Performance of temperature and humidity independent control air-conditioning system in an office building
Kang Zhao,Xiao-Hua Liu,Tao Zhang,y w jiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2011.03.041
IF: 7.201
2011-01-01
Energy and Buildings
Abstract:The temperature and humidity independent control (THIC) system, which controls indoor temperature and moisture separately, may be an attractive alternative to existing conventional HVAC systems for its prominent improvement on the overall system performance and utilization of low grade energy resources. In order to verify the effectiveness of THIC system, a pilot project has been implemented in an office building in Shenzhen, China. In the system, liquid desiccant fresh air handling units driven by heat pumps are utilized to remove the entire latent load of outdoor air supplied for the whole building, and chilled water at the temperature of 17.5 °C from chiller is pumped and distributed into dry fan coil units and radiant panels to control indoor temperature. This paper presents the results of field test of the system, which shows that the system can provide a comfortable indoor environment even in very hot and humid weather. The COP of the entire THIC system can reach 4.0. According to the energy usage data recorded from the year 2009, the energy consumption of the THIC system in the tested office building was 32.2 kWh/(m 2 yr), which demonstrates magnificent energy-saving potential compared with the conventional air-conditioning system (around 49 kWh/(m 2 yr)). Keywords THIC (temperature and humidity independent control) Dehumidification Cooling Performance Air conditioning Nomenclature COP air coefficient of performance of the fresh air unit COP CH coefficient of performance of the chiller COP hum coefficient of performance of a set of humidity control subsystem COP HUM coefficient of performance of the humidity control subsystem COP TEMP coefficient of performance of the temperature control subsystem COP SYS coefficient of performance of the THIC system TC CT transport coefficient of the cooling tower TC CTP transport coefficient of the cooling water pump TC CWP transport coefficient of the chilled water pump TC fan transport coefficient of the fans in the humidity control subsystem TC FCU transport coefficient of indoor FCUs P air input power of the compressors and pumps inside the fresh air units P CH input power of the compressors of the chiller P CT input power of the cooling tower P CTP input power of the cooling water pump P CWP input power of the chilled water pump P fan input power of the fans in the humidity control subsystem P FCU input power of the fan coil units Q air cooling capacity of the fresh air unit Q CH cooling capacity of the temperature control subsystem 1 Introduction In the conventional HVAC system that removes moisture by condensation, air is cooled and dehumidified simultaneously. In most cases, sensible load of building covers the majority part of the whole cooling load while the latent load (moisture load) takes only a small part. However, as the required cooling source temperature of dehumidification is much lower than that of cooling, the chilled water temperature has to be reduced to meet the demand for condensation dehumidification. Moreover, the ratio of sensible load to latent load varies largely due to the changes of outdoor climate, number variance of indoor occupants, indoor equipments and lighting utilization mode and so on. Therefore, the indoor temperature and humidity, the two key parameters, can hardly be satisfied with condensation by the cooling coil only. In practice, the common reaction to the increased humidity is to reduce the set-point temperature and then re-condition the air after passing the cooling coil to the proper temperature, which results in a plenty of energy wastefulness [1] . To avoid the aforementioned problems, temperature and humidity independent control (THIC) air-conditioning system stands out as an appropriate pattern that temperature and humidity can be regulated independently with temperature control subsystem and humidity control subsystem respectively. Besides, the coil temperature for cooling in the temperature control subsystem can be considerably increased, e.g. from current 7 °C to 17 °C, so that improvement on the performance of chillers or even free cooling from ambient could be obtained. Many investigations have been carried out on the hybrid desiccant dehumidification and air-conditioning system [1–4] , which integrates liquid/solid desiccant units with a conventional cooling system to avoid excess cooling. Liquid desiccant units developed quickly in recent years, for its advantages of dehumidifying at a temperature higher than the air's dew-point to avoid reheat procedure in the system, and regenerating desiccant at a low temperature which can be driven by low-grade heat sources [5,6] . Many studies focusing on improving its performance with process optimization have been conducted in depth, such as Yadav [7] , DryKor Ltd. [8] , and Liu et al. [9] . Chen et al. [10] designed an independent dehumidification air-conditioning system with a hot water-driven liquid desiccant and a chiller that provides 18–21 °C chilled water for an office building in Beijing, which saved about 30% cooling cost compared with conventional system. The performance of a hybrid system tested by Ma et al. [11] was 44.5% higher than conventional vapor compression system at a latent load of 30% and this improving could be achieved by 73.8% at a 42% latent load. Besides, the specific research on the feasibility and performance of the hybrid system in hot and humid regions is promoted [12,13] . This paper will investigate the real operating performance of a THIC air-conditioning system operated in an office building located in Shenzhen, a modern metropolis in southern China of hot and humid climate. In this THIC system, the liquid desiccant fresh air handling units driven by heat pumps are employed to handle the outdoor air to remove the entire latent load and supply enough fresh air to the occupied spaces, and the high-temperature chiller that produces chilled water of 17.5 °C for the indoor terminal devices (radiant panels and dry fan coil units) is applied to control indoor temperature. The operating principle and performance test results of the THIC system will be shown in this paper, and suggestion for performance improvement will also be included. 2 Description of the THIC system in an office building The THIC system has been put into practice as a pilot project in an office building in Shenzhen, China. This system has been brought into operation in July 2008 and the basic information about the building and air-conditioning system goes as follows. 2.1 Basis information The 5-story office building, as shown in Fig. 1 , is located in Shenzhen, China, with total building area of 21,960 m 2 and the areas of 5940 m 2 , 5045 m 2 , 3876 m 2 , 3908 m 2 , 3191 m 2 for the 1st to 5th floor respectively. The main function of the 1st floor is restaurant, archive and carport, the 2nd to 4th floors are the office rooms, the 5th floor is the meeting room, and there is a vestibule vertically through up the 2nd to 4th floors in the north of the building. In the vestibule, curtain wall with ventilation shutters in the upper is applied on its north surface, as shown in Fig. 2 . The outdoor condition in Shenzhen is rather hot and humid all through the year as shown in Fig. 3 . The annual outdoor air relative humidity is about 80% and humidity ratio in summer is as high as 20 g/(kg dry air). The building requires cooling and dehumidification in a long period of time, and no heating and humidification requirement in winter. Therefore, how to handle the moisture efficiently is a key issue in such a subtropical area. 2.2 THIC air-conditioning system The THIC system serves from 1st to 4th floor with the net air-conditioning area of 13,180 m 2 (total area of 18,769 m 2 ), and the 5th floor is served by several stand-alone air conditioners so that is not within the scope of our discussion. The schematic of the THIC system is shown in Fig. 4 with the main devices’ parameters listed in Table 1 . The right side of Fig. 4 is the humidity control subsystem, including 9 liquid desiccant fresh air handling units that supply adequate dry fresh air into the occupied spaces. As the volume of the supplied fresh air is proportional to the number of people, the pollutants, CO 2 and latent heat produced by human bodies can be removed by fresh air. The schematic of the fresh air processors using liquid desiccant is illustrated in Fig. 5 (a) , which is composed of a two-stage total heat recovery device and a two-stage air handling device coupled with refrigeration cycles. Lithium bromide (LiBr) aqueous solution is employed as liquid desiccant in these air processors. The total heat recovery device is used to recover the energy from indoor exhaust air (return air) to decrease the energy consumption in the fresh air handling process. And in the heat pump driven air handling device, the diluted solution from the dehumidification modules is heated by the exhaust heat from the condenser and concentrated in the regeneration modules, then the hot concentrated solution is cooled by passing through the heat exchanger and evaporator before it enters the dehumidification modules, and lastly used to remove moisture from the fresh air. To make it clear, the air-handling processes are displayed in the air psychrometric chart in Fig. 5 (b) where the fresh air first passes the total heat recovery device to recovery the energy from the indoor exhaust air, and then flows into the dehumidification modules to be further dehumidified and cooled before it is supplied into the occupied spaces. In general, the COP of the liquid desiccant fresh air units (total heat removed from the fresh air divided by the power consumption of the heat pumps and solution pumps) can be as high as 5.0 with the following three main reasons: (1) the cooling capacity of the indoor exhaust air is fully exploited to remove heat from the fresh air by the total heat recovery device; (2) both the cooling capacity from evaporator and exhaust heat from condenser are utilized to enhance the air handling processes; and (3) the efficiency of the heat pump is significantly raised since the required evaporating temperature in this liquid desiccant device is much higher than that in the conventional condensing dehumidification system. Besides, as indicated in Fig. 5 (b), the supplied air temperature is lower than the indoor air temperature, so the liquid desiccant system can remove some sensible load of the building as well as the entire latent load. The left side of Fig. 4 is the temperature control subsystem that takes up the rest sensible load to control indoor temperature, including a high-temperature chiller, cooling tower, cooling water pump, chilled water pump, and indoor terminal devices (radiant panels and dry fan coil units). The high-temperature chiller is a centrifugal chiller with the rated COP of 8.3 (designed condition: the inlet and outlet temperature of the chilled water and cooling water are 20.5 °C/17.5 °C and 30.0 °C/35.0 °C respectively), which is much higher than the conventional chiller operating at the chilled water temperature of 12 °C/7 °C. As for indoor terminal devices, as shown in Fig. 6 , fan coil units (FCUs) operating in ‘dry condition’ are set up in the restaurant, archive and office regions which serve about 81% of the entire cooling load of the temperature control subsystem, while radiant floor and radiant ceiling panels are applied in vestibule and some office rooms which serve the rest 19%. In the previous sections, the whole THIC system layout has been introduced briefly. Particularly, stratified air conditioning, a key design principle of large space, is selected in the air-conditioning design of the vestibule as shown in Fig. 2 (b). Specifically, in the occupied zone (the height within 2 m), chilled water with temperature of 17.5 °C is pumped and distributed into radiant floor for cooling, and the handled dry fresh air and indoor exhaust air are supplied and expelled in the bottom and in the middle of the space respectively, which forms a “dry air layer” to protect the cold floor surface from condensation; in the higher space that far from occupied zone, solar radiation that enters through glass curtain wall is absorbed by the ornamental decorations in the higher space, and the heat is then carried away by natural ventilation through the shutters directly. The temperature control subsystem and humidity control subsystem can be operated separately according to ambient condition and indoor requirement. • The two subsystems operate together at hot and humid outdoor climate; • Only the humidity control subsystem operates at cold but humid ambient condition; • Outdoor air is directly introduced into occupied spaces after filtering when outdoor air is dry enough, such as 11 g/kg. 3 Performance test of the THIC system 3.1 Indoor thermal environment Fig. 7 shows the tested results of indoor temperatures, humidity ratios and CO 2 concentrations with the outdoor temperature and relative humidity of 34.9 °C and 61% respectively. As indicated by the figure, the THIC system could provide a comfortable indoor environment with suitable thermal condition and good indoor air quality. Fig. 8 depicts the tested temperatures and humidity ratios along the vertical direction in the vestibule. In the occupied zone (the height within 2 m), the temperature and humidity ratio were about 26 °C and 12 g/kg respectively which meet human thermal comfort well. Both the temperature and humidity ratio increased fast along the vertical direction, which reached about 30 °C and 20 g/kg respectively at the height of 10 m. And the peak temperature at upper space (over 7 m) occurred at noon, due to the strong solar radiation and high ambient temperature. According to the test results, the THIC system applied in large space is effective on energy-saving, which only keeps the occupied zone in comfort condition and forms apparent stratification of indoor temperature and humidity ratio along the vertical direction. Moreover, the natural ventilation from the shutters contributed to remove the absorbed heat of decorations to outdoor environment. 3.2 Energy efficiency of the THIC system The field test of the energy efficiency of the THIC system was conducted both under the partial load condition and very hot and humid outdoor condition. The former one is on May 27th, 2009, with ambient temperature of 29.3 °C and relative humidity of 79% (absolute humidity 20.3 g/kg), and the latter one is on July 16th, 2009, with ambient temperature of 34.9 °C and relative humidity of 61% (absolute humidity 21.6 g/kg). The measurement was divided into two parts: humidity control subsystem and temperature control subsystem. 3.2.1 Energy efficiency of humidity control subsystem The performances of the liquid desiccant fresh air units were tested one by one on May 27th, 2009, according to the measured flow rates, air inlet and outlet parameters through the processor and input power of compressors, solution pumps and fans. The tested results of seven fresh air units are summarized in Table 2 ; the other two processors are neglected due to the difficult of installing the measuring sensors. The east side processor of the 2nd floor is a typical example for the fresh air unit, and its specific operation information is shown in Table 3 . The fresh air flow rate was 5059 m 3 /h, the outdoor air parameter was 29.3 °C and 20.3 g/kg, and the supply air parameter was 17.1 °C and 6.2 g/kg. So the cooling capacity ( Q air ), calculated by energy balance equation, was 82.6 kW. The input power of compressors and solution pumps ( P air ) inside the processor was 17.8 kW, and the input power of the supply air and exhaust air fans ( P fan ) was 2.2 kW. Therefore, the performance of the fresh air unit ( COP air ), the transport coefficient of fans ( TC fan ) and the performance of the entire humidity handling process ( COP hum ), as shown in Eqs. (1)–(3) , are 4.7, 37.5 and 4.2 respectively. (1) C O P air = Q air P air (2) T C fan = Q air P fan (3) C O P hum = Q air P air + P fan As shown in Table 2 , the COP air of the tested seven fresh air units are in the range of 4.4–4.9, the TC fan of the fans are 35–40, and the COP hum of the entire humidity handling processes are 4.0–4.4. According to the test data of May 27th, 2009 and rated parameters of the fresh air units and fans, the calculated cooling capacity of the entire humidity control subsystem is 773.0 kW with total inside compressors and solution pumps input power of 166.9 kW and total fans input power of 20.0 kW, so the coefficient of performance of the humidity control subsystem ( COP HUM ), shown in Eq. (4) , is 4.1. (4) C O P HUM = ∑ Q air ∑ ( P air + P fan ) Similarly, on the basis of the test data of July 16th, 2009, the COP HUM under the design condition is 4.1, with the calculated cooling capacity of 915.0 kW, total inside compressors and solution pumps input power of 194.4 kW and total fans input power of 25.1 kW. 3.2.2 Energy efficiency of temperature control subsystem The performances of the chiller, cooling tower, cooling and chilled water pumps and indoor dry FCUs were measured, according to the measured flow rates, water inlet and outlet parameters through the chiller and input powers of above facilities. The tested results of each device are listed in Table 4 . According to the test data under the partial load condition (May 27th), the calculated cooling capacity of the temperature control subsystem ( Q CH ) is 446.1 kW with total input power of 120.8 kW, so the COP of the temperature control subsystem ( COP TEMP ), shown in Eq. (5) , is 3.7. As well, the COP TEMP under the very hot and humid condition (July 16th) is 4.1, with the calculated cooling capacity of 543.4 kW and total input power of 133.6 kW. (5) C O P TEMP = Q CH P CH + P CT + P CTP + P CWP + P FCU 3.2.3 Energy efficiency of the entire THIC system The entire load of the building is composed of the latent load and sensible load. The former is both the moisture introduced by fresh air and released by respiration and perspiration of occupants and indoor plants, and the latter is the caused by the ventilation, heat transfer, solar radiation, heat dissipation of devices and activity of occupants, etc., as illustrated in Fig. 9 . In the THIC system, processed outdoor air is used to remove the entire latent load and part of the sensible load, while cooling plant provides high temperature chilled water to remove the rest sensible load. By calculation, under the partial load condition, the humidity control subsystem removed 63% of entire cooling load with 61% environmental control energy consumption, and the temperature control subsystem removed the rest 37% load with the rest 39% energy consumption. Similar conclusion also can emerge from the test results in the very hot and humid outdoor condition. Calculated from the above tested data, the overall COP of the THIC system ( COP SYS ) under partial load and very hot and humid outdoor climate are 4.0 and 4.1 respectively, as shown in Eq. (6) . (6) C O P SYS = Q CH + ∑ Q air ( P CH + P CT + P CTP + P CWP + P FCU ) + ∑ ( P air + P fan ) Based on the test results of these two typical operating conditions, it is convinced that the THIC system in this office building has achieved a high efficiency with its total COP more than 4.0. For the conventional air-conditioning system, such as fan coil unit plus fresh air supply system or all air system, the measured average coefficient of performance of whole system is lower than 3.0 [14] . Therefore, there is a remarkable energy efficiency improvement of the THIC system comparing with the conventional system. 3.3 Energy consumption of the THIC system Energy consumption of the THIC system is measured by the power metering monitoring system. Fig. 10 shows the monthly power consumption of the system from 15th April, 2009 to 15th October, 2009 (apart from weekends and statutory holidays). The total energy consumption was 425 MWh during the air-conditioning season, and the humidity control subsystem occupied 61% of the total power consumption which was proportional to the ratio of cooling load that the humidity control subsystem took up. The energy consumption in unit building area and unit net air-conditioning area of the tested THIC system were 22.6 kWh/(m 2 yr) and 32.2 kWh/(m 2 yr) respectively. However, the average energy consumption levels of office building of the similar building envelope and occupant density during the same time in Shenzhen are around 42 kWh/(m 2 yr) and 49 kWh/(m 2 yr) respectively according to the investigated results by Zi [15] . Therefore, the THIC system in this office building achieves noticeable energy saving compared with the conventional air-conditioning system. The initial cost of THIC system is about 10–20% higher than conventional fan coil unit plus outdoor air process system, and the added cost can be recalled within about two years. 4 Discussion According to our knowledge, cooling air can be realized more easily than dehumidification by condensation, since the latter one requires lower temperature of cooling source than the former. However, the COP of the tested temperature control subsystem is lower than or equal to that of the humidity control subsystem in present THIC system. Thus, this section will focus on how to improve the performance of the temperature control subsystem. According to the performance of each component in the temperature control subsystem shown in Table 4 , three main improvements of the temperature control subsystem are recommended: (1) modifying the frequency of the chilled water pump; (2) improving the cooling tower performance by tightening the strap; and (3) improving the performance of FCUs under dry working condition. The first two methods can be easily realized in the building, while the third one depends on the improvement of new FCU products. 4.1 Improve the performance of chilled water pump As indicated in Fig. 9 (b) and Table 4 , the power consumption of the chilled water pump was near 60% of the chiller. It is because the variable-speed pump has operated at 50 Hz in the past that the chiller temperature difference of the inlet and outlet chilled water is only 1.6–1.8 °C, while the designed value is 3.0 °C. Therefore, the power consumption of the chilled water pump can be considerably cut down after reducing the chilled water flow rate by frequency regulation. For instance, the energy savings of the chilled water pump could be up to 40%, if the transport coefficient of chilled water pump ( TC CWP ) is increased from the current 14.6–18.5 to the empirical value of 25. 4.2 Improve the performance of cooling tower According to Table 4 , the transport efficient of cooling tower ( TC CT ) was near 140, which was lower than the empirical index of 200. Detailed performance test is then launched. For the cooling tower, the mass flow rate ratio of air to water was 0.55, with air flow rate of 99,620 kg/h and water flow rate of 180,000 kg/h, and the temperatures of inlet water, outlet water and outdoor air wet bulb were 35.6 °C, 32.9 °C and 28.3 °C respectively. Hence, the efficiency of the cooling tower (the temperature variance of the cooling water divided by the possible maximal temperature variance) was (35.6 − 32.9)/(35.6 − 28.3) = 37%. By field survey, the low air flow rate, which led to low efficiency of the cooling tower, was caused by the loose strap of fan. The energy consumption of the cooling tower in the entire air-conditioning system is relatively small, but it seriously influences the chiller performance by affecting the condensing temperature. The expected efficiency of the cooling tower can be higher than 55% if the air flow rate increases to about 180,000 kg/h, and thus the condensing temperature can decrease at least 2 °C. As a result, the COP of the chiller ( COP CH ) can be increased from current 8.5 to 9.3. 4.3 Improve the performance of FCU As the chilled water inlet temperature is higher than the indoor dew point temperature in this THIC system, fan coil units that operate under dry working condition are put into use in this building to remove large part of the sensible load of the building. At present, the configuration of the adopted dry FCUs is similar to the originally wet FCUs (with standard chilled water inlet temperature of 7 °C and transport coefficient of 50). However, the tested transport coefficient of the dry FCUs ( TC FCU ) was around 20, as shown in Table 4 . Factually, the configuration of dry FCUs should be rather different from wet FCUs, since condensing water no longer exists in dry FCUs, and some dry FCUs with new configuration have appeared with TC FCU close to 50. So there is a huge potential to improve the performance of dry FCU with the transport coefficient increased to around 40. The contribution of the above three improvements to the temperature control subsystem is summarized in Table 5 . And the expected COP TEMP and COP SYS can be increased to 4.8 and 4.4 respectively after these alterations. Therefore, the energy consumption of the altered temperature control subsystem can save 23% compared to present situation, and the entire THIC system can save 9% compared to its performance at present. 5 Conclusion The operating performance of the THIC system in an office building in Shenzhen is presented in this paper. Liquid desiccant fresh air units are used to supply dry fresh air to control indoor humidity, and chilled water with the temperature of 17.5 °C is pumped and distributed into radiant panels and dry fan coil units to control indoor temperature. The followings are the conclusions based on the tested results: (1) The THIC system can provide a comfortable indoor environment that indoor temperatures, humidity ratios as well as CO 2 concentrations are all within the comfortable ranges. (2) The COP of the entire THIC system can reach 4.0, with the COP of the temperature control subsystem and humidity control subsystem of 3.7–4.1 and 4.1 respectively. The energy consumption of the THIC system in the tested office building is 32.2 kWh/(m 2 yr) (net air-conditioning area), that is, the energy efficiency is much higher than that of the conventional air-conditioning system available in literature. (3) Possible improvements of the temperature control subsystem are provided, including modification on the chilled water pump, cooling tower and FCUs. Thus, the expected system COP can be further increased to 4.4, which can save 9% compared to present air-conditioning system. Acknowledgements The research described in this paper was supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51006058 ) and the foundation for the author of National Excellent Doctoral Dissertation of China . The authors appreciate the valuable help from Mr. Qiang Bin and Mr. Yang Haibo in Shenzhen. References [1] D.G. Waugaman A. Kini C.F. Kettleborough A review of desiccant cooling systems Journal of Energy Resources Technology 115 1 1993 1 8 [2] T.A. Ameel K.G. Gee B.D. Wood Performance predictions of alternative, low cost absorbents for open-cycle absorption solar cooling Solar Energy 54 2 1995 65 73 [3] C.S.K. Ahmed P. Gandhisan A.A. Al-Farayedhi Simulation of a hybrid liquid desiccant based air-conditioning system Applied Thermal Engineering 17 2 1997 125 134 [4] C.H. Liang L.Z. Zhang L.X. Pei Independent air dehumidification with membrane-based total heat recovery: modeling and experimental validation Journal of Refrigeration 33 2 2010 398 408 [5] S. Patnaik T.G. Lenz G.O.G. Löf Performance studies for an experimental solar open-cycle liquid desiccant air dehumidification system Solar Energy 44 3 1990 123 135 [6] Y.G. Yin X.S. Zhang Z.Q. Chen Experimental study on dehumidifier and regenerator of liquid desiccant cooling air conditioning system Building and Environment 42 7 2007 2505 2511 [7] Y.K. Yadav Vapour-compression and liquid-desiccant hybrid solar space-conditioning system for energy conservation Renewable Energy 6 7 1995 719 723 [8] DryKor Ltd. Beyond air conditioning – our dry air is cool Illustrative Brochure 2001 DryKor Ltd. [9] X.H. Liu Z. Li Y. Jiang B.R. Lin Annual performance of liquid desiccant based independent humidity control HVAC system Applied Thermal Engineering 26 11–12 2006 1198 1207 [10] X.Y. Chen Z. Li Y. Jiang K.Y. Qu Field study on independent dehumidification air-conditioning system – II. Performance of the whole system ASHRAE Transactions 111 2 2005 277 284 [11] Q. Ma R.Z. Wang Y.J. Dai X.Q. Zhai Performance analysis on a hybrid air-conditioning system of a green building Energy and Buildings 38 5 2006 447 453 [12] J.L. Niu L.Z. Zhang H.G. Zuo Energy savings potential of chilled-ceiling combined with desiccant cooling in hot and humid climates Energy and Buildings 34 5 2002 487 495 [13] Y. Li K. Sumathy Y.J. Dai J.H. Zhong R.Z. Wang Experimental study on a hybrid desiccant dehumidification and air conditioning system Journal of Solar Energy Engineering 128 1 2006 77 82 [14] AQSIQ, SAC. GB/T 17981-2007 Economic Operation of Air Conditioning Systems 2008 China Standards Press Beijing [15] X.Q. Zi Diagnosis of energy efficiency and study on solutions for the air conditioning of the high-rise comprehensive office building in Shenzhen 2007 Master thesis, Chongqing University Chongqing