Abstract:In emerging markets characterized by weak institutions, the expropriation of minority shareholders by large shareholders is the primary concern in corporate governance. One important way to indurate the protection of minority shareholder rights is the implementation of cumulative voting (CV) scheme for board election. China carried out an experiment of regulatory reform to introduce the CV rule to many listed companies in China. In 2002, the Chinese Securities Regulatory Commission released the "Code of Corporate Governance for Listed Companies'', aiming to elevate minority shareholder rights and to improve corporate governance. In this paper, based on our unique hand-collected data set, we investigate whether the use of CV has substantial effects on board composition and the characteristics of elected board directors, corporate policies and further on firm value. To mitigate the "endogeneity'' or "self-selection'' problem, this paper adopts matching methods to construct control groups and conduct DID style analysis to further reduce econometrical confoundedness. To increase the robustness of our main empirical results, we employ two different matching methods (Barber and Lyon method and "Coarsened exact matching'' method) to construct two samples. To assess the efficacy of the implementation of CV, we examine whether the directors elected via CV are different from those elected via straight voting in terms of personal characteristics of directors including their education qualifications, professional experiences (accountant, lawyer, engineer, economist, etc.), managerial experiences (CEO/chairman experiences), work experiences in the same industry, and political connections (former central, or local government officials). We find that the proportion of directors as representatives of the second largest shareholder significantly increases under the CV rule based on a clean subsample where the top ten shareholders are unrelated. We also find that the implementation of CV has created some positive changes in the quality of directors and the "independence'' of independent directors. But the incremental improvements are not significant enough to curb tunneling activities and generate substantial positive effects on firm performance. Our findings imply that the CV reform has achieved some success, bringing some positive changes to corporate boards, but the success is still limited to a large degree. The broad institutional and legal environment in China remains weak, which imposes constraints on the functioning of the reform scheme.

Optimized Design of Voting Mechanism in Corporate Governance

The Effects of Corporate Governance on Innovation in Chinese Firms ∗

The Analysis and Enhancement of Voting Behaviors in P2P Networks

Ownership Structure,Resolution Mechanism and Control Right of Listed Companies

Voting Efficiency and the Even-Odd Effects of Corporate Board : Theory and Evidence

Corporate Governance for Sustainable Development: A Study on Mechanism Configuration

On Voting Trust

Does Cumulative Voting Matter? The Case of China: An Empirical Assessment

Does regulatory reform of cumulative voting promote a more balanced power distribution in the boardroom?

Regulatory Reform of Cumulative Voting in Corporate China: Who Were Elected and its Impacts

The Governance Mechanism for Chinese Listed Companies' Based on Double Principal-Agent Model HuiWang

Shareholder Voting: A Complementary Mechanism to Mandatory Disclosure Regulation

Mechanism Analysis and Path Study of Digital Transformation on Corporate Governance: Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies

Does Independent Director Protect Rights and Interests of Small and Medium Shareholders?——Research on Voting Mechanisms of Chinese Listed Companies

Shareholder's Voting Right: The Connecting Point between Corporate Ownership and Corporate Controlling

Political Connection and the Effectiveness of Corporate Governance——Based on the Security Irregularities Data of Listed Companies

Does Corporate Governance Enhance Common Interests of Shareholders and Primary Stakeholders?

Orchestrating Organizational Politics: Baron and Ferejohn Meet Tullock *

Corporate Harmony,Stakeholders Governance and Corporate Performance

Corporate Governance and Market Valuation in China

Coordinated Co-governance and Grassroots Innovation: A Case Study of Shenzhen’s Livelihood-Related Project Voting System