Analysis of World-class Discipline Evaluation Indicators for World University Ranking

Zhu Ming,Yang Xiaojiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3963/j.issn.1672-8742.2012.02.002
2012-01-01
Abstract:Systematic research on discipline evaluation is basically a virgin ground in China,especially the study of world-class discipline evaluation.All these fail to meet the needs of scientific and technological innovation,management decision-making,scientific evaluation,university establishment and so on.By comparatively studying five famous discipline rankings such as THE,USNWR,CHE,RAE,CWCU and comprehensively analyzing their disciplinary evaluation indicators,this paper emphatically probes into how to scientifically design a set of the evaluation indicators for world-class discipline.For the convenience of scientific evaluation,this paper selects some comprehensive indicators,which can measure the discipline′s level and are accepted at home and abroad.Meanwhile,quantitative indicators should match qualitative indicators.Besides,the paper pays great attention to some valuable questions such as time delay,research originality,discipline's balance between its material and spiritual sense.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?