition of Ru to Ni-based superalloys has been proved to be helpful to improve the microstructural stability and suppress the formation of TCP phase, thereby improving their high-temperature creep properties [28] . It has been also shown that Ru stabilizes the γ/γ′ structure in Ni-based superalloys by suppressing the precipitation of TCP during prolonged thermal exposure [29] . Due to the above merits, Ru/Pt-modified NiAl coatings for thermal barrier coating system have been investigated [30] . Ru provides an increase in creep strength of the bond coat, hence improving its rumpling resistance. In our work, a RuNiAl coating is proposed to work as a diffusion barrier between β-NiAl coating and Ni-based superalloy [31,32] . In this work, a novel NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating was produced on Ni-based single crystal superalloy DD3 by a combination of electroplating and EB-PVD. The cyclic oxidation and interdiffusion behavior of the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating and the NiAlDy coating are investigated. The purpose of this study is to understand the effect mechanisms of the RuNiAl layer in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating for suppressing SRZ in the superalloy and cyclic oxidation behavior of the coating. 2 Experimental procedures Ni-base single crystal superalloy DD3 was used as the substrate material, with the nominal composition listed in Table 1 . The surfaces of rectangular specimens (13 × 9 × 3 mm) were ground by 800-grit emery papers and ultrasonically cleaned in a mixed alkaline solution (15 g/l NaOH + 15 g/l Na 3 PO 4 + 15 g/l Na 2 CO 3 ). Subsequently, the specimens were cleaned in de-ionized water. Before NiAlDy coating deposition, a Ru film with a thickness of 3–5 μm was first electroplated on the substrate. The solution containing ruthenium chloride (concentration: 6 g/l) and amidosulphonic acid (concentration: 50 g/l) was used for Ru plating, and the pH level was adjusted to be 1–2 by using ammonia liquor or amidosulphonic acid. During electroplating, a platinum foil (25 × 25 × 0.3 mm) was used as anode. Cathodic electroplating was performed at a current density of ∼1.2 A/dm 2 for about 30 min. After electroplating, the specimen was washed in acetone. A NiAlDy coating was deposited onto the Ru coated specimen by EB-PVD. Two EB-guns were applied during the deposition, one of which was used for heating the specimen and the other for evaporation of Ni-49.95Al-0.05Dy (in at.%) ingot. The EB current for evaporating the NiAlDy ingot was kept at 0.91 A and substrate temperature was kept at ∼700 °C during the deposition. For comparison, a NiAlDy coating specimen was also prepared by EB-PVD. The as-deposited coatings were annealed in vacuum at 1050 °C for 2 h. The coated samples were annealed in vacuum at 1100 °C for 30, 50 and 100 h, respectively, with a chamber pressure of ∼10 −3 Pa, to investigate interdiffusion between the coating and the superalloy. The cyclic oxidation test was performed in air furnace at 1100 °C. All the surfaces of the samples, including side surfaces, were deposited with the coatings. The samples were held in alumina crucibles and heated at 1100 °C. Each cycle included 1 h heating in furnace and 2 min cooling out of the furnace. The weight gains of the coating samples together with the crucibles were measured by an electronic balance (Sartorious BS 224S, Germany) with a precision of 0.1 mg. Also, the weight changes of the only specimens, exclusive of the weight of spallations of oxide scales, were measured by the balance. The phases of the oxides were identified by X-ray diffraction (XRD, Cu Kα, Rigaku D/max 2200PC, Japan). The specimens were mounted in epoxy resin, sectioned, ground and finely polished. The cross-section microstructures of the coatings were characterized by a QUANTA 600 scanning electron microscope (SEM, FEI, Holland) equipped with energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS, IE 350) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM, JEM-2100F). The chemical compositions were determined by electron probe micro-analyzer (EPMA, JXA-8100). 3 Results and discussion 3.1 As-deposited and annealed coatings The coatings deposited by EB-PVD are usually featured with columnar structure. A representative cross-sectional image of the as-deposited NiAlDy/Ru coating is shown in Fig. 1 . A continuous Ru film of ∼3 μm in thickness is observed on the superalloy. Actually, there are two other layers beneath the Ru film. The chemical compositions of the layers determined by EDS are both enriched in Ni and Al. The layer closed to the superalloy substrate shows a relatively higher content of Ni but lower content of Al as compared to the layer closed to the Ru film. Those layers were formed during deposition of NiAlDy coatings at high-temperature, as a result of interdiffusion between the NiAlDy layer, the Ru film and substrate. The coating composition is analyzed by EPMA to be 52.5 Ni, 47.46 Al and 0.04 Dy (in at.%), which is similar to the NiAlDy ingot composition. A few voids are observed at the Ru film/substrate interface, which was formed mainly due to chemical etching of Ni-based superalloy in the acidic electrolyte solution. A NiAlDy coating of ∼30 μm in thickness is intimately bonded to the Ru film. Fig. 2 a and b show the cross-sections of the NiAlDy sample and NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample after 2 h annealing in vacuum at 1050 °C, respectively. Note that for the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample, there is a RuNiAl layer of around 5 μm in thickness above the interdiffusion zone, as a result of interdiffusion between the NiAlDy layer and Ru film. However, the interface between the NiAlDy layer and RuNiAl layer is not distinct in Fig. 2 a. For both of the samples, a thin interdiffusion zone (IDZ) is formed in between the coating and substrate. In the IDZ, some bright granular precipitates are dispersed in the β matrix. In our investigation, the granular precipitates are identified to be σ-TCP phases [33] . The IDZ in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample ( Fig. 2 a) is a little thinner than that in the NiAlDy sample ( Fig. 2 b). Apart from this, small amount of γ′ phase (marked by the arrows in Fig. 2 b) appeared in the NiAlDy coating near the substrate. This suggests that inward diffusion of Al from the coating to superalloy occurred during annealing. Note that the Ru film as shown in Fig. 1 is invisible and the interface between the film and NiAl coating became ambiguous after 30 h annealing due to interdiffusion between the NiAl coating and Ru film. In our investigation, the diffusion of Ni and Al from the coating to the Ru film results in the formation of (Ru,Ni)Al zone [31] . The (Ru,Ni)Al zone is a miscibility zone between NiAl and RuAl [34] . Like the traditional B2 pint-modified NiAl bond coat, RuAl is a B2-based system stable over a range of composition, but with a melting point over 2000 °C [35] . Partial substitution for Ru by Ni could provide the ability to tailor the properties because the extensive B2 phase field extends from NiAl to RuAl [31] . 3.2 Interdiffusion between the coating and superalloy The morphology of cross-section of the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample after 30 h annealing at 1100 °C is shown in Fig. 3 . The granular TCP phases observed in the IDZ after 2 h annealing are developed into large ellipsoidal phases, growing perpendicularly towards the coating/substrate interface. In the NiAlDy sample, the IDZ reveals a similar morphology to that in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample. However, a large number of finer granular phases are precipitated beneath the IDZ, as shown in Fig. 4 . In addition, more γ′ phases appeared in the NiAlDy coating, suggesting severe inward diffusion of Al from the coating to the superalloy. In order to understand the effect of interdiffusion on the phase evolution in the above samples, the chemical compositions of the areas near or within the IDZ are examined. The chemical compositions of the areas marked in Figs. 3 and 4 are given in Table 2 , respectively. The content of Al at point 5 in the NiAlDy sample (30.83 at.%) is relatively lower than that at point 1 in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample (40.68 at.%). This implies that inward diffusion of Al from the coating to superalloy is faster for the case of NiAlDy sample because the RuNiAl layer effectively suppressed inward diffusion of Al. Besides, the elements such as Cr and Co coming from the superalloy are also found in the coatings. However, the contents of Cr and Co in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating (point 1 in Fig. 3 ) are relatively lower than those in the NiAlDy coating (point 5 in Fig. 4 ). This is because that outward diffusion of elements from the superalloy is also slow down in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample as the RuNiAl layer works as a buffer layer between the coating and superalloy. Correspondingly, in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample the content of Al beneath the IDZ (point 2 in Fig. 3 , ∼8.7 at.%) is relatively lower than that in the NiAlDy sample (point 6 in Fig. 4 , ∼14.2 at.%). This means that less Al diffused to the RuNiAl coated superalloy. In addition, in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample, the content of Ni beneath the IDZ (point 2 in Fig. 3 , ∼70.3 at.%) is a little higher than that in the NiAlDy sample (point 6 in Fig. 4 , 66.7 at.%). In the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample, there is about 2 at.% Ru in the IDZ (point 3 in Fig. 3 ), as a result of inward diffusion of Ru from the RuNiAl layer. Also, according to the EDS analysis of point 4 in Fig. 3 and point 8 in Fig. 4 , the bright ellipsoidal phases (σ-TCP phases) are enriched in Cr, W and Mo. Note that the fine granular phase precipitated in the NiAlDy coated superalloy show similar chemical composition to the ellipsoidal precipitates in the IDZ. Fig. 5 a and b compare the morphologies of the NiAlDy/RuNiAl and NiAlDy samples after 100 h annealing. The amount of γ′ phases in the coatings continuously increased. For the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample, the thickness of IDZ increased to ∼20 μm, as shown in Fig. 5 a. In contrast to this, the IDZ in the NiAlDy sample is even thicker (∼30 μm). Besides, a SRZ with a thickness of ∼50 μm is observed beneath the IDZ, in which some needle-like phases grew towards the internal superalloy with a preferential direction, as shown in Fig. 5 b. The SRZ consists of γ′ matrix containing γ and the needle phase. It should be noted that SRZ is not present in the RuNiAl/NiAlDy sample even after 200 h annealing, as shown in Fig. 6 , indicating that the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating effectively suppressed the formation of SRZ. The microstructure of the needle-like phase observed in Fig. 5 b is investigated by TEM. The needle phase is ∼0.2 μm in width and ∼5 μm in length, as shown in Fig. 7 . The needle-like phase has a tetragonal lattice with the lattice constants of a = 0.89 nm and c = 0.46 nm, which is in agreement with the σ-TCP phase lattice constant ( a = 0.88–0.91 nm, c = 0.45–0.48 nm) [36] . Therefore, it can be inferred that the needle phase is σ-TCP. The composition of the needle is also determined by EDS to have high contents of Cr, W and Mo, as given in Table 3 . SRZ is usually observed under the interdiffusion zone of diffusion aluminide coatings in advanced superalloys containing high levels of refractory elements. The Al activity of the coating and the residual stress state of the coating surface play key role in determining the propensity of a specimen to form SRZ [22] . In our previous work, SRZ was also observed in Ni-based superalloy K403, partially due to inward diffusion of Al from the β-NiAl coating to the superalloy [31,32] . In the present study, severe inward diffusion of Al and outward diffusion of Ni occurred in the NiAlDy coupon. On one hand, the reduction of Ni in the superalloy would cause the precipitation of refractory elements such as W and Ta from the superalloy; on the other hand, Al constantly diffused to the superalloy, dissolved in γ phase, then promoted the phase transformation from γ to γ′, destroyed the γ–γ′ net-like coherent structure, and impelled the refractory element precipitation. Due to these two effects, destabilization of γ–γ′ microstructure in the superalloy happened, which led to the formation of SRZ. In the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coupon, the RuNiAl layer worked as a buffer layer and effectively slowed down interdiffusion between the coating and superalloy. It has been shown that the interdiffusion coefficient of Al in the RuNiAl coupon is lowered by nearly an order of magnitude as compared to that in the NiAl coupon [33] . As a result, the superalloy remained a stable γ–γ′ microstructure and SRZ did not occur even after 200 h annealing. 3.3 Cyclic oxidation kinetics at 1100 °C Cycle oxidation tests were performed in air furnace at 1100 °C and the oxidation kinetics of the coatings are shown in Fig. 8 . The mass gains include both the weights of the coatings and the spallations, while the mass changes only include the weights of the coatings, excluding the weight of the spallations during cyclic oxidation. The NiAlDy sample yielded a weight gain of ∼1.1 mg/cm 2 after 150 h exposure, while the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample yielded a relatively lower weight gain of ∼0.9 mg/cm 2 , as shown in Fig. 8 a. This implies a lower oxidation rate for the latter. From the mass changes as shown in Fig. 8 b, an abrupt mass loss is observed for the NiAlDy sample after about 80 h cyclic oxidation, suggesting an apparent spallation of the oxide scale. In contrast to this, the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coated sample exhibited a very stable mass increase during 150 h cyclic oxidation. According to the cyclic oxidation result, the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating exhibits a better oxidation-resistance than the NiAlDy coating. Fig. 9 compares the XRD patterns of the coatings after 2 h annealing in vacuum at 1050 °C and after 150 h cyclic oxidation at 1100 °C. The annealed coatings are basically composed of β-NiAl phase. After 150 h cyclic oxidation, the RuNiAl/NiAlDy coating mainly consists of β-NiAl, γ′-Ni 3 Al and α-Al 2 O 3 phases. As for the NiAlDy coating, besides those phases detected on the RuNiAl/NiAlDy coating, quite an amount of spinel phases are also detected. In the RuNiAl/NiAlDy coating, only small amount of spinel is detected. The formation of spinel phases is related to depletion of Al in the coating. Fig. 10 a and b compare the surface morphologies of the oxide scales grown on the coatings after 150 h cyclic oxidation at 1100 °C. An intact oxide scale remains on the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating despite a few contaminants are also observed on the coating surface ( Fig. 10 a). In contrast to this, bulk spallation of oxide scale can be visible on the NiAlDy coating. Thus, some naked areas can be seen on the coating ( Fig. 10 b). According to EPMA analysis, the scale grown on the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating is mostly composed of alumina, as seen in Table 4 . The composition analysis of the spalled area in the NiAlDy coating (area B in Fig. 10 b) indicates that there is an amount of elements such as Cr, Co and Ti (Cr: 4.5, Co: 2.5, Ti: 1.2, in at.%) due to outward diffusion of these elements from the superalloy. Also, the elements of about 4.8 at.% Cr, 2.1 at.% Co, 1.0 at.% Ti and 31.8at.% Ni are also detected on the scale remaining on the coating (area C in Fig. 10 b). This implies that some spinel phases are present in the oxide scale, which are also identified by XRD as shown in Fig. 9 . It is also worthy of note that the concentrations of Cr, Co and Ti in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating are much lower than those in the NiAlDy coating because the RuNiAl layer inhibited the migration of refractory elements in the superalloy towards the coating. Actually, small amount of substrate elements such as Hf could be helpful in enhancing oxide scale adherence, but outward diffusion of high levels of substrate elements such as Cr, Ti and Co towards the TGO/bond coat interface could cause weakening of the oxide scale adherence [34,35] . The cross-sections of the scales formed during high-temperatures are also examined. For the NiAlDy coating, the oxide scale is discontinuous due to spallation of the scale during 150 h cyclic oxidation, as shown in Fig. 11 a. Rumpling of the scale is also observed. In addition, a SRZ of ∼40 μm in thickness is formed in the superalloy. As for the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating, a dense, even and continuous oxide scale, with the thickness of 5–8 μm, is visible on the coating, as shown in Fig. 11 b. The scale is intact even after 150 h cyclic oxidation. For the NiAlDy coating, severe interdiffusion between the coating and superalloy substrate occurred at high-temperature. Inward diffusion of Al from the coating to the superalloy cause depletion of Al in the coating, thus leading to degradation of the oxidation-resistance property of the latter [36,37] . Moreover, depletion of Al would promote the phase transformation from β to γ′ in the coating. Unfortunately, such phase change promotes surface rumpling of NiAl coating during thermal cycling [38,39] . For the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample, interdiffusion between the coating and the superalloy is effectively prohibited as the RuNiAl layer acts as a buffer between the NiAlDy layer and superalloy. As a result, more Al is reserved in the NiAlDy layer to sustain the formation of an intact and uniform α-Al 2 O 3 scale at high-temperature. Therefore, the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating exhibits an improved oxidation-resistance property as compared to the NiAlDy coating. 4 Conclusions A novel NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating was deposited onto a Ni-based SC superalloy DD3 by a combination of electroplating and EB-PVD. The cyclic oxidation and interdiffusion behavior of the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating and the NiAlDy coating at 1100 °C were investigated. For the NiAlDy sample, SRZ consisting of a γ′ matrix containing γ and σ-TCP needle phases was formed in the superalloy after 100 h annealing at 1100 °C due to severe inward diffusion of Al from the coating to the superalloy. For the NiAlDy/RuNiAl sample, interdiffusion between the coating and superalloy was effectively suppressed as the RuNiAl layer acted as a buffer. As a result, SRZ did not occur in the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating even after 200 h annealing. On the other hand, the NiAlDy coating showed premature oxide scale spallation after nearly 80 h cyclic oxidation. In contrast to this, an intact oxide scale mostly composed of α-Al 2 O 3 remained on the NiAlDy/RuNiAl coating even after 150 h cyclic oxidation, indicating improved oxidation-resistance property for the coating. Acknowledgements The research is sponsored by National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, No. 50731001 and No. 51071013 ) and National Basic Research Program (973 Program) of China under grant No. 2010CB631200 . References [1] M.J. Pomeroy Coatings for gas turbine materials and long term stability issues Mater. Design 26 2005 223 231 [2] G.W. Goward Progress in coatings for gas turbine airfoils Surf. Coat. Technol. 73 1998 108 109 [3] N. Padture M. Gell E. Jordan Thermal barrier coatings for gas-turbine engine applications Science 296 2002 280 284 [4] A.G. Evans D.R. Mumm J.W. Hutchinson G.H. Meier F.S. Pettit Mechanisms controlling the durability of thermal barrier coatings Prog. Mater. Sci. 46 2001 505 553 [5] T.N. Rhys-Jones Coatings for blade and vane applications in gas turbines Corros. Sci. 29 1989 623 646 [6] W.Z. Li Y.Q. Li Q.M. Wang C. Sun X. Jiang Oxidation of a NiCrAlYSi overlayer with or without a diffusion barrier deposited by one-step arc ion plating Corros. Sci. 52 2010 1753 1761 [7] P.Y. Hou V.K. Tolpygo Examination of the platinum effect on the oxidation behavior of nickel-aluminide coatings Surf. Coat. Technol. 202 2007 623 627 [8] H.B. Guo L.D. Sun H.F. Li S.K. Gong High temperature oxidation behavior of hafnium modified NiAl bond coat in EB-PVD thermal barrier coating system Thin Solid Films 516 2008 5732 5735 [9] B.A. Pint The oxidation behavior of oxide-dispersed β-NiAl: I. short-term performance at 1200 C Oxid. Met. 49 1998 531 559 [10] C.A. Barrett Effect of 0.1 at.% zirconium on the cyclic oxidation resistance of β-NiAl Oxid. Met. 30 1988 361 390 [11] H. Svensson M. Christensen P. Knutsson G. Wahnström K. Stiller Influence of Pt on the metal – oxide interface during high temperature oxidation of NiAl bulk materials Corros. Sci. 51 2009 539 546 [12] D. Prajitno B. Gleeson D.J. Young The cyclic oxidation behavior of a α-Cr+ β-NiAl alloys with and without trace Zr addition Corros. Sci. 39 1997 639 654 [13] C. Leyens B.A. Pint I.G. Wright Effect of composition on the oxidation and hot corrosion resistance of NiAl doped with precious metals Surf. Coat. Technol. 133/134 2000 15 22 [14] R. Yu P.Y. Hou First-principles calculations of the effect of Pt on NiAl surface energy and the site preference of Pt Appl. Phys. Lett. 91 2007 011907 [15] G.Y. Zhang H. Zhang J.T. Guo Improvement of cyclic oxidation resistance of a NiAl-based alloy modified by Dy Surf. Coat. Technol. 201 2006 2270 2275 [16] H.B. Guo X.Y. Wang J. Li S.X. Wang S.K. Gong Effects of Dy on cyclic oxidation resistance of NiAl alloy T. Nonferr. Metal. Soc. 19 2009 1185 1189 [17] B.A. Pint I.G. Wright W.Y. Lee Substrate and bond coat compositions: factors affecting alumina scale adhesion Mater. Sci. Eng. A 245 1998 201 211 [18] H.B. Guo S.X. Wang X.Y. Wang S.K. Gong Cyclic oxidation behaviors of EB-PVD Dy doped β-NiAl coatings at 1100 °C Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 24 2010 3143 3148 [19] H.B. Guo D.Q. Li H. Peng Y.J. Cui S.K. Gong High-temperature oxidation and hot-corrosion behavior of EB-PVD β-NiAlDy coatings Corros. Sci. 53 2011 1050 1059 [20] J. Angenete K. Stiller E. Bakchinova Microstructural and microchemical development of simple and Pt-modified aluminide diffusion coatings during long term oxidation at 1050 °C Surf. Coat. Technol. 176 2004 272 283 [21] J.H. Chen J.A. Little Degradation of the platinum aluminide coating on CMSX4 at 1100 °C Surf. Coat. Technol. 92 1997 69 77 [22] W.S. Walston J.C. Schaefter W.H. Murphy A new type of microstructure instability in superalloy-SRZ R.D. Kissinger Superalloys 1996 TMS 9 18 [23] D.K. Das K.S. Murphy S.W. Ma T.M. Pollock Formation of secondary reaction zones in diffusion aluminide-coated Ni-base single-crystal superalloys containing ruthenium Metall. Mater. Trans. A 39 2008 1647 1657 [24] B. Tryon Q. Feng T. Pollock Intermetallic phases formed by ruthenium-nickel alloy, interdiffusion Intermetallics 12 2004 957 962 [25] B. Tryon T.M. Pollock M.F.X. Gigliotti K. Hemker Thermal expansion behavior of ruthenium aluminides Scripta Mater. 50 2004 845 848 [26] P.J. Bellina A. Catanoiu F.M. Morales M. Rühle Formation of discontinuous Al 2 O 3 layers during high-temperature oxidation of RuAl alloys J. Mater. Res. 21 2006 276 286 [27] B. Tryon F. Cao K.S. Murphy C.G. Levi T.M. Pollock Ruthenium-containing bond coats for thermal barrier coating systems JOM 58 2006 53 59 [28] M.S.A. Karunaratne C.M.F. Rae R.C. Reed On the microstructural instability of an experimental nickel-base superalloy Metall. Mater. Trans. A 32 2001 2409 2421 [29] R.A. Hobbs L. Zhang C.M.F. Rae S. Tin Mechanisms of topologically close-packed phase suppression in an experimental ruthenium-bearing single-crystal nickel-base superalloy at 1100 °C Metall. Mater. Trans. A 39 2008 1014 1025 [30] B. Tryon K.S. Murphy J.Y. Yang C.G. Levi T.M. Pollock Hybrid intermetallic Ru/Pt-modified bond coatings for thermal barrier systems Surf. Coat. Technol. 202 2007 349 361 [31] Y. Wang H.B. Guo H. Peng S.K. Gong Diffusion barrier behaviors of (Ru, Ni)Al/NiAl coatings on Ni-based superalloy substrate Intermetallics 191 2011 191 195 [32] Y. Wang, H.B. Guo, L.Q. Peng, S.K. Gong, Processing and microstructure of NiRuAl diffusion barrier coating on Ni-based superalloy, Surf. Eng., DOI: 10.1179/174329409X446359 . [33] Y. Wang, Manufacturing and diffusion barrier behavior of EB-PVD RuNiAl coating [D], Beihang University, 2009. [34] U. Schulz M. MenZebach C. Leyens Y.Q. Yang Influence of substrate material on oxidation behavior, cyclic lifetime of EB-PVD TBC systems Surf. Coat. Technol. 117 2001 146 147 [35] H.B. Guo Y.J. Cui H. Peng S.K. Gong Improved cyclic oxidation resistance of electron beam physical vapor deposited nano-oxide dispersed β-NiAl coatings for Hf-containing superalloy Corros. Sci. 52 2010 1440 1446 [36] B.M. Warnes D.C. Punola Clean diffusion coatings by chemical vapor deposition Surf. Coat. Technol. 94–95 1997 1 6 [37] M.H. Li Z.Y. Zhang X.F. Sun Oxidation and degradation of EB-PVD thermal-barrier coating Oxid. Met. 58 5–6 2002 499 512 [38] V.K. Tolpygo D.R. Clarke Surface rumpling of a (Ni, Pt)Al bond coat induced by cyclic oxidation Acta Mater. 48 2000 3283 3293 [39] Y. Zhang J.A. Haynes B.A. Pint I.G. Wright W.Y. Lee Martensitic transformation in CVD NiAl and (Ni, Pt)Al bond coatings Surf. Coat. Technol. 163/164 2003 19 24